AQA A-Level Biology
Natural selection and adaptation
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A hospital ward has a patient infected with a bacterium. When the patient is first treated with an antibiotic, almost all the bacteria are killed. A few bacteria carry an allele for an enzyme that breaks down the antibiotic. Over several weeks of repeated treatment, most of the bacteria in the patient are found to carry this allele.(a)How did the allele for the antibiotic-breaking enzyme most probably arise in the bacterial population?[1 mark]
- AThe antibiotic caused the bacteria to mutate so they could survive it
- BThe bacteria chose to develop the allele when they were exposed
- CA random mutation occurred in the DNA of a bacterium
- DThe bacteria that were killed passed the allele to the survivors
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)Which type of selection is shown by the bacteria exposed to the antibiotic?[1 mark]- ADirectional selection
- BStabilising selection
- CArtificial selection
- DRandom genetic drift
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)Explain why the proportion of bacteria carrying the allele increased during the treatment.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] bacteria with the allele survived (the antibiotic) and reproduced, whereas those without it were killed
Accept: greater reproductive success of resistant bacteria
[1] they passed the allele to their offspring, so the allele frequency increased over generations
Do not accept: bacteria became resistant to the antibioticTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A study of a large number of human births recorded the birth weight of each baby and whether the baby survived the first month. Mortality was lowest for babies with a birth weight of about 3.5 kg. It was 1.2% at 3.5 kg, but 18% for babies of 1.5 kg, and also much higher for babies far heavier than 3.5 kg.(a)Which type of selection acts on birth weight in humans, according to the study?[1 mark]
- ADirectional selection towards heavier babies
- BDirectional selection towards lighter babies
- CSelection with no effect on the range of weights
- DStabilising selection
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(b)How many times greater was the mortality of babies of 1.5 kg than that of babies of 3.5 kg?[1 mark]- A6.7
- B16.8
- C15
- D0.07
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(c)Explain how selection keeps the mean birth weight of humans about the same over many generations.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] babies with weights close to the mean are more likely to survive (and reproduce) than those with very low or high weights
Accept: extremes are selected against
[1] so alleles for the average weight are passed on and the range of weights stays narrow
Accept: alleles for extreme weights become less frequentTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A student investigates the effect of three antibiotics on a bacterium. She spreads a culture of the bacterium over the surface of nutrient agar in a Petri dish. She then places four sterile paper discs on the agar: one soaked in antibiotic A, one in B, one in C, and a control disc soaked in sterile water. After incubation, the diameters of the clear zones around the discs are: A 12 mm, B 20 mm, C 0 mm and the control 0 mm.(a)Describe three precautions the student should take to reduce the risk of contamination and of culturing pathogens.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] sterilise equipment (inoculating loop or spreader) by flaming, and use sterile discs and forceps
Accept: disinfect the bench and wash hands
[1] keep the lid on the Petri dish as much as possible / lift it only briefly, close to a Bunsen flame
[1] seal the lid with tape (not completely) and incubate at a low temperature, about 25 °C, so human pathogens do not grow
Accept: below 30 °C
Do not accept: incubate at 37 °C(b)Calculate the area of the clear zone around the discs for A and for B, using area = . Use the results, and the control, to evaluate which antibiotic is most effective against this bacterium.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the control shows that the clear zones are caused by the antibiotics, not by the disc or the water
[1] area for B mm²
Accept: 310 or 314.2
[1] area for A mm²
Accept: 110 or 113.1
[1] B is the most effective, because it has the largest area of killed bacteria, and the bacteria are resistant to C, which has no clear zone
Accept: follow-through from incorrect areasTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4On a small island, a population of ground-feeding birds eats seeds. Beak depth varies between individuals and is controlled by several genes. After a severe drought, only large, hard-cased seeds were left on the island. Over the next six years, the mean beak depth of the population rose from 9.2 mm to 10.1 mm.(a)Explain how selection could have produced the change in mean beak depth in the population of birds.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] there was genetic diversity in the population: different alleles for beak depth, which arose originally by random mutation
[1] the drought left only large, hard seeds, so there was a selection pressure for deep beaks
[1] birds with deeper beaks could crack the seeds, so were more likely to survive and feed/breed successfully
Accept: birds with shallow beaks starved
[1] these birds had greater reproductive success and passed on their advantageous alleles to their offspring
[1] over many generations the frequency of the alleles for deep beaks increased
[1] so the mean beak depth rose, which is directional selection(b)Calculate the percentage increase in mean beak depth. Explain how selection on beak depth leads to adaptation of the population, and how adaptation and selection contribute to the diversity of living organisms. Give one physiological and one behavioural adaptation, other than beak depth, that could help the birds to survive a drought.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] percentage increase
Accept: 9.78 or 10%
[1] beak depth is an anatomical adaptation, which makes the population better adapted to the environment, so more survive and reproduce
[1] an example of a physiological adaptation: kidneys that produce more concentrated urine to conserve water in the drought
Accept: any valid physiological example
[1] an example of a behavioural adaptation: feeding at a cooler time of day, or searching larger areas for seeds
Accept: any valid behavioural example
[1] if populations of a species live in different environments, different alleles are favoured by selection
[1] over many generations the populations become increasingly different, so adaptation and selection contribute to evolution and to the diversity of living organismsTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions