Life Cycle Assessment and Recycling
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- A life cycle assessment (LCA) measures the environmental impact of a product at four stages.
- The four stages are raw materials, manufacture and packaging, use, and disposal.
- LCAs let you compare products fairly because they total the impact across the whole life.
- Some impacts are hard to measure, so LCAs need value judgements and can be biased.
- Recycling metals saves ores and energy and cuts landfill; aluminium saves about 95% of the energy.
The four stages
An LCA evaluates the environmental impact of a product or process through its whole life, in four stages.
Each stage uses energy and resources and may create waste or emissions.
- Raw materials: extracting and processing.
- Manufacture and packaging.
- Use and operation.
- Disposal at end of life: landfill, recycling or incineration.
- 1
Raw materials
extracting and processing
- 2
Manufacture
making and packaging
- 3
Use
use and operation
- 4
Disposal
landfill, recycling or incineration
Which is one of the four stages assessed in an LCA?
Comparing products
Totalling the energy, emissions and waste across all four stages shows which product has the lowest overall impact.
LCAs can compare paper bags with plastic bags, recycled aluminium with newly extracted aluminium, or different ways of making the same product.
All four stages must be counted: a product that looks green at one stage may hide a large cost at another, such as a product with no waste in use that needs huge amounts of energy to make.
- 1
Raw materials
extracting and processing
- 2
Manufacture
making the product and its packaging
- 3
Use
during its working life
- 4
Disposal
landfill, reuse or recycling
| Reusable cup | Disposable paper cup | |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacture | Energy-intensive to make | Quick to make |
| Over its life | Saves resources over many uses | Creates continuous waste |
Reusable cup
- Manufacture:
- Energy-intensive to make
- Over its life:
- Saves resources over many uses
Disposable paper cup
- Manufacture:
- Quick to make
- Over its life:
- Creates continuous waste
Why must all four stages be considered when comparing two products?
Limits of LCAs
Some impacts are hard to put a number on, so LCAs rely on value judgements and can be biased.
Impacts that are difficult to quantify include loss of biodiversity, visual pollution, noise pollution, water pollution and habitat destruction.
So an LCA needs value judgements: subjective decisions about how important each impact is. Different people weigh them differently, so results can vary between studies of the same product.
- 1
Measurable impacts
energy used, emissions, waste
- 2
Hard-to-measure impacts
biodiversity, noise, visual and water pollution
- 3
Value judgements
people decide how much each impact matters
- 4
Results vary
between studies, and bias is possible
Easier to measure
- Energy used
- Emissions produced
- Waste generated
Hard to measure
- Loss of biodiversity
- Visual pollution
- Noise pollution
- Water pollution and habitat destruction
Why can two LCAs of the same product give different results?
Why recycle metals
Recycling metals conserves ores, saves energy, reduces landfill and is often profitable.
Metal ores are non-renewable, so recycling means less mining and ores last longer.
Extraction (mining, crushing, processing) needs huge amounts of energy. Recycled metal is already refined, so it only needs remelting, which also means fewer carbon emissions.
Recycling diverts metal from landfill, and scrap metal has market value.
- 1
Collect and sort
scrap metal is gathered and separated
- 2
Remelt
already refined, so no extraction from ore is needed
- 3
Reshape
cast into new products
- 4
Result
ores last longer, less landfill, fewer carbon emissions
Extracting from ore
- Mining, crushing and processing
- Large energy input
- Uses up ore deposits
Recycling
- Collect and remelt
- Much less energy
- Conserves ores and saves landfill space
Why does recycling a metal use less energy than extracting it from its ore?
Recycling aluminium
The more energy it takes to extract a metal, the more energy recycling saves. Aluminium is a prime example.
Aluminium is extracted by electrolysis of molten ore, which needs enormous amounts of electrical energy. Recycling uses only about 5% of that energy, so recycled aluminium is much cheaper and gives far lower carbon emissions.
Copper, steel and lead are also worth recycling: copper because extraction is energy-intensive, steel because it is used so widely, and lead because it is toxic.
Why is recycling aluminium especially worthwhile?
Try an exam question
Explain why recycling aluminium is better for the environment than extracting new aluminium.
[4 marks]
- [1]Aluminium is extracted from its ore by electrolysis.
- [1]Electrolysis needs very large amounts of electrical energy.
- [1]Recycling uses only about 5% of the energy needed to extract new aluminium.
- [1]So less fossil fuel is burned (fewer carbon emissions), and less ore is mined and less waste goes to landfill.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which of the following is one of the four stages considered in a life cycle assessment?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which of the following is one of the four stages considered in a life cycle assessment?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme