IB MYP Sciences
Combustion
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A chef in Lagos cooks on a gas hob that burns natural gas, which is mainly methane. When the air holes at the base of the burner are open, the flame is blue and the pan stays clean. When the air holes are closed, the flame becomes yellow and the base of the pan is coated in a black deposit.(a)What is the black deposit on the pan?[1 mark]
- ACarbon monoxide
- BCarbon dioxide
- CCarbon (soot)
- DWater
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)Which products are made when methane burns completely?[1 mark]- ACarbon dioxide and water
- BCarbon monoxide and water
- CCarbon and water
- DCarbon dioxide and hydrogen
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)Explain why the flame is yellow and produces a black deposit when the air holes are closed.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] with the air holes closed there is not enough (a limited supply of) oxygen
[1] so incomplete combustion occurs, and some of the carbon in the fuel is released as soot (carbon)
Accept: carbon is not fully oxidised
Do not accept: no oxygen at allTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A family in Montreal runs a gas heater in a small bedroom during a cold winter. The windows are sealed to keep the heat in. During the night, a carbon monoxide alarm in the room sounds loudly.(a)Why is carbon monoxide dangerous to breathe in?[1 mark]
- AIt reacts with oxygen in the air to make acid rain
- BIt is toxic because it stops the blood carrying oxygen around the body
- CIt explodes at room temperature
- DIt makes the air in the room too hot to breathe
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)Why is carbon monoxide difficult for people to notice without an alarm?[1 mark]- AIt is bright yellow
- BIt has a strong smell of rotten eggs
- CIt is a liquid at room temperature
- DIt is colourless and has no smell
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Suggest two ways in which the family could reduce the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] make sure there is a good supply of fresh air (open a window or use a ventilated room)
Accept: do not seal the room; do not use the heater in a small closed room
[1] have the heater serviced regularly / keep the alarm fitted and working
Accept: use a heater that is safe indoors; stop using a faulty heaterTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3Alana, a student in Wellington, investigates how long a candle burns under glass jars of different volumes. She lights three identical candles, covers each with an upturned jar and times how long it takes for each flame to go out. The 250 cm³ jar gave 8 seconds, the 500 cm³ jar gave 17 seconds and the 1000 cm³ jar gave 33 seconds. She tested each jar once.(a)Describe the trend in Alana's results and explain it using the fire triangle.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the larger the jar, the longer the candle burns
Accept: time roughly doubles when the volume doubles
[1] a larger jar holds more air, so contains more oxygen
[1] the flame goes out when the oxygen is used up, because one side of the fire triangle (fuel, oxygen, heat) has been removed
Accept: combustion needs oxygen(b)Evaluate Alana's investigation, and suggest two improvements.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the results show a clear pattern, so they support the conclusion that a larger volume of air allows the candle to burn for longer, although there are only three jar sizes
[1] each test was done once, so the reliability is unknown: repeat each test and calculate a mean
[1] improvement: control other variables, such as using candles of the same size and wick length and placing each jar on the same surface so the seal is the same
[1] improvement: use more jar volumes and measure the time with a video or a stopwatch from a fixed point to reduce timing error
Accept: use an oxygen sensorTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4An engineer in Perth designs gas-fired water heaters for homes. They burn methane (CH₄) and have air vents at the base. In tests, when the vents are partly blocked, the flame turns yellow and the heater gives off a poisonous gas. A regulator is considering a rule that every home with a gas appliance must have a carbon monoxide alarm and an annual safety service, both paid for by the householder.(a)Explain, using the fire triangle and equations, why blocking the vents changes the products of burning methane.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] burning needs fuel, oxygen and heat (the fire triangle)
[1] with plenty of oxygen methane burns completely: methane + oxygen → carbon dioxide + water
Accept: CH₄ + 2O₂ → CO₂ + 2H₂O
[1] blocking the vents reduces the supply of oxygen
[1] so incomplete combustion occurs
[1] methane + oxygen → carbon monoxide + water (and/or carbon)
Accept: 2CH₄ + 3O₂ → 2CO + 4H₂O
[1] the yellow flame is caused by glowing carbon (soot) particles, and the carbon monoxide is the poisonous gas
Accept: carbon monoxide is toxic(b)Discuss and evaluate the regulator's proposed rule that every home with a gas appliance must have a carbon monoxide alarm and an annual safety service.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] benefit: carbon monoxide is colourless and odourless, so an alarm is the only warning and can save lives
[1] benefit: a service checks that the appliance burns the fuel completely, reducing soot and carbon monoxide and making better use of fuel
Accept: appliances that burn efficiently cost less to run
[1] economic drawback: an annual service costs money, which is harder for low-income households and tenants
[1] social/ethical point: those who cannot afford it may be less safe unless the cost is shared, e.g. by government help or landlords
[1] environmental point: burning gas releases carbon dioxide whatever the service, so the rule does not reduce this and other heating methods could be considered
Accept: efficient burning wastes less fuel
[1] justified conclusion: e.g. the rule should be introduced because lives are protected, with support for low-income households
Accept: any conclusion supported by the points aboveTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions