3.3 Conservation and regeneration

3.3 Conservation and regeneration

IB Environmental Systems and Societies SL: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Five justifications for preservation: aesthetic, ecological, economic, ethical, social.
  • Species-based conservation tends to be ex situ; habitat-based tends to be in situ.
  • Large, round reserves with corridors and buffer zones work best.
  • Rewilding restores natural processes by reducing human management.
  • Ecocentric, anthropocentric and technocentric value systems favour different strategies.

Species-based

  • Tends to be ex situ
  • Zoos, seed banks, botanic gardens

Habitat-based

  • Tends to be in situ
  • Reserves and national parks

Why preserve nature?

Arguments for preservation can be aesthetic, ecological, economic, ethical or social.

Arguments for preserving species and habitats rest on five kinds of justification.

  • Aesthetic: nature's beauty and inspiration.
  • Ecological: species and habitats support ecosystem function and services such as pollination, flood regulation and carbon storage.
  • Economic: resources, tourism and genetic material for medicines and crops.
  • Ethical: species have an intrinsic right to exist, and we owe a duty to future generations.
  • Social: cultural and recreational value, wellbeing and livelihoods.
  1. 1

    Aesthetic

    beauty and inspiration

  2. 2

    Ecological

    ecosystem function and services

  3. 3

    Economic

    resources, tourism, medicines

  4. 4

    Ethical

    intrinsic right, duty to future generations

  5. 5

    Social

    culture, wellbeing, livelihoods

Five justifications for preservation

"A forest stores carbon and regulates floods, so it should be protected." Which justification is this?

Species, habitat and mixed approaches

Species-based conservation tends to be ex situ, habitat-based tends to be in situ, and a mixed approach combines them.

Species-based conservation tends to use ex situ strategies (outside the natural habitat): captive breeding in zoos, seed banks, botanic gardens.

Habitat-based conservation tends to use in situ strategies (within the natural habitat): reserves and national parks.

A mixed approach considers both, for example protecting a reserve while breeding and reintroducing a flagship species. The California condor fell to 22 birds in 1982; all wild birds were captured by 1987 and bred, with releases from 1992.

The UN Convention on Biological Diversity addresses both approaches; in 2022 parties targeted protecting at least 30% of land and sea by 2030.

  1. 1

    Species-based: ex situ

    Outside the natural habitat: captive breeding, seed banks, botanic gardens

  2. 2

    Habitat-based: in situ

    Within the natural habitat: reserves and national parks

  3. 3

    Mixed approach

    Both together, e.g. a reserve plus species breeding

Three conservation approaches.

Species-based

  • Tends to be ex situ
  • Captive breeding, seed banks

Habitat-based

  • Tends to be in situ
  • Reserves, national parks

Mixed

  • Both together
  • Reserve plus species breeding

A seed bank is an example of which strategy?

Reserve design

Large, round reserves with corridors and buffer zones protect species best.

Habitat conservation protects species by conserving their natural environment, through protection of wild areas or active management such as controlling invasive species.

Effective reserves depend on the biology of target species (territory, diet, breeding, migration) and the size and shape of the area:

  • Larger reserves support larger populations and more species.
  • A circular shape has the lowest edge-to-area ratio, so the least edge effect.
  • Corridors connect reserves, allowing gene flow and movement.
  • Buffer zones around a core area reduce disturbance.
OR1R2R3R4
Two reserves of equal area (about 12.6 units²): the circle's edge is 12.6 units long, the long rectangle's is 19.1, so it has more edge exposed to disturbance.

Better design

  • Large
  • Circular
  • Corridors between reserves
  • Buffer zone

Why

  • More species and larger populations
  • Lowest edge-to-area ratio
  • Gene flow and movement
  • Reduces disturbance

Why is a circular reserve better than a long narrow one of the same area?

Regeneration and rewilding

Rewilding regenerates natural processes by reducing human management, often by returning grazing animals or missing species.

Rewilding regenerates natural processes in ecosystems by reducing human management, often with the return of grazing animals or missing species.

Conservation and regeneration can reverse biodiversity decline and keep humanity within a safe operating space for the biodiversity planetary boundary.

At Knepp Estate (England), 1,400 hectares of former farmland have regenerated since 2001 with free-roaming cattle, ponies, pigs and deer; nightingales, turtle doves and purple emperor butterflies now breed there.

  1. 1

    Reduce human management

    stop intensive farming

  2. 2

    Return natural processes

    free-roaming grazers, missing species

  3. 3

    Ecosystem regenerates

    wildlife returns

Rewilding

What does rewilding aim to do?

Value systems

Ecocentric, anthropocentric and technocentric value systems favour different strategies.

Perspectives and value systems affect the strategies a society chooses. Different groups (conservationists, farmers, governments) hold different values, which can cause conflict over land use.

  1. 1

    Ecocentric

    Nature has intrinsic value: protection with minimal intervention, e.g. rewilding

  2. 2

    Anthropocentric

    Nature valued for its use to humans: managed use and ecosystem services

  3. 3

    Technocentric

    Faith in technology and management: active intervention

Value systems from least to most intervention.

Ecocentric

View:
Nature has intrinsic value
Favoured strategy:
Protection with minimal intervention, e.g. rewilding

Anthropocentric

View:
Nature is valued for its use to humans
Favoured strategy:
Managed use and ecosystem services

Technocentric

View:
Faith in technology and management
Favoured strategy:
Active intervention, e.g. captive breeding

Which value system would most favour rewilding with minimal intervention?

Try an exam question

Compare species-based and habitat-based conservation, giving an example of each.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which feature of Proposal 1 best reduces edge effects?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes