AQA A-Level Biology
Measuring biodiversity
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1Two ponds were each surveyed with the same sampling effort. Each pond contained four species and 100 individuals in total. In pond A the individuals were shared equally between the four species. In pond B, one species made up 97 of the individuals and each of the other three species was represented by a single individual.(a)Which statement defines species richness?[1 mark]
- AThe number of individuals of the commonest species in a community
- BThe number of different species in a community
- CThe total number of individuals of all species in a community
- DThe relationship between the number of species and the number of individuals in each species
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)Which pond has the higher index of diversity, and why?[1 mark]- APond A, because the individuals are spread evenly between the species
- BPond B, because it contains a very large population of one species
- CBoth ponds have the same value because they have the same number of species
- DPond B, because three of its species are rare
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)Explain why species richness alone is not a sufficient measure of the biodiversity of the two ponds.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] species richness only counts the number of species and takes no account of the number of individuals in each species
Accept: does not show how evenly individuals are distributed
[1] pond B has the same richness as pond A but is dominated by one species, so is less diverse
Accept: an index of diversity would be much lower for pond BTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2An ecologist calculated the index of diversity (d) for ground beetles in two habitats. The value for a hedgerow was 1.8 and the value for an area of ancient woodland was 14.5.(a)Which conclusion is best supported by these values?[1 mark]
- AThe hedgerow is more diverse, because a lower value shows individuals are spread more evenly
- BThe woodland must contain more individuals than the hedgerow
- CThe woodland community is more diverse, with more species and/or a more even spread of individuals between them
- DThe woodland contains exactly eight times as many species as the hedgerow
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)A community containing only a single species, with more than one individual, would give a value of d equal to which of the following?[1 mark]- A0
- B0.5
- CThe total number of individuals, N
- D1
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Suggest why the community in the woodland is likely to be more stable than the community in the hedgerow when the environment changes.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] woodland has more species / greater variety, so there are more food sources and niches
Accept: more complex food webs
[1] if one species is lost or declines (e.g. through disease or pollution), others can still fill its role so the community is less affected
Do not accept: the woodland is largerTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A survey of ground beetles in a woodland used randomly placed pitfall traps and recorded five species, with 12, 8, 5, 3 and 2 individuals of each. A sample collected in the same way in a neighbouring conifer plantation contained three species, with 25, 4 and 1 individuals of each.(a)Calculate the index of diversity (d) for the woodland sample, using . Show your working.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] N = 30 so N(N-1) = 30 × 29 = 870
[1] Σn(n-1) = (12×11) + (8×7) + (5×4) + (3×2) + (2×1) = 216
[1] d = 870 ÷ 216 = 4.0 (4.03)
Accept: 4 or 4.03; follow-through from an incorrect N or Σn(n-1)(b)Calculate the index of diversity for the conifer plantation sample and use both values to compare the two habitats.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] Σn(n-1) = (25×24) + (4×3) + (1×0) = 612
[1] d = 870 ÷ 612 = 1.4 (1.42)
Accept: follow-through from (a)
[1] the woodland has a higher index of diversity (4.0 compared with 1.4), so it is more diverse
[1] the plantation has fewer species and is dominated by one species, so it is less diverse
Accept: individuals are less evenly spread in the plantationTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4An ecologist compared two meadows in the same county. Each was sampled once in June using the same number of randomly placed quadrats. In meadow X, 12 plant species were recorded but a single grass species made up about 90% of all the plants counted. In meadow Y, 7 plant species were recorded, with roughly equal numbers of each.(a)Evaluate which meadow has the greater biodiversity, referring to species richness and to an index of diversity.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] species richness is higher in meadow X (12 species compared with 7)
[1] species richness only counts the number of different species and takes no account of the number of individuals
[1] an index of diversity uses the number of individuals in each species as well as the number of species
[1] meadow X is dominated by one grass species, so its index of diversity would be low
Accept: very uneven distribution of individuals
[1] meadow Y has an even spread of individuals, so its index of diversity would be higher
[1] conclusion: meadow Y is more diverse overall, although X has the higher richness
Accept: a calculated index for each meadow would be needed to confirm this(b)The county council wants to use these results to describe the biodiversity of all meadows in the county. Evaluate how reliable this conclusion would be, and explain how the investigation could be improved.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] only two meadows were sampled, so they may not be representative of all meadows in the county
[1] a single sampling visit in June may not represent other times of year, as the species present change with the seasons
[1] a small number of quadrats may not represent the whole meadow, so the calculated d may be unreliable
[1] improvement: sample more meadows, using random sampling to avoid bias
Accept: use random number tables or coordinates to place quadrats
[1] improvement: take more quadrats and repeat the survey at different times of the year
[1] a value of d is only useful for comparing with other habitats or the same habitat over time
Accept: conclusion would be reliable only for these two meadows on this occasionTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions