Predicting feasibility and limitations

Predicting feasibility and limitations

Edexcel A-Level Chemistry: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell} positive means a reaction is thermodynamically feasible; it says nothing about rate.
  • More positive E⊖E^\ominus: stronger oxidising agent; more negative: stronger reducing agent.
  • ΔStotal=nFE⊖/T\Delta S_{total} = nFE^\ominus/T and ln⁡K=nFE⊖/RT\ln K = nFE^\ominus/RT.
  • Limitations: kinetic inhibition and non-standard conditions.
  • Disproportionation is feasible if Ecell⊖=E⊖(reduction)−E⊖(oxidation)E^\ominus_{cell} = E^\ominus(\text{reduction}) - E^\ominus(\text{oxidation}) is positive.

Predicting feasibility

The reaction is feasible if Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell} is positive, with the more positive half-cell being reduced.

  1. Write the two half-equations.
  2. Take the more positive half-cell as the one reduced.
  3. Ecell⊖=Ereduced⊖−Eoxidised⊖E^\ominus_{cell} = E^\ominus_{reduced} - E^\ominus_{oxidised}.

If Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell} is positive, the reaction is feasible under standard conditions. If negative, it is not (the reverse is).

  • Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell}Ereduced⊖−Eoxidised⊖E^\ominus_{reduced} - E^\ominus_{oxidised}
  • Feasible ifpositive

Worked example

Will acidified MnOX4X−\ce{MnO4-} oxidise FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+}? E⊖(MnOX4X−/MnX2+)=+1.51E^\ominus(\ce{MnO4-/Mn^2+}) = +1.51 V and E⊖(FeX3+/FeX2+)=+0.77E^\ominus(\ce{Fe^3+/Fe^2+}) = +0.77 V.

A negative E°cell means:

The electrochemical series

The more positive the E⊖E^\ominus, the stronger the oxidising agent. The more negative, the stronger the reducing agent.

Listing half-equations in order of E⊖E^\ominus gives the electrochemical series.

  • More positive E⊖E^\ominus: stronger oxidising agent (species on the left) and more stable reduced form.
  • More negative E⊖E^\ominus: stronger reducing agent (species on the right).

A species will oxidise any reduced form with a less positive E⊖E^\ominus.

−3−2−101Li⁺/LiMg²⁺/MgZn²⁺/ZnFe²⁺/FeH⁺/H₂Cu²⁺/CuI₂/I⁻Fe³⁺/Fe²⁺Ag⁺/AgBr₂/Br⁻Cl₂/Cl⁻MnO₄⁻/Mn²⁺Half-cellE° / V
Standard electrode potentials, most negative to most positive

Which is the strongest oxidising agent in the series?

E°cell, entropy and K

A positive Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell} means total entropy rises and K>1K > 1.

nn is the number of electrons transferred, F=96 500F = 96\,500 C mol−1^{-1}, R=8.31R = 8.31 J K−1^{-1} mol−1^{-1} and TT in kelvin.

ΔStotal=nFEcell⊖Tln⁡K=nFEcell⊖RT\Delta S_{total} = \frac{nFE^\ominus_{cell}}{T} \qquad \ln K = \frac{nFE^\ominus_{cell}}{RT}

  • ΔStotal\Delta S_{total}nFEcell⊖T\dfrac{nFE^\ominus_{cell}}{T}
  • ln⁡K\ln KnFEcell⊖RT\dfrac{nFE^\ominus_{cell}}{RT}

Worked example

For Zn+CuX2+→ZnX2++Cu\ce{Zn + Cu^2+ -> Zn^2+ + Cu}, Ecell⊖=+1.10E^\ominus_{cell} = +1.10 V, n=2n = 2, T=298T = 298 K. Find ΔStotal\Delta S_{total} and KK.

A positive E°cell means:

Limitations of predictions

E° gives only thermodynamic feasibility, and it applies only under standard conditions.

  1. Kinetic inhibition. If the activation energy is very high, the rate is negligible and no change is observed.
  2. Non-standard conditions. E⊖E^\ominus values apply only at 1.00 mol dm−3^{-3}, 298 K and 100 kPa. Other conditions shift the half-cell equilibria.

For example, acidified MnOX4X−\ce{MnO4-} could oxidise water (Ecell⊖=+0.28E^\ominus_{cell} = +0.28 V), yet solutions stay purple for weeks. If Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell} is only slightly positive or negative, a change in conditions can reverse the prediction.

Kinetic inhibition

Cause:
Very high activation energy
Effect:
Rate negligible

Non-standard conditions

Cause:
Concentration, T or p changed
Effect:
Electrode potentials change

Acidified MnO4- does not oxidise water at a noticeable rate because:

Disproportionation

Disproportionation is the simultaneous oxidation and reduction of the same species. It is feasible if Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell} is positive.

It is feasible when the species is more easily reduced than oxidised.

Copper(I): CuX++eX−⇌Cu\ce{Cu+ + e- <=> Cu} is +0.52+0.52 V; CuX2++eX−⇌CuX+\ce{Cu^2+ + e- <=> Cu+} is +0.15+0.15 V. For 2 CuX+→CuX2++Cu\ce{2Cu+ -> Cu^2+ + Cu}, Ecell⊖=+0.52−0.15=+0.37E^\ominus_{cell} = +0.52 - 0.15 = +0.37 V: feasible, so CuX+\ce{Cu+} is unstable in water.

Iron(II): FeX2+/Fe\ce{Fe^2+/Fe} is −0.44-0.44 V and FeX3+/FeX2+\ce{Fe^3+/Fe^2+} is +0.77+0.77 V, so Ecell⊖=−1.21E^\ominus_{cell} = -1.21 V: not feasible, so FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+} is stable.

CuX+\ce{Cu+}

Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell}:
+0.37 V
Disproportionation:
Feasible
Result:
Unstable

FeX2+\ce{Fe^2+}

Ecell⊖E^\ominus_{cell}:
-1.21 V
Disproportionation:
Not feasible
Result:
Stable

Disproportionation is:

Try an exam question

Use E° values to show that copper(I) ions disproportionate in water. Cu+ + e- <=> Cu (+0.52 V); Cu2+ + e- <=> Cu+ (+0.15 V).

[3 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What is E°cell for the reaction MnO₄⁻ + 5Fe²⁺ + 8H⁺ → Mn²⁺ + 5Fe³⁺ + 4H₂O?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes