Edexcel GCSE Chemistry
Qualitative Analysis: Tests for Ions
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A technician is given four unlabelled white solids left over from a school laboratory and must identify the metal ion present in each using flame tests and sodium hydroxide solution.(a)A technician heats a small sample of an unknown white solid on a clean nichrome wire loop in a blue Bunsen flame. The flame turns a lilac colour throughout the test. Which ion is most likely present in the solid?[1 mark]
- ASodium ion, Na+
- BPotassium ion, K+
- CCalcium ion, Ca2+
- DCopper ion, Cu2+
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)A second solid from the same set is dissolved in water and a few drops of sodium hydroxide solution are added. A blue precipitate forms immediately, and no further precipitate forms when excess sodium hydroxide is added. Which ion is present in the solution?[1 mark]- AIron(II) ion, Fe2+
- BIron(III) ion, Fe3+
- CCopper ion, Cu2+
- DAluminium ion, Al3+
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(c)A third solid gives no colour change in a flame test, but when dissolved in water and warmed gently with sodium hydroxide solution, a gas is produced that turns damp red litmus paper blue. Identify the ion responsible for this result and explain why the flame test alone would not have identified this ion.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the ion is the ammonium ion, NH4⁺, because ammonia gas is given off and turns damp red litmus paper blue
[1] the flame test would not identify it, because the ammonium ion is not a metal ion and gives no flame colourTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A student analyses a second colourless solution using dilute acids and precipitation tests to identify the anions present, working through the tests for halide, sulfate and carbonate ions.(a)A student is given an unknown colourless solution and adds a few drops of dilute nitric acid followed by silver nitrate solution. A cream-coloured precipitate forms. Which halide ion is present in the solution?[1 mark]
- AChloride ion, Cl-
- BSulfate ion, SO₄ 2-
- CIodide ion, I-
- DBromide ion, Br-
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(b)The same student adds dilute hydrochloric acid followed by barium chloride solution to a separate sample of the solution. A dense white precipitate forms that does not dissolve when more dilute hydrochloric acid is added. Which ion does this confirm?[1 mark]- ASulfate ion, SO₄ 2-
- BChloride ion, Cl-
- CCarbonate ion, CO₃ 2-
- DNitrate ion, NO3-
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)A third sample of the same solution is tested by adding a few drops of dilute hydrochloric acid directly to it. Effervescence is observed and the gas produced is bubbled through limewater, which turns cloudy. Identify the ion responsible and write the word equation for the reaction between the acid and this ion.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the ion is the carbonate ion, CO3²⁻, because the acid gives carbon dioxide, which turns limewater cloudy
[1] word equation: metal carbonate + hydrochloric acid → metal chloride + water + carbon dioxide
Accept: the actual salt, e.g. calcium carbonate + hydrochloric acid → calcium chloride + water + carbon dioxideTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A school laboratory technician is asked to fully identify a mystery salt using a combination of flame tests and chemical tests, and to justify the need for using more than one type of test.(a)A laboratory receives a mystery salt sample and a technician performs a flame test, observing an orange-red flame colour. State the ion identified by this result, and explain why a flame test result on its own is not always sufficient to fully identify an unknown salt.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] calcium ion, Ca²⁺
Accept: Ca²⁺ from orange-red or brick-red
[1] a flame test only identifies the metal ion (cation), not the anion
[1] more tests, such as acid with barium chloride or silver nitrate, are needed to identify the anion and so the whole salt
Accept: any valid anion test(b)The technician then dissolves a sample of the same mystery salt in water, adds sodium hydroxide solution dropwise and observes a white precipitate that dissolves when excess sodium hydroxide solution is added, forming a colourless solution. Identify the cation present, and describe how the technician could then confirm the anion present is a chloride ion, including the observation expected.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the cation is the aluminium ion, Al³⁺
Accept: Al³⁺
[1] add dilute nitric acid to a fresh sample of the solution
[1] then add silver nitrate solution
[1] a white precipitate forms, which confirms chloride ions
Do not accept: cream or yellow precipitateTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4A school science department is choosing between two methods for analysing unknown ionic compounds: traditional wet chemical tests carried out by students, versus sending samples away for instrumental analysis using a flame photometer that compares emitted light with reference data and a calibration curve.(a)Traditional wet chemical tests include flame tests, sodium hydroxide tests, and acid and precipitation tests. Describe how these tests would be used to fully identify the cation and anion in an unknown ionic solid, describing at least three different tests and the observations that would distinguish between possible ions at each stage.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] flame test: heat a sample on a clean wire loop in a hot flame and compare the colour with references
Accept: lilac for K⁺, orange-red for Ca²⁺, blue-green for Cu²⁺
[1] dissolve the solid in water and add sodium hydroxide solution, noting the colour of any precipitate
[1] precipitate colours distinguish the metal ions, e.g. white, blue, green, brown; white precipitates that dissolve in excess identify Al³⁺, not Ca²⁺
Accept: white (Al³⁺, Ca²⁺), blue (Cu²⁺), green (Fe²⁺), brown (Fe³⁺)
[1] warm with sodium hydroxide if ammonium is suspected; ammonia turns damp red litmus paper blue
[1] test for carbonate: add dilute acid; effervescence that turns limewater cloudy
[1] halides and sulfate: add nitric acid then silver nitrate for chloride (white), bromide (cream) or iodide (yellow); hydrochloric acid then barium chloride gives white for sulfate(b)Evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of using an instrumental method such as a flame photometer, compared with the traditional wet chemical tests, for identifying and measuring the concentration of metal ions in solution. Your answer should refer to sensitivity, accuracy, speed, and any practical limitations of each approach.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] instrumental methods are more sensitive, detecting much smaller concentrations of ions
[1] they are more accurate, giving a numerical reading instead of relying on judging a colour by eye
[1] they are faster, especially for many samples, once calibrated
[1] a flame photometer can measure concentration by comparing with a calibration curve, and identify ions from reference data
[1] disadvantage: the equipment is expensive and may not be available, so samples may be sent away, which adds time and cost
[1] wet tests are cheap, need no special equipment and can distinguish several ions, but are less accurate, depend on judging colours and cannot easily give concentrationTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions