D4.1 Natural selection
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Natural selection acts on heritable variation, from mutation and sexual reproduction; acquired characteristics do not evolve.
- Populations overproduce offspring, so competition for limited resources favours higher fitness.
- Natural selection changes allele frequencies in the gene pool.
- Directional, disruptive and stabilizing selection all change allele frequencies.
- Hardy–Weinberg: p + q = 1 and p² + 2pq + q² = 1 if no conditions are broken.
Natural selection and variation
Natural selection is the mechanism of evolutionary change, acting on heritable variation, and replaced Lamarckism.
Natural selection has acted continuously for billions of years, producing Earth's biodiversity. Darwin's theory supplied the mechanism that earlier naturalists lacked and replaced Lamarckism (inheritance of acquired characteristics): a paradigm shift.
Variation comes from mutation (new alleles) and sexual reproduction (new combinations of alleles). Only heritable traits evolve: characteristics acquired during life are not encoded in the base sequence of genes.
- 1
Heritable variation
mutation and sexual reproduction
- 2
Differential survival
some individuals are better suited to the environment
- 3
Survivors reproduce
they pass on their alleles
- 4
Allele frequencies change
the population evolves over generations
Lamarckism
- Inheritance of acquired characteristics
- Replaced by Darwin's theory
Natural selection
- Acts on heritable variation
- Variation from mutation and sexual reproduction
Why can a characteristic acquired during life not evolve?
Competition and fitness
Populations overproduce offspring and resources limit numbers, so competition favours genotypes with higher fitness.
Populations overproduce offspring, and resources such as food or nest sites limit carrying capacity, so there is intraspecific competition. Abiotic factors such as extreme temperatures act as density-independent selection pressures. Fitness is the survival value and reproductive potential of a genotype.
Sexual selection: traits that signal overall fitness (plumage of birds of paradise) increase mating success.
- 1
Overproduction
populations produce more offspring than can survive
- 2
Limited resources
food or nest sites set the carrying capacity
- 3
Competition
individuals compete within the species
- 4
Differences in fitness
survival value and reproductive potential differ
Female choice
- Favours bright male guppies
Strong predators (pike cichlid)
- Favour dull male guppies
In Endler's guppies, what favours dull males?
HL: Gene pools and isolation
Natural selection changes allele frequencies in the gene pool, and isolated populations can differ.
A gene pool is all the genes and their different alleles in a population. Natural selection between individuals with different heritable traits changes allele frequencies in it.
Geographically isolated populations have no gene flow, so allele frequencies can differ. The cystic fibrosis and lactase persistence alleles have very different frequencies in different human populations, found in online allele-frequency databases.
Darwin lacked genetics; neo-Darwinism integrates genetics with natural selection.
- Natural selectionchanges allele frequencies in the gene pool
- No gene flowallele frequencies can differ between populations
What does neo-Darwinism add to Darwin's theory?
HL: Types of selection
Directional selection shifts the mean, disruptive favours both extremes, and stabilizing favours intermediates.
- Directional: one extreme is favoured and the mean shifts (antibiotic resistance).
- Disruptive: both extremes are favoured over intermediates, which can split a population.
- Stabilizing: intermediates are favoured and extremes removed, so variation narrows (human birth mass).
All three change allele frequencies.
| Directional | Disruptive | Stabilizing | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Favoured | One extreme | Both extremes | Intermediates |
| Effect | The mean shifts | Can split a population | Variation narrows |
Directional
- Favoured:
- One extreme
- Effect:
- The mean shifts
Disruptive
- Favoured:
- Both extremes
- Effect:
- Can split a population
Stabilizing
- Favoured:
- Intermediates
- Effect:
- Variation narrows
Which type of selection favours both extremes over intermediates?
HL: Hardy–Weinberg
With two alleles, p + q = 1 and p² + 2pq + q² = 1 as long as no equilibrium conditions are broken.
For a gene with two alleles, p and q are the allele frequencies. With random mating, is homozygous dominant, heterozygous and homozygous recessive.
Equilibrium needs a large population, random mating, no migration, no mutation and no selection. If observed frequencies do not fit, at least one condition fails: mating is non-random or survival varies between genotypes.
- p + q1
- 1
Worked example
1 in 2500 people is affected by a recessive condition. Find the carrier frequency.
- 1
Affected people are homozygous recessive, so .
- 2
Take the square root: .
- 3
Then .
- 4
Carriers are heterozygous: .
Observed genotype frequencies do not fit p² + 2pq + q² = 1. What can you conclude?
HL: Artificial selection
Artificial selection is deliberate choice of breeders; unintended resistance, such as antibiotic resistance, is natural selection.
Artificial selection is the deliberate choice of individuals with desirable traits for breeding, in crop plants (cabbage gave broccoli, cauliflower and Brussels sprouts) and domesticated animals.
Unintended consequences of human action, such as antibiotic resistance in bacteria or herbicide resistance in weeds, result from natural selection, because nobody chooses which individuals breed.
- 1
Choose
breeders pick individuals with the desired trait
- 2
Breed
only the chosen individuals reproduce
- 3
Select offspring
pick the best offspring again
- 4
Repeat
the trait becomes more common each generation
Artificial selection
- Humans deliberately choose breeders
- Cabbage to broccoli, cauliflower, Brussels sprouts
Unintended selection
- Nobody chooses which individuals breed
- Antibiotic and herbicide resistance
Antibiotic resistance in bacteria is an example of which process?
Try an exam question
Explain how antibiotic resistance spreads in a bacterial population.
[4 marks]
- [1]Mutation produces variation, including an allele for resistance.
- [1]The antibiotic acts as a selection pressure.
- [1]Resistant bacteria survive and reproduce more, passing the heritable allele to offspring.
- [1]The allele frequency rises in the gene pool; this is natural selection, as nobody chooses which bacteria breed.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
What is the frequency of the cystic fibrosis allele (q) in population X?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
What is the frequency of the cystic fibrosis allele (q) in population X?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme