Yields, atom economy and experimental errors

Yields, atom economy and experimental errors

Edexcel A-Level Chemistry: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Percentage uncertainty = absolute uncertainty ÷ measured value × 100. For two readings, double the absolute uncertainty.
  • Reduce percentage error with larger quantities and more precise apparatus.
  • Percentage yield = actual ÷ theoretical × 100.
  • Atom economy = MM(desired product) ÷ sum of MM(all products) × 100.
  • A hazard can cause harm; a risk is the chance it does, with its severity.

Measurement uncertainty

Every measurement has an uncertainty. Express it as a percentage, and add absolute uncertainties when a value comes from two readings.

Every measurement has an uncertainty, the interval within which the true value is expected to lie. A burette is ±0.05 cm³ per reading, a 25.0 cm³ pipette ±0.06 cm³ and a balance ±0.001 g per reading.

When a value comes from two readings (a titre, or a mass by difference) the absolute uncertainties add.

Percentage error compares the result with an accepted value: (∣result−accepted∣÷accepted)×100(|\text{result} - \text{accepted}| \div \text{accepted}) \times 100.

  1. 1

    Two readings

    start and end

  2. 2

    Absolute uncertainty adds

    0.05 + 0.05 = ±0.10 cm³

  3. 3

    Percentage uncertainty

    0.10 ÷ 25.0 × 100 = 0.4%

Uncertainty in a titre, e.g. a burette (±0.05 cm³ per reading).
  • Percentage uncertaintyabsolute uncertaintymeasured value×100\dfrac{\text{absolute uncertainty}}{\text{measured value}} \times 100

Worked example

A titre of 20.00 cm³ is found from two burette readings, each ±0.05 cm³. Find the percentage uncertainty.

A 2.000 g sample is weighed by difference on a balance reading to ±0.001 g per reading. What is the percentage uncertainty?

Sources of error

Random errors are reduced by repeating; systematic errors are not. Larger quantities and more precise apparatus cut percentage uncertainty.

To reduce percentage uncertainty:

  • use a larger quantity, so the same absolute uncertainty is a smaller fraction
  • use apparatus with a smaller uncertainty, such as a pipette instead of a measuring cylinder
  • weigh by difference, noting this doubles the absolute uncertainty.

If the difference between a result and the accepted value is larger than the total percentage uncertainty, a systematic error is probably present. Quantities in excess, such as acid in excess, need not be measured precisely.

123456789100.20.40.60.81xy(0.5 g, 0.4%)(2 g, 0.1%)(10 g, 0.02%)% uncertainty = 0.2 / mass
Weighing by difference (±0.002 g in total): percentage uncertainty = 0.2 ÷ mass, so larger masses give smaller percentage uncertainty.

Random error

Effect on results:
Scatter in either direction
Reduced by repeating?:
Yes, by averaging
Example:
Judging the meniscus

Systematic error

Effect on results:
Every result shifted the same way
Reduced by repeating?:
No
Example:
Balance not zeroed

A balance reads 0.02 g too high every time. What type of error is this?

Percentage yield

Percentage yield compares the mass of product obtained with the maximum possible. It is below 100% because of incomplete reactions and losses.

The percentage yield compares the mass of product actually obtained with the theoretical yield, the maximum possible.

Yields are below 100% because of incomplete reactions, side reactions, losses in transferring and purifying, and equilibrium.

Identify the limiting reactant before calculating the theoretical yield.

0246810Theoretical yieldActual yieldMass of product (g)
Illustrative values: 7.5 g obtained from a theoretical yield of 10.0 g gives a percentage yield of 75%.
  • Percentage yieldactual masstheoretical mass×100\dfrac{\text{actual mass}}{\text{theoretical mass}} \times 100

Worked example

5.00 g of salicylic acid (138.0 g mol⁻¹) gives 4.80 g of aspirin (180.0 g mol⁻¹), in a 1 : 1 reaction. Find the percentage yield.

A reaction has a theoretical yield of 8.00 g and gives 6.00 g. What is the percentage yield?

Atom economy

Atom economy is the percentage of the reactant mass that ends up as the desired product, found from the balanced equation alone.

Atom economy is calculated from the balanced equation alone. It measures how much of the reactant mass ends up as the desired product, so a high atom economy means less waste.

It is not the same as yield: a reaction can have a high yield but a low atom economy. Addition reactions, in which everything joins into one product, have an atom economy of 100%. Uses for by-products raise the sustainability of a process.

0102030405060CaO (desired product)CO₂ (waste)Relative formula mass
CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂ (relative formula masses 100, 56, 44): atom economy for CaO = 56 ÷ 100 = 56%.
  • Atom economyM(desired product)∑M(all products)×100\dfrac{M(\text{desired product})}{\sum M(\text{all products})} \times 100

Worked example

Find the atom economy for making hydrogen: CHX4+HX2O→CO+3 HX2\ce{CH4 + H2O -> CO + 3H2}.

What is the atom economy of CX2HX4+HX2→CX2HX6\ce{C2H4 + H2 -> C2H6}, making ethane?

Risks and hazards

A hazard is something that could cause harm; a risk is the chance it does, with its severity. Link each hazard to a precaution.

A hazard is something with the potential to cause harm; a risk is the chance that the harm occurs, combined with its severity.

Identify the hazards, decide how likely and how serious harm is, then choose precautions. A good risk assessment concludes whether the risk is acceptably low once the precautions are taken.

  1. 1

    Identify the hazard

    something that could cause harm

  2. 2

    Judge likelihood and severity

    this is the risk

  3. 3

    Choose a precaution

    linked to each hazard

  4. 4

    Conclude

    is the risk acceptably low?

Carrying out a risk assessment.

Hazard

  • Irritant 2.0 mol dm⁻³ HCl\ce{HCl}
  • Corrosive concentrated acids
  • Toxic fumes
  • Flammable solvents
  • Hot apparatus and glassware
  • Gas pressure

Precaution

  • Eye protection, gloves
  • Eye protection, gloves, add acid to water
  • Use a fume cupboard
  • Heat with a water bath, keep away from flames
  • Support glassware, allow to cool
  • Do not seal a flask that is heated or producing gas

What is the difference between a hazard and a risk?

Try an exam question

A reaction makes 4.50 g of product. The theoretical yield is 6.00 g. Calculate the percentage yield and give two reasons why it is less than 100%.

[3 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What is the percentage atom economy for making hydrogen in the first stage, CH₄ + H₂O → CO + 3H₂?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes