3.3 Conservation and regeneration
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Reasons to preserve biodiversity: aesthetic, ecological, economic, ethical and social.
- In situ conservation protects habitats; ex situ conservation keeps species outside their habitat.
- Reserves work best when large and circular, with corridors between them.
- Rewilding regenerates natural processes, e.g. wolves in Yellowstone.
- HL: NGO success depends on media, speed, diplomacy, finance and political influence; ecotourism has benefits and costs.
Preservation strategies and treaties
Biodiversity can be conserved by protecting species ex situ or habitats in situ, guided by the Convention on Biological Diversity.
Arguments for preservation can be aesthetic, ecological, economic, ethical and social. The Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) is a UN treaty covering both species-based and habitat-based conservation.
Limitations of ex situ conservation: the habitat and ecological interactions are not conserved, some species cannot be stored or bred in captivity, and it is costly.
- 1
Species-based, tends to be ex situ
zoos, captive breeding, seed banks such as Svalbard
- 2
Habitat-based, tends to be in situ
reserves and national parks
- 3
Mixed approach
a reserve plus a captive breeding programme
| Species-based | Habitat-based | Mixed approach | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Approach | Tends to be ex situ | Tends to be in situ | Both |
| Examples | Zoos, captive breeding, seed banks such as the Svalbard Global Seed Vault | Reserves, national parks | A reserve plus a captive breeding programme |
Species-based
- Approach:
- Tends to be ex situ
- Examples:
- Zoos, captive breeding, seed banks such as the Svalbard Global Seed Vault
Habitat-based
- Approach:
- Tends to be in situ
- Examples:
- Reserves, national parks
Mixed approach
- Approach:
- Both
- Examples:
- A reserve plus a captive breeding programme
A seed bank stores seeds of endangered plants. Is this in situ or ex situ conservation?
Habitat conservation and reserve design
Reserves work best when large, circular and linked by corridors, matched to the biology of the target species.
Habitat conservation protects species by conserving their natural environment, through protection of wild areas or active management. Effective reserves depend on the biology of the target species and on size and shape.
By conserving and regenerating ecosystems, humanity can stay in a safe operating space within the biodiversity planetary boundary.
Better design
- Larger reserve supports more species
- Circular shape: least edge effect
- Corridors link populations
Worse design
- Small reserve supports fewer species
- Long thin shape: more edge effect
- Isolated populations
Why is a circular reserve better than a long thin one of the same area?
Rewilding
Rewilding regenerates natural processes in ecosystems, and the strategy chosen depends on a society's value systems.
Natural processes can be regenerated by rewilding, for example the reintroduction of wolves to Yellowstone in 1995–97.
Environmental perspectives and value systems affect the strategy a society chooses.
- 1
Wolves reintroduced
1995 to 1997
- 2
Prey and ecosystem respond
natural processes are regenerated
- 3
Strategy reflects values
ecocentric, anthropocentric and technocentric views choose differently
Ecocentric
- Intrinsic value of nature
Anthropocentric
- Human benefit
Technocentric
- Technology and management
Which value system gives nature intrinsic value?
HL: success of organisations
Success depends on media use, speed of response, diplomatic constraints, finance and political influence.
(HL) The success of international, governmental and non-governmental organisations depends on several factors: use of the media, speed of response, diplomatic constraints, financial resources (funding sets the scale and length of programmes) and political influence.
Intergovernmental bodies depend on agreement among states: the IWC moratorium on whaling is ignored by Norway, Iceland and Japan, which continue to hunt.
- 1
Media and finance
raise awareness and fund the scale and length of programmes
- 2
Speed of response
NGOs often act faster than states
- 3
Diplomacy and political influence
agreement among states is needed; IWC whaling rules are ignored by some members
NGOs
- Media raises awareness, pressure and donations (Greenpeace)
- Can often act faster
- Lobby governments
Governments and intergovernmental bodies
- Slower: need agreement among states
- Diplomatic constraints (IWC whaling)
- Can legislate and enforce
Give one reason an NGO may respond to a conservation problem faster than an intergovernmental body.
HL: feedback loops and rewilding
Rewilding can trigger positive feedback loops that enhance biodiversity, though it has costs and limits.
(HL) Rewilding and habitat restoration can trigger positive feedback loops that enhance biodiversity and promote ecosystem equilibrium.
Benefits: restored processes, more biodiversity, ecosystem services, tourism. Limitations: conflict with farmers, cost, slow and uncertain results, disputed cause and effect.
Success must be assessed by monitoring indicators (species numbers, diversity index, vegetation cover) against a baseline over the long term.
- 1
Wolves reduce elk grazing
less browsing of young trees
- 2
Willow regrows
vegetation recovers
- 3
Beavers return
they use the willow
- 4
Dams create wetlands
supporting more species
- 5
More willow and beavers
the loop continues
Then back to step 1
Why is the Yellowstone example described as positive feedback?
HL: ecotourism
Ecotourism can fund protection and support communities, but can also harm wildlife and communities.
(HL) Ecotourism can increase the interdependence of local communities and increase biodiversity by generating income and funding protection. In Rwanda, mountain gorilla permits cost about 1,500 US dollars and about 10% of revenue goes to communities.
There can be negative societal and ecological impacts: disease transmission and disturbance, unequal sharing of benefits, loss of access to land, and dependence on tourism.
- 1
Tourists pay
Rwanda gorilla permits cost about 1,500 US dollars
- 2
Income funds protection
about 10% of revenue goes to communities
- 3
Communities value wildlife
biodiversity is protected
- 4
Risks
disease, disturbance, unequal benefits and dependence on tourism
Then back to step 1
Benefits
- Generates income
- Funds protection of areas
- Supports local communities
Drawbacks
- Disease transmission and disturbance
- Unequal sharing of benefits
- Loss of access to land
- Dependence on tourism
Give one benefit and one drawback of ecotourism.
Try an exam question
Distinguish between in situ and ex situ conservation, and state one limitation of ex situ conservation.
[3 marks]
- [1]In situ conservation protects species within their natural habitat, e.g. reserves or national parks.
- [1]Ex situ conservation keeps species outside their natural habitat, e.g. zoos or seed banks.
- [1]Limitation of ex situ: the habitat and ecological interactions are not conserved (or it is costly, or some species cannot be bred in captivity).
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
How is the Svalbard Global Seed Vault best classified?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
How is the Svalbard Global Seed Vault best classified?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme