Classification and the species concept

Classification and the species concept

Spec 3.1 · Edexcel A-Level Biology B: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • The hierarchy runs domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species.
  • A species can interbreed to produce fertile offspring, but the definition has limits.
  • Gel electrophoresis separates DNA fragments by size; more shared bands mean closer relatives.
  • DNA sequencing and bioinformatics compare sequences; more differences mean an older common ancestor.
  • Evidence is validated by peer review, journals and conferences.
  • The three-domain model (Archaea, Bacteria, Eukarya) came from rRNA evidence.

The classification hierarchy

Organisms are placed in nested groups from domain down to species, and named by genus then species.

Each group sits within the one above: domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species. Members of a group share features and usually a recent common ancestor.

Each species has a two-part scientific name (binomial), genus then species, for example Homo sapiens.

  1. 1

    Domain

    highest rank

  2. 2

    Kingdom

    Animalia, Plantae…

  3. 3

    Phylum

    nested group

  4. 4

    Class

    nested group

  5. 5

    Order

    nested group

  6. 6

    Family

    nested group

  7. 7

    Genus

    first part of the name

  8. 8

    Species

    second part of the name

The hierarchy, highest rank to lowest

In the name Homo sapiens, which part is the genus?

The species concept

A species interbreeds to produce fertile offspring, but this cannot be tested or applied in many cases.

A species is a group of organisms with similar characteristics that can interbreed to produce fertile offspring. It is difficult to apply to asexual organisms, fossils, hybrids (lions and tigers in captivity; a horse and donkey give an infertile mule), isolated populations, and species that look similar.

Asexual organisms

  • Many bacteria do not interbreed

Fossils

  • Breeding cannot be tested

Hybrids

  • Some different species interbreed

Isolated populations

  • Interbreeding cannot be tested

Why can the interbreeding definition not be applied to fossils?

Gel electrophoresis

It separates DNA fragments by size; more shared bands means species are more closely related.

DNA is cut with restriction enzymes and loaded into wells in an agarose gel. DNA is negatively charged, so it moves towards the positive electrode. Smaller fragments move faster and further, giving a banding pattern.

It is quick and cheap, but gives only limited information.

  1. 1

    Cut

    restriction enzymes cut the DNA

  2. 2

    Load

    fragments placed in wells in agarose gel

  3. 3

    Run

    DNA moves to the positive electrode

  4. 4

    Read

    smaller fragments travel further, giving bands

Gel electrophoresis

Which fragments travel furthest in the gel?

Sequencing and bioinformatics

Comparing base sequences gives a percentage similarity: more differences mean the species diverged longer ago.

DNA sequencing gives the exact order of bases in a gene such as ribosomal RNA or cytochrome c. Bioinformatics uses computers to compare sequences from many species and calculate percentage similarity.

Sequencing is more precise than electrophoresis, and works for fossils or microbes where interbreeding cannot be tested.

Few differences

  • Recent common ancestor
  • Closely related

Many differences

  • Distant common ancestor
  • Less closely related

Two species have many differences in a gene sequence. What does this suggest?

Validating new evidence

Peer review, publication, repeats and conferences validate new claims.

Results are published in scientific journals. In peer review, independent experts check the methods and conclusions before publication. Other scientists repeat the work or test it with other evidence, and results are discussed at conferences.

Many independent lines of evidence, including DNA sequences, support the theory of evolution.

  1. 1

    Research

    scientists collect evidence

  2. 2

    Peer review

    independent experts check methods and conclusions

  3. 3

    Publication

    results appear in a journal

  4. 4

    Repeat

    others repeat or test with other evidence

Validating a claim

What is peer review?

Three domains or five kingdoms?

Woese’s rRNA comparisons showed archaea are as different from bacteria as from eukaryotes.

The five-kingdom model puts all prokaryotes in one kingdom. The three-domain model (Archaea, Bacteria, Eukarya) came from Carl Woese, who compared ribosomal RNA sequences.

Other evidence: different membrane lipids, no peptidoglycan in archaeal walls, and archaeal RNA polymerase and ribosomes resembling eukaryotic ones.

Five kingdoms

  • Prokaryotae
  • Protoctista
  • Fungi
  • Plantae
  • Animalia

Three domains

  • Archaea
  • Bacteria
  • Eukarya

Which evidence led Carl Woese to propose three domains?

Try an exam question

Explain why gel electrophoresis can be used to compare the DNA of two species.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which sequence lists the taxonomic ranks in order from the highest to the lowest?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes