AQA GCSE Chemistry
The Evolution of the Atmosphere
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A science museum is designing a new exhibit timeline showing how the Earth's atmosphere has changed over billions of years. The exhibit begins with a description of the atmosphere roughly four and a half billion years ago, when intense volcanic activity is believed to have released large amounts of gas.(a)According to this theory, which gas made up the majority of the early atmosphere?[1 mark]
- ACarbon dioxide
- BOxygen
- CNitrogen
- DHydrogen
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(b)The exhibit's next panel explains that, as the Earth cooled, water vapour released by volcanic activity condensed to form the oceans. What happened to much of the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere once the oceans had formed?[1 mark]- AIt reacted with nitrogen to form ammonia
- BIt dissolved into the oceans and carbonates were precipitated
- CIt was immediately converted into oxygen by sunlight
- DIt escaped into space and was permanently lost
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(c)A visitor asks the museum curator why scientists say the theory of the early atmosphere's composition is uncertain rather than definitely proven. Explain why this is the case.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the early atmosphere formed about 4.5 billion years ago, so there is very little direct evidence from that time
Accept: no one was there to record it
[1] scientists have to use indirect evidence and interpret it, so theories cannot be proved and may change with new evidence
Accept: evidence from rocks open to different interpretationsTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A marine biologist is studying ancient fossilised algae mats found in layered rock formations, which scientists believe were among the first organisms to release a significant new gas into the atmosphere around 2.7 billion years ago.(a)Which process were these early algae carrying out that released this gas?[1 mark]
- ACombustion
- BRespiration
- CPhotosynthesis
- DFermentation
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)The biologist explains to students that the gas released by these algae is the same gas that later increased steadily as plants evolved and spread across the land. Which gas is this?[1 mark]- AAmmonia
- BMethane
- CCarbon dioxide
- DOxygen
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)The biologist also explains that carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere fell steadily over the same long period. Describe two separate processes, other than photosynthesis by algae and plants, that contributed to the removal of carbon dioxide from the early atmosphere.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] carbon dioxide dissolved in the oceans and formed carbonates that built up as sediments/sedimentary rocks such as limestone
[1] carbon was locked away in fossil fuels (coal, crude oil, natural gas) formed from the buried remains of dead organisms
Accept: formation of sedimentary rocks containing carbonTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A geography teacher is preparing a lesson on limestone quarrying near a village, and wants to explain to students how the limestone in the local hills is connected to the history of the Earth's atmosphere.(a)Describe how the carbon dioxide once present in the early atmosphere became locked into limestone rock over geological time.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] carbon dioxide dissolved in the oceans as they formed
[1] the dissolved carbon dioxide formed carbonates
[1] the carbonates were precipitated and settled as sediment, which over millions of years formed sedimentary rock such as limestone
Accept: shells and skeletons of marine organisms built up to form limestone(b)A student asks the teacher why scientists believe fossil fuel deposits found beneath the village, such as coal seams, are also evidence for changes in the ancient atmosphere. Explain the connection between the formation of fossil fuels and the reduction of carbon dioxide in the early atmosphere, and describe why this evidence, while useful, does not perfectly prove the exact original composition of the atmosphere.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] fossil fuels such as coal formed from the buried remains of dead plants that had absorbed carbon dioxide by photosynthesis
[1] the carbon was locked underground rather than returned to the atmosphere, so atmospheric carbon dioxide fell
[1] the large amount of fossil fuel is indirect evidence that there was once much more carbon dioxide in the atmosphere
[1] it does not prove the exact composition because it only shows how much carbon was removed, not the original concentration or timing, so scientists have to combine it with other evidence
Accept: the evidence is indirect and open to interpretationTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4A science communicator is writing a public article explaining, from start to finish, the widely accepted theory of how the Earth's atmosphere changed from its earliest volcanic beginnings to its present-day composition. A reader later writes in pointing out that some scientists have proposed alternative theories about the early atmosphere.(a)Describe the full sequence of changes, from the release of gases by volcanic activity through to the roughly stable modern atmosphere, explaining the key processes responsible for each major change in gas composition, and referencing approximately when in Earth's history each stage occurred.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] in the first billion years, volcanic activity released mainly carbon dioxide, with little or no oxygen, plus nitrogen, water vapour and small amounts of methane and ammonia
[1] as the Earth cooled, water vapour condensed to form the oceans
[1] carbon dioxide dissolved in the oceans and formed carbonates that were precipitated as sediments, which formed sedimentary rocks
[1] about 2.7 billion years ago, algae began photosynthesis, releasing oxygen; plants later increased oxygen further
[1] photosynthesis and the formation of fossil fuels and sedimentary rocks locked carbon away, so carbon dioxide fell further
[1] the modern atmosphere is about 80% nitrogen and 20% oxygen with small amounts of carbon dioxide, water vapour and noble gases, and has been stable for a long time
Accept: roughly four-fifths nitrogen and one-fifth oxygen(b)A reader writes to the science communicator pointing out that some scientists have proposed alternative theories about the exact composition of the early atmosphere, and asks why there is not just one single, universally agreed theory if the process happened so long ago. Evaluate why uncertainty exists in this area of science, discussing the types of evidence available to scientists, the limitations of that evidence, and the role of peer review and scientific debate in refining these theories over time.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the early atmosphere formed billions of years ago, before life existed, so there are no direct measurements of it
[1] scientists rely on indirect evidence such as ancient rocks, sediments and early fossils
[1] this evidence is limited: records are incomplete, altered over time or open to more than one interpretation
[1] different scientists may interpret the same evidence differently, giving competing theories
[1] peer review: other scientists check theories before they are accepted, finding flaws and building confidence in the best-supported theory
[1] conclusion: debate and new evidence refine theories over time, which is a normal part of science and not a sign that it is unreliableTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions