Development of the Atomic Model

Development of the Atomic Model

Spec 4.1.1.3 · AQA GCSE Chemistry: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Dalton (1808): atoms are indivisible solid spheres. Thomson's electron disproved it.
  • Thomson (1897): the plum pudding model, with electrons embedded in positive charge.
  • Rutherford (1909): alpha particle scattering showed a tiny, dense, positive nucleus in mostly empty space.
  • Bohr (1913): electrons orbit in fixed shells at specific distances. Chadwick (1932) discovered the neutron.
  • Scientific models change when new experimental evidence becomes available.
  1. 1808

    Dalton

    Solid, indivisible spheres.

  2. 1897

    Thomson

    Plum pudding: electrons in positive charge.

  3. 1909

    Rutherford

    A tiny dense nucleus, from alpha scattering.

  4. 1913

    Bohr

    Electrons in fixed shells.

  5. 1932

    Chadwick

    The neutron completes the nucleus.

Dalton's solid sphere

John Dalton proposed that all matter is made of tiny, indivisible solid spheres called atoms. It explained reactions as the rearranging of atoms.

John Dalton (1808) proposed the first scientific atomic model:

  • Each element has identical atoms.
  • Atoms of different elements have different masses.
  • Atoms cannot be created, destroyed or changed into other atoms.
  • Compounds form when atoms combine in simple whole-number ratios.

This explained chemical reactions as rearrangements of atoms. The key limitation is that atoms are indivisible in his model: we now know they have internal structure.

Solid sphere

Dalton's solid sphere model.

What was the key limitation of Dalton's model?

Thomson's plum pudding

Thomson found that atoms contain negative electrons, so atoms are not solid or indivisible. He proposed the plum pudding model.

J.J. Thomson (1897) discovered electrons by studying electrical discharge in gases. His plum pudding model had positive charge spread through the atom (the pudding) with electrons embedded in it (the plums).

He showed atoms are not indivisible, electrons are in all atoms, and electrons can be removed from atoms. The model was accepted for only about 10 years before new evidence replaced it.

+++++++++−−−−−−−−

Plum pudding

Plum pudding model.

In the plum pudding model, where are the electrons?

Rutherford's scattering experiment

Firing alpha particles at gold foil showed the positive charge is concentrated in a tiny, dense nucleus, and the rest of the atom is empty space.

Ernest Rutherford (1909) fired alpha particles (positive helium nuclei) at thin gold foil and watched their deflection on a fluorescent screen.

The plum pudding model predicted only slight deflections through spread-out positive charge. Large deflections and bounce-backs proved a tiny, dense, positive nucleus, with electrons orbiting in the empty space. Link each observation to its evidence in exam answers.

  1. 1

    Most passed straight through

    little or no deflection: most of the atom is empty space

  2. 2

    Some deflected at large angles

    their path was changed by the concentrated positive charge

  3. 3

    A few bounced straight back

    they hit a tiny, dense, positive nucleus

What Rutherford observed.
+

Nuclear

The nuclear model.

Why did a few alpha particles bounce straight back?

Bohr's shells

Bohr placed electrons in fixed shells at specific distances with fixed energies, so they do not spiral into the nucleus.

Niels Bohr (1913) modified Rutherford's model to solve a problem: classical physics predicted electrons should spiral into the nucleus. He proposed that electrons orbit in fixed shells (energy levels) at specific distances, with defined energies. Electrons jump between shells by absorbing or emitting energy, and cannot exist between shells.

The model explained atomic spectra and the hydrogen atom. Later work shows electrons occupy orbitals, but shells remain useful at GCSE.

Na11p 12n

Sodium

2,8,1

Bohr model of sodium: electrons in fixed shells.

How do electrons change shell in Bohr's model?

Chadwick and the neutron

Chadwick found radiation that no electric or magnetic field deflected, proving a neutral particle, the neutron, in the nucleus.

James Chadwick (1932) bombarded beryllium with alpha particles and found radiation not deflected by electric or magnetic fields. Charged particles are deflected, so this showed a neutron: a neutral particle.

The nucleus held protons but the atom's mass was too large for protons alone. Neutrons have a similar mass to protons and no charge, and they explain isotopes. The nuclear model was now complete.

He2p 2n

Helium

2

Helium with its neutrons: 2 protons, 2 neutrons in the nucleus and 2 electrons.

Proton

Charge:
+1
Relative mass:
1
Where:
Nucleus

Neutron

Charge:
0
Relative mass:
1
Where:
Nucleus

What showed that Chadwick's radiation was neutral?

Why models change

Models change when new experimental evidence contradicts them. Each model answered earlier questions but raised new ones.

Old evidence was incomplete (Dalton could not detect electrons), new experiments contradicted models (plum pudding could not explain Rutherford's results), and better technology allowed closer observation.

Today the atom has a nucleus of protons and neutrons, electrons in orbitals, and is mostly empty space. Models are provisional, not absolute truth. Always connect a specific piece of evidence to a specific change in the model.

  1. 1897

    Thomson

    plum pudding: electrical discharge

  2. 1909

    Rutherford

    nuclear model: alpha scattering

  3. 1913

    Bohr

    shells: atomic spectra

  4. 1932

    Chadwick

    neutron: bombarding beryllium

Each new model followed new evidence.

Thomson 1897

Model:
Plum pudding
Key change:
Atoms have internal structure
New evidence:
Electrical discharge

Rutherford 1909

Model:
Nuclear model
Key change:
Nucleus; mostly empty space
New evidence:
Alpha particle scattering

Bohr 1913

Model:
Shells model
Key change:
Electrons in fixed shells
New evidence:
Atomic spectra

Chadwick 1932

Model:
Proton-neutron nucleus
Key change:
Nucleus has neutrons
New evidence:
Bombardment of beryllium

Why did the plum pudding model have to be replaced?

Try an exam question

Explain how the results of the alpha particle scattering experiment led scientists to replace the plum pudding model with the nuclear model of the atom.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

A museum curator is writing a timeline display about scientific ideas of the atom. Before the discovery of the electron in 1897, scientists such as John Dalton pictured atoms as tiny, solid spheres that could not be divided into smaller parts.

What is this earliest model of the atom called?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes