Edexcel A-Level Biology B
Classification and the species concept
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1Researchers collected several specimens of an unfamiliar beetle from the canopy of a rainforest. All the specimens are female, no males have ever been found, and the beetles are thought to reproduce without mating.(a)Which sequence lists the taxonomic ranks in order from the highest to the lowest?[1 mark]
- ADomain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species
- BKingdom, domain, phylum, class, family, order, genus, species
- CDomain, kingdom, class, phylum, order, family, species, genus
- DSpecies, genus, family, order, class, phylum, kingdom, domain
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(b)Why is it difficult to apply the biological species definition to this beetle?[1 mark]- AThe beetles cannot produce fertile offspring
- BBeetles that reproduce without mating do not interbreed, so the definition cannot be tested
- CThe definition applies only to plants
- DAll the specimens are female and so must belong to different species
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(c)Suggest how the researchers could use DNA to decide whether the beetle is a new species.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] sequence DNA (or a gene) from the beetle and compare it with sequences from known, related species held in a database (bioinformatics)
Accept: use of a named gene, such as ribosomal RNA or mitochondrial DNA
[1] a large number of differences / a low percentage similarity to all known species suggests it is a new species
Accept: it would be placed in a different species if base sequences differ greatlyTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2Gel electrophoresis was used to compare DNA from four related species of finch, A to D. DNA from each species was cut with the same restriction enzyme and the fragments were separated on an agarose gel. Species A and B shared five of their six bands, species A and C shared three bands, and species A and D shared only one band.(a)Why do the DNA fragments move through the gel?[1 mark]
- ADNA is positively charged, so the fragments move towards the negative electrode
- BDNA is uncharged, so the fragments move by diffusion
- CDNA is negatively charged because of its phosphate groups, so the fragments move towards the positive electrode
- DDNA is negatively charged, so the fragments move towards the negative electrode
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)Which conclusion about the four species is best supported by the results?[1 mark]- ASpecies A and D are the most closely related
- BSpecies A, B and C belong to the same species because they share bands
- CThe bands show that species A and B have identical DNA base sequences
- DSpecies A and B are the most closely related, and species D is the least closely related to species A
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Explain why the smaller DNA fragments are found further from the wells at the end of the run.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] smaller fragments move through the pores of the gel more easily / faster
Accept: less resistance from the gel
[1] so in the same time they travel further towards the positive electrode
Do not accept: smaller fragments are more negatively chargedTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3Until the 1970s, living organisms were classified into five kingdoms: Prokaryotae, Protoctista, Fungi, Plantae and Animalia. In 1977 Carl Woese compared the base sequences of ribosomal RNA from many organisms. He found that the prokaryotes fell into two groups, bacteria and archaea, which differed from each other as much as each differs from the eukaryotes. Archaea also differ from bacteria in the lipids of their membranes and in their RNA polymerase.(a)Explain how Woese's evidence supports the three-domain model rather than the five-kingdom model.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the ribosomal RNA sequences showed that archaea differ from bacteria as much as they differ from eukaryotes
[1] so the prokaryotes should not be treated as a single group (kingdom)
Accept: Prokaryotae is not a natural group
[1] the three-domain model (Archaea, Bacteria, Eukarya) shows these evolutionary relationships better
Accept: archaea and eukaryotes share a more recent common ancestor(b)Explain how the scientific community would have helped to validate Woese's claim before it was accepted.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] he would have published the results in a scientific journal
[1] the paper would have been peer reviewed, with independent experts checking the methods and conclusions before publication
Accept: experts check validity
[1] other scientists would repeat the work or test it with other evidence, such as other genes or differences in membrane lipids
Accept: replication
[1] it would have been discussed at scientific conferences, and accepted by the community only when the evidence was reliable
Accept: the model was later included in textbooksTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4The species is the basic unit of the classification hierarchy. Biologists describe thousands of new species each year, including organisms from deep oceans, fossils and microbial samples, and they have a growing range of techniques for comparing them.(a)Evaluate the limitations of defining a species as a group of organisms that can interbreed to produce fertile offspring.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the definition cannot be applied to asexual organisms, such as bacteria, which do not interbreed
[1] it cannot be tested on fossils, as breeding cannot be observed
[1] some different species can interbreed, for example lions and tigers in captivity, and so organisms do not always keep to the definition
Accept: hybrids such as a mule, which is infertile
[1] it is difficult to test for populations that are geographically separated or hard to observe in the wild
[1] species may not be distinguishable by appearance (similar characteristics), so other evidence such as DNA sequences is needed
Accept: cryptic species
[1] conclusion: the definition is useful for sexually reproducing organisms that live together, but it is not universal
Accept: any justified judgement(b)Evaluate gel electrophoresis and DNA sequencing with bioinformatics as methods for distinguishing species and determining evolutionary relationships.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] gel electrophoresis separates DNA fragments (or proteins) by size, and the banding patterns are compared; more shared bands means more closely related
[1] electrophoresis is quick and cheap, but it detects only differences in fragment size, not the exact base sequence
[1] DNA sequencing gives the exact order of bases, so even small differences can be detected
[1] bioinformatics uses computers to compare sequences with large databases and calculate the percentage similarity
Accept: many species can be compared quickly
[1] the more differences in the base sequence, the longer ago the species shared a common ancestor
Accept: evidence for evolutionary relationships
[1] conclusion: sequencing is more precise but more expensive; the methods can be used together, and results are validated by peer review
Accept: any justified judgementTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions