D1.3 Mutation and gene editing
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- A gene mutation is a change to the base sequence: a substitution, insertion or deletion.
- Insertions and deletions not in multiples of three cause a frameshift.
- Mutation is random and is the original source of all genetic variation; only germ cell mutations are inherited.
- CRISPR–Cas9 uses a guide RNA to take Cas9 to a matching sequence and cut both DNA strands.
- Highly conserved sequences stay similar over long evolutionary periods.
Gene mutations
Substitutions, insertions and deletions change the base sequence, and insertions or deletions not in threes cause a frameshift.
A gene mutation is a structural change to the base sequence of a gene.
Substitutions swap one base for another. Because the code is degenerate, a substitution may leave the amino acid unchanged, change one amino acid, or create a stop codon. SNPs result from base substitutions.
Insertions and deletions not in multiples of three cause a frameshift, so the polypeptide is very likely to stop functioning.
- 1
Original: ATG GCA TTC
Met - Ala - Phe
- 2
Delete the G of GCA
The reading frame moves along by one base
- 3
New reading: ATG CAT TC...
Met - His - ... every later amino acid may change
Substitution
- No change, one amino acid changed, or a stop codon
Insertion or deletion, not a multiple of 3
- Frameshift; polypeptide very likely non-functional
Insertion or deletion, multiple of 3
- Amino acids added or lost, reading frame kept
Why does deleting one base usually have a bigger effect than substituting one base?
Causes and consequences
Mutations arise at random from errors in replication or repair, are made more frequent by mutagens, and are inherited only from germ cells.
Mutations arise from errors in DNA replication or repair and are more frequent with mutagens: chemicals (benzo[a]pyrene in tobacco smoke, nitrosamines, mustard gas) and radiation (UV, X-rays, gamma rays).
Mutation is random: it can happen anywhere in the genome, and there is no natural mechanism for deliberately changing a base to change a trait.
Mutation is the original source of all genetic variation: mostly harmful or neutral to individuals, but essential for natural selection.
- 1
Mutagen or replication error
Radiation, chemicals or a copying mistake
- 2
Base sequence of a gene changes
Random: anywhere in the genome
- 3
In a germ cell
Passed to offspring, adding variation
- 4
In a somatic cell
Not inherited; may cause cancer in that person
| Germ cell | Somatic cell | |
|---|---|---|
| Inherited? | Yes | No |
| Possible consequence | Passed to offspring; source of variation | Can cause cancer in that individual |
Germ cell
- Inherited?:
- Yes
- Possible consequence:
- Passed to offspring; source of variation
Somatic cell
- Inherited?:
- No
- Possible consequence:
- Can cause cancer in that individual
A mutation occurs in a skin cell. Can it be passed to the person's children?
HL: Gene knockout
A gene is made inoperative and the effect on the organism is observed.
Gene knockout is a technique for investigating what a gene does. The gene is changed so it is inoperative, then the effect on the organism is observed.
For some model species used in research, such as mice, a library of knockout organisms exists, with a line for many individual genes. You do not need to know the details of the techniques.
- 1
Knock out
change the gene so it is inoperative
- 2
Observe
record the effect on the organism
- 3
Compare
check against wild-type controls
What is the purpose of a gene knockout?
HL: CRISPR–Cas9
A guide RNA leads the enzyme Cas9 to a matching DNA sequence, where it cuts both strands.
CRISPR sequences are used to make a guide RNA complementary to the target DNA. The enzyme Cas9 carries it to the matching sequence and cuts both strands.
When the cell repairs the cut, bases may be inserted or deleted (inactivating the gene), or a supplied DNA template can insert a new sequence.
Successful example: exa-cel (Casgevy), approved in 2023 for sickle cell disease. A patient's blood stem cells are edited to make fetal haemoglobin and returned; most treated trial patients had no severe pain crises.
- 1
Guide RNA made
complementary to the target DNA
- 2
Cas9 carries it
to the matching sequence
- 3
Both strands cut
by Cas9
- 4
Cell repairs the cut
bases inserted or deleted, or a new sequence added from a template
What decides where Cas9 cuts the DNA?
HL NOS: Ethics of genome editing
Germ-line editing is inherited by people who cannot consent, and regulation is being harmonised internationally.
Some uses of CRISPR raise ethical issues that must be addressed before implementation.
- Editing embryos changes the germ line, so edits are inherited by people who cannot consent.
- Off-target cuts may cause harm.
- Editing could be used for enhancement.
Regulatory systems differ across the world, so there is an international effort to harmonise regulation of genome editing.
- 1
Embryo is edited
CRISPR changes the DNA of one cell
- 2
Every cell carries the edit
Including the gametes
- 3
Edit is inherited
Passed to children and later generations
- 4
Those people cannot consent
Off-target cuts could also cause harm
| Somatic editing | Germ-line editing | |
|---|---|---|
| Passed on to children? | No | Yes |
| Who is affected | Only the treated person | Future generations, who cannot consent |
Somatic editing
- Passed on to children?:
- No
- Who is affected:
- Only the treated person
Germ-line editing
- Passed on to children?:
- Yes
- Who is affected:
- Future generations, who cannot consent
Why is germ-line editing more ethically contentious than somatic editing?
HL: Conserved sequences
Highly conserved sequences stay similar over long periods because changes harm function or because mutation is slower there.
Conserved sequences are identical or similar across a species or group of species. Highly conserved sequences stay similar over long periods of evolution (histone H4, for example).
Evidence such as many silent third-base DNA differences but few amino acid differences supports the functional-requirement hypothesis.
- 1
Gene product needs an exact structure
For example histone H4
- 2
Almost any change is harmful
The organism is less fit
- 3
Natural selection removes the change
Carriers do not pass it on
- 4
Sequence stays conserved
Little change over long periods of evolution
Functional requirements
- The gene product needs an exact structure
- Almost any change is harmful and removed by natural selection
Slower mutation rate
- That part of the genome mutates less often
Many third-base DNA differences but almost no amino acid differences between species support which hypothesis?
Try an exam question
Outline how CRISPR–Cas9 can be used to inactivate a gene.
[4 marks]
- [1]A guide RNA is made with a base sequence complementary to the target DNA.
- [1]Cas9 carries the guide RNA to the matching sequence.
- [1]Cas9 cuts both DNA strands.
- [1]When the cell repairs the cut, bases may be inserted or deleted, which inactivates the gene.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
What is meant by a gene knockout?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
What is meant by a gene knockout?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme