Cambridge IGCSE Chemistry
Experimental Design
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A student plans an experiment to measure the volume of gas produced when marble chips react with dilute hydrochloric acid over time, to investigate the rate of this reaction.(a)Which piece of apparatus should the student use to measure the volume of gas collected?[1 mark]
- AGas syringe
- BBalance
- CThermometer
- DBurette
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(b)The student wants to keep the results comparable across repeated experiments while varying the surface area of the marble chips. Which variable must the student control?[1 mark]- AThe size of the individual marble chips
- BThe surface area of the marble chips
- CThe concentration and volume of the hydrochloric acid used each time
- DThe volume of gas produced
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(c)Suggest one advantage and one disadvantage of using the volume of gas produced (rather than the loss in mass of the reaction flask) as the method of monitoring this reaction.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] advantage: gas volume can be read directly / gives a more direct measure of how much product is formed
Accept: does not need a balance sensitive to small mass changes; readings can be taken continuously; no gas is lost to the air
[1] disadvantage: gas can escape before the syringe is connected, or the syringe can leak or stick
Accept: gas may dissolve in water if collected over water; the syringe may be too small; more complex apparatus to set up
Do not accept: human errorTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A separate group investigates the effect of temperature on the rate of reaction between sodium thiosulfate solution and dilute hydrochloric acid, timing how long it takes for a mark under the reaction flask to disappear from view as a precipitate of sulfur forms.(a)Which apparatus is essential for this method?[1 mark]
- AA measuring cylinder only
- BA gas syringe and a balance
- CA burette and a volumetric pipette
- DA stopwatch and a thermometer
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(b)The group repeats the experiment at several different temperatures, keeping the concentrations and volumes of both solutions the same each time. Why is it important to control the concentrations and volumes in this way?[1 mark]- ASo that the reaction produces a different gas at each temperature
- BSo that temperature is the only variable affecting the rate, making the comparison fair
- CSo that the total volume of gas produced can be measured accurately
- DSo that a precipitate no longer forms during the reaction
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(c)Suggest one limitation of using 'time for the mark to disappear' as the measured quantity in this experiment, and suggest one way the group could improve the reliability of their results.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] limitation: deciding when the mark has disappeared is subjective / depends on the observer
Accept: different people see the mark disappear at different times; reaction time when using the stopwatch
Do not accept: human error
[1] improvement: repeat each temperature and calculate a mean
Accept: use the same observer each time; use a light sensor to detect when the mark disappears; ignore anomalous resultsTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A student is asked to design an experiment to investigate the effect of surface area on the rate of reaction between calcium carbonate and dilute hydrochloric acid, monitoring the loss in mass of the reaction flask over time using a balance. The student plans to plug the top of the flask loosely with cotton wool during the experiment.(a)State three variables the student must keep constant to ensure a fair test.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] concentration of the hydrochloric acid
Accept: any three different variables from: concentration of acid; volume of acid; total mass of calcium carbonate; temperature; same apparatus / flask size
[1] volume of the hydrochloric acid
[1] mass of calcium carbonate
Do not accept: surface area (this is the variable being investigated); amount of calcium carbonate(b)Explain the purpose of loosely plugging the top of the flask with cotton wool in this experiment, and describe how the student should use their results to compare the rates of reaction for the different surface areas tested.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] cotton wool allows carbon dioxide to escape, so the mass loss can be measured
Accept: so the pressure does not build up and blow the bung out
[1] cotton wool stops liquid / acid spray leaving the flask, which would cause extra mass loss
Do not accept: stops air getting in
[1] record the mass of the flask and contents at regular time intervals for each surface area
Accept: plot a graph of mass loss against time
[1] compare the steepness (gradient) of the graphs / time to reach a given mass loss; steeper or shorter time means faster rateTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4A school laboratory technician is preparing an experiment for students to investigate how changing the concentration of hydrochloric acid affects its rate of reaction with excess magnesium ribbon, using the volume of hydrogen gas collected in a gas syringe over time.(a)Describe, in detail, how the experiment should be designed, including the apparatus needed, the variables that must be controlled, and how the results should be recorded and analysed to draw a valid conclusion.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] apparatus: conical flask connected by a delivery tube to a gas syringe, with a stopwatch and measuring cylinder
Accept: inverted measuring cylinder or burette over water
[1] independent variable: concentration of acid, varied by dilution with water to give a range
Accept: dependent variable is the volume of hydrogen collected at set times
[1] control variables: volume of acid, mass / surface area of magnesium (excess), temperature
[1] method: add the magnesium to the acid, start the stopwatch, record gas volume at regular intervals until the reaction stops
[1] plot gas volume against time for each concentration and use the initial gradient (or time to a fixed volume) as the rate
[1] conclusion: compare the rates; higher concentration giving a steeper initial gradient shows a faster rate
Accept: repeat each concentration and take a mean; check the syringe is airtight(b)After running the experiment, several student groups obtain slightly different initial rates for the same concentration of acid. Evaluate possible sources of error or limitation in this experimental method, and suggest specific improvements the technician could make to increase the reliability and accuracy of the class's results.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] error: gas escapes through loose connections or before the bung is replaced, so the volume is too low
[1] improvement: check that all connections are airtight before starting
Accept: replace the bung immediately
[1] error: different surface area / thickness or an oxide layer on the magnesium between groups
[1] improvement: use the same mass and length of ribbon, cleaned with sandpaper
Accept: weigh the magnesium on a balance
[1] error: temperature differs between groups or changes during the reaction
[1] improvement: use a water bath at a fixed temperature, or repeat and take a mean
Accept: error from starting the stopwatch late; improvement is to use a start routine or data loggerTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions