Yield and Atom Economy

Yield and Atom Economy

Spec 4.3.3 · AQA GCSE Chemistry: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Theoretical yield is the maximum mass of product from the balanced equation; actual yield is what you really get.
  • Percentage yield = actual ÷ theoretical × 100, and is never more than 100%.
  • Yield is below 100% because of incomplete reactions, side reactions and losses during separation.
  • Atom economy = MrM_r of desired product ÷ sum of MrM_r of all products × 100.
  • High atom economy means less waste and lower costs. These calculations are Higher tier.
  • Percentage yieldactualtheoretical×100\dfrac{\text{actual}}{\text{theoretical}} \times 100
  • Atom economyMr desiredtotal Mr of products×100\dfrac{M_r\text{ desired}}{\text{total }M_r\text{ of products}} \times 100

Theoretical and actual yield

Theoretical yield is the most product the equation allows; actual yield is what the experiment gives, and it is always less.

Theoretical yield is calculated from the balanced equation and molar masses, assuming all the limiting reactant is converted and nothing is lost.

Actual yield is the mass you really obtain. It is always less than or equal to the theoretical yield.

01234TheoreticalActualYieldMass of MgO (g)
Illustrative: 2.4 g of Mg could give 4.0 g of MgO (theoretical). Collecting 3.6 g (actual) is a percentage yield of 90%.

Meaning

Theoretical yield:
Maximum mass from the equation
Actual yield:
Mass obtained in the experiment
Percentage yield:
Actual as a percentage of theoretical

Value

Theoretical yield:
Calculated
Actual yield:
Measured
Percentage yield:
0–100%

A reaction has a theoretical yield of 20 g and the experiment gives 15 g. What is the percentage yield?

Percentage yield

Divide the actual yield by the theoretical yield and multiply by 100.

percentage yield=actual yieldtheoretical yield×100\text{percentage yield} = \frac{\text{actual yield}}{\text{theoretical yield}} \times 100

A percentage yield of 88% means 12% of the possible product was lost. Work out the theoretical yield first, using moles and the balanced equation.

  1. 1

    Theoretical yield

    use the balanced equation and molar masses

  2. 2

    Actual yield

    take the mass from the experiment

  3. 3

    Divide

    actual ÷ theoretical

  4. 4

    Multiply by 100

    give the answer as a percentage

Percentage yield calculation

Worked example

4.0 g of copper is heated in air: 2 Cu+OX2→2 CuO\ce{2Cu + O2 -> 2CuO}. The experiment gives 4.4 g of copper oxide. Calculate the percentage yield. (Ar: Cu = 64, O = 16)

Why must percentage yield include a "× 100" step?

Why yield is below 100%

Reactions may not finish, may make unwanted products, or lose product during separation.

Name a specific reason, not just "losses".

  • Reversible reactions reach equilibrium before all the reactants are used up, e.g. NX2+3 HX2⇌2 NHX3\ce{N2 + 3H2 <=> 2NH3}
  • A side reaction makes unwanted products: magnesium heated in air also forms some MgX3NX2\ce{Mg3N2}
  • Product sticks to apparatus, is trapped in filter paper or is lost as spray
  • Impurities in the reactants reduce the pure reactant available
  1. 1

    Incomplete reaction

    reversible reactions reach equilibrium

  2. 2

    Side reactions

    unwanted products form

  3. 3

    Losses in separation

    product sticks to apparatus or filter paper

Three reasons for a yield below 100%.

Incomplete reaction

  • Reversible, reaches equilibrium

Side reactions

  • Unwanted products form

Purification losses

  • Product stuck to apparatus or filter paper

Which is the best answer to "Give one reason the percentage yield was less than 100%"?

Atom economy

Atom economy is the percentage of the mass of products that is the useful, desired product.

Atom economy is worked out from the balanced equation, so it is a theoretical value that does not depend on experimental losses.

  • High atom economy (near 100%) means little waste
  • Low atom economy means many unwanted by-products

2 Na+ClX2→2 NaCl\ce{2Na + Cl2 -> 2NaCl} has one product, so its atom economy is 100%. In CHX4+2 OX2→COX2+2 HX2O\ce{CH4 + 2O2 -> CO2 + 2H2O} with COX2\ce{CO2} wanted, it is 44÷80×100=55%44 \div 80 \times 100 = 55\%.

0204060801002Na + Cl₂ to NaClCaCO₃ to CaOReactionAtom economy (%)
Atom economy (%) from the balanced equations: 2Na + Cl₂ → 2NaCl has one product (100); CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂ gives 56/100 = 56 if CaO is wanted.
  • Atom economyMr desiredtotal Mr of products×100\dfrac{M_r\text{ desired}}{\text{total }M_r\text{ of products}} \times 100

Worked example

Calculate the atom economy for making calcium oxide by CaCOX3→CaO+COX2\ce{CaCO3 -> CaO + CO2}. (Ar: Ca = 40, C = 12, O = 16)

A reaction makes only one product. What is its atom economy?

Why atom economy matters

Less waste means a more sustainable process and lower costs.

High atom economy matters for sustainability and for money.

  • Less waste goes to landfill and less harm is caused by disposing of by-products
  • Raw materials and energy are conserved
  • Lower disposal costs and more of each reactant becomes sellable product

Chemists design green chemistry processes to balance profit with environmental responsibility.

  1. 1

    High atom economy

    most reactant atoms end up in the product

  2. 2

    Less waste and fewer by-products

  3. 3

    Lower disposal costs and fewer raw materials used

  4. 4

    More sustainable and more profitable

Why a high atom economy is better.

Sustainability

  • Reduces waste
  • Conserves raw materials
  • Lowers environmental impact

Economics

  • Lower disposal costs
  • More profit
  • More efficient process

Give one economic reason why a company prefers a reaction with high atom economy.

High or low atom economy?

Reactions with one main product are high; reactions that give off water, gases or heavy by-products are low.

You can judge it from the balanced equation.

  • High: addition reactions such as CX2HX4+HX2O→CX2HX5OH\ce{C2H4 + H2O -> C2H5OH} (100%), and syntheses with one product
  • Low: substitution reactions with by-products such as KBr\ce{KBr}, and reactions giving off water or gases

Atom economy is theoretical. Percentage yield is experimental.

020406080100CH₄ burning (CO₂)CaCO₃ → CaOC₂H₅Br + KOHC₂H₄ + H₂ON₂ + 3H₂Reaction (desired product)Atom economy (%)
Atom economy of reactions in these notes, from balanced equations

Which reaction is likely to have the highest atom economy?

Try an exam question

A student heats 4.0 g of copper in air to make copper oxide, 2 Cu+OX2→2 CuO\ce{2Cu + O2 -> 2CuO}, and obtains 4.4 g. The theoretical yield is 5.0 g. Calculate the percentage yield and give one reason it is less than 100%.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

A perfume manufacturer reacts two starting chemicals to produce a fragrant ester, with a theoretical maximum yield of 50 g predicted from the balanced equation. After the reaction and purification, the manufacturer actually collects 40 g of the ester. What is the percentage yield of this reaction?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes