IB Environmental Systems and Societies SL
3.1 Biodiversity and evolution
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1The Cavendish banana supplies almost all of the bananas traded internationally. Cavendish plants are propagated from cuttings, so plantations consist of genetically identical clones. A soil fungus called Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubense Tropical Race 4 causes Panama disease, a wilting disease, and has spread through plantations in Asia, Africa and Latin America. There is no effective fungicide. The variety grown before the Cavendish, Gros Michel, was largely lost to an earlier race of the same disease.(a)Which level of biodiversity describes the variation in alleles between individual Cavendish plants?[1 mark]
- ASpecies diversity
- BHabitat diversity
- CGenetic diversity
- DEcosystem diversity
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)Which statement best explains why the plantations are so vulnerable to Tropical Race 4?[1 mark]- AThe plants are genetically identical, so none is likely to carry a resistance allele and the pathogen can infect them all
- BCloning plants makes the fungus mutate faster
- CThe plantations contain too many different species for the plants to compete
- DPlants reproduced by cuttings cannot be attacked by soil fungi until they flower
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)Suggest how maintaining genetic diversity within banana crops would increase their resilience to disease.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] some plants may carry alleles that give resistance to the disease
[1] these plants survive and reproduce, so the crop as a whole is not lost and can recover
Do not accept: the plants would be immune, with no reference to variationTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2On Daphne Major in the Galápagos Islands, researchers studied the medium ground finch (Geospiza fortis) for decades. Beak depth varies between individuals and is inherited from parents. In 1977 a severe drought greatly reduced the supply of small, soft seeds, leaving mainly large, hard seeds that only birds with deep beaks could crack. Most of the finches died. In the following generation the average beak depth of the population was greater than before the drought.(a)Which is a selective pressure acting on the finch population in 1977?[1 mark]
- AMutation of the genes controlling beak depth
- BShortage of small, soft seeds, causing competition for food
- CReproductive isolation between island populations
- DSelective breeding by humans
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)Which sequence correctly describes natural selection in this population?[1 mark]- ABirds strained to crack large seeds, so their beaks grew deeper during their lives and this was inherited by their offspring
- BAll beak depths were equally likely to survive, so the average changed by chance alone
- CThe drought caused mutations for deeper beaks in every bird that survived
- DVariation in beak depth, competition for limited seeds, higher survival and reproduction of deep-beaked birds, and inheritance of their alleles
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Explain why the average beak depth was greater in the generation after the drought.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] finches with deep beaks could crack the large, hard seeds, so were more likely to survive and reproduce
[1] beak depth is inherited, so alleles for deep beaks were passed to offspring and the average beak depth increased
Do not accept: the finches changed their beaks to suit the seedsTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3Ground beetles were sampled with pitfall traps over the same period in two woodland plots of equal area in England. Plot A is native mixed woodland and Plot B is a plantation of a single conifer species. Five beetle species were recorded in each plot, 50 individuals in total in each. Plot A: species 1 to 5 numbered 12, 11, 10, 9 and 8 individuals. Plot B: species 1 to 5 numbered 38, 6, 3, 2 and 1 individuals. The Simpson's reciprocal index for Plot B was calculated as 1.7.(a)Calculate Simpson's reciprocal index for Plot A. Show your working.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] formula stated: D = N(N − 1) ÷ Σn(n − 1)
[1] N(N − 1) = 50 × 49 = 2450 and Σn(n − 1) = 132 + 110 + 90 + 72 + 56 = 460
Accept: ECF if one n(n − 1) term is miscalculated
[1] D = 5.3
Accept: 5.33; 5.326; any answer that rounds to 5.3(b)Using the data, compare the species diversity of the two plots and explain why richness alone would not show the difference.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] both plots have the same species richness (5 species)
[1] Plot A has the higher index (5.3 compared with 1.7), so it has the higher species diversity
[1] in Plot A individuals are spread fairly evenly, whereas in Plot B one species makes up 76% (38 of 50) of the individuals, so evenness is low
Accept: 38 out of 50, or about three quarters
[1] the index takes account of both richness and evenness, so it shows a difference that richness alone cannotTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4Lake Victoria in East Africa contains hundreds of species of cichlid fish, most of them found nowhere else. Genetic evidence suggests that many of these species evolved over a relatively short geological time from a small number of ancestral populations. The species differ in diet, preferred depth of water and male breeding colours. In the 1950s the Nile perch, a large predatory fish, was introduced to the lake. Populations of many cichlids collapsed and a large number of species are thought to have become extinct. Pollution and nutrient enrichment have also reduced water clarity. Managers deciding what to protect must rely on surveys of which species are present and how many there are.(a)Explain how evolution by natural selection could have produced the large number of cichlid species in Lake Victoria.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] individuals in a population show variation in inherited characteristics
[1] more offspring are produced than the environment can support
[1] there is competition for limited resources such as food and breeding sites
[1] individuals with adaptations best suited to their conditions survive and reproduce at a higher rate, passing on their alleles
[1] populations using different diets or depths are selected in different directions, so differences accumulate over generations
[1] when populations no longer interbreed they are separate species (speciation), so species diversity rises(b)Evaluate the extent to which knowledge of the lake's biodiversity is needed to develop effective strategies to conserve it.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] surveys show which species are present and where, so habitats and areas can be targeted for protection
[1] repeated surveys, with an index such as Simpson's, monitor change and show the effect of the Nile perch or pollution
[1] knowledge allows managers to prioritise rare, endemic or declining species
[1] limitation: many species are hard to identify or not yet described, so knowledge is incomplete and surveys are costly
[1] knowledge alone is not enough: strategies also depend on funding, enforcement and the livelihoods of people who fish the lake
Accept: reference to the Nile perch fishery
[1] reasoned conclusion, e.g. knowledge is essential but must be combined with other factors
Accept: any justified judgement of the extentTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions