Edexcel GCSE Biology
Natural Selection & Evolution
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A population of moths in a polluted woodland contains both pale and dark forms. Over several decades, soot from nearby factories darkened the tree bark. Bird predators hunt the moths by sight. Records show the proportion of dark moths rose from 2% to 95% of the population over this period.(a)Which statement best explains why the dark moths increased in proportion?[1 mark]
- ADark moths were better camouflaged against the sooty bark, so fewer were eaten by birds
- BDark moths mutated more often than pale moths
- CPale moths deliberately changed colour to survive
- DBirds preferred to eat dark moths, reducing pale moth numbers
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(b)Which term describes the dark colouring of the moths in this scenario, which gave them a survival advantage once the bark darkened?[1 mark]- AA learned behaviour
- BAn advantageous variation
- CAn acquired characteristic passed on by practice
- DA vestigial structure
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(c)Using Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection, explain how the proportion of dark moths increased from 2% to 95% over several decades.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] dark moths were better camouflaged on the dark bark, so were less likely to be eaten by birds
[1] more dark moths survived to reproduce and passed on the allele for dark colour, so it became more common over generationsTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2A hospital ward treated patients with the antibiotic methicillin for many years. Over time, doctors noticed that infections caused by the bacterium *Staphylococcus aureus* became increasingly difficult to treat with this antibiotic, and a resistant strain (MRSA) became common in the ward.(a)What is the most likely explanation for the rise of MRSA in the ward?[1 mark]
- AThe resistant bacteria copied resistance genes from the patients' cells
- BMethicillin caused the bacteria to develop resistance in response to treatment
- CA few bacteria already had a mutation giving resistance, and methicillin killed the non-resistant bacteria, leaving resistant ones to multiply
- DAll bacteria in the ward became resistant at the same time by chance
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)Which of the following would most effectively reduce the further spread of antibiotic-resistant bacteria such as MRSA in the ward?[1 mark]- AStopping antibiotic courses as soon as symptoms improve
- BIncreasing the dose of methicillin given to every patient
- CUsing methicillin to treat viral infections as well as bacterial ones
- DPrescribing antibiotics only when necessary and completing the full course each time
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Explain, in terms of natural selection, how the use of methicillin in the ward led to the emergence of MRSA as a common resistant strain.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] mutation had produced a few bacteria that were resistant to methicillin
Accept: variation in the bacterial population
[1] methicillin killed non-resistant bacteria, so the resistant ones survived, reproduced and passed on the resistance allele, making MRSA commonTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3Palaeontologists compared three human-relative fossils: Ardi, dated to 4.4 million years ago, with a mixture of climbing and upright-walking features; Lucy, dated to 3.2 million years ago, with a pelvis and leg bones more suited to upright walking than Ardi's; and a set of fossils found by Richard Leakey, dated to 1.6 million years ago, with a skeleton very similar to modern humans.(a)Explain how these three fossils, considered together, provide evidence for human evolution.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the fossils show gradual change in anatomy over millions of years rather than a sudden appearance of modern humans
[1] the older fossil (Ardi) has a mixture of climbing and walking features, Lucy is better adapted to upright walking and the youngest fossil is very similar to modern humans
[1] fossils can be dated, so they can be placed in order, showing a trend towards modern human features over time(b)Alongside these fossils, archaeologists found stone tools buried in the same rock layers, close to each set of remains. The tools found near the oldest fossils were simple, roughly-shaped flakes, while the tools found near the youngest fossils were more finely shaped and symmetrical.[4 marks]
Explain how dating the rock layers and stone tools alongside the fossils strengthens the evidence for human evolution, and describe what the change in tool design over time suggests about human ancestors.Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] rock layers can be dated, so tools in the same layer as a fossil can be given the same age
[1] tools consistently found with fossils of a similar age at several sites give independent support for the timeline suggested by the fossils
[1] the simple, roughly shaped tools near the oldest fossils suggest early ancestors had only basic toolmaking skills
[1] the finer, symmetrical tools near younger fossils suggest increasing manual dexterity and brain development over time
Accept: increasing intelligenceTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4A student compares the forelimb bones of a human, a bat, a whale and a dog. Despite these animals living in very different environments and using their forelimbs for very different purposes (grasping, flying, swimming and walking), the student notices that all four forelimbs are built from the same basic arrangement of one upper bone, two lower bones, a set of wrist bones, and five digits (the pentadactyl limb).(a)Describe what the pentadactyl limb is, and evaluate why its presence across such different animals is considered strong evidence for the theory of evolution rather than being explained by chance or by each animal separately being designed for its own function.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the pentadactyl limb has one upper bone, two lower bones, wrist bones and five digits
[1] this pattern is found in humans, bats, whales, dogs and many other vertebrates
[1] the limbs are used for very different functions, so the shared structure is not explained by needing the same job done
[1] a shared structure suggests the animals share a common ancestor that had this limb
[1] differences in bone size and shape show natural selection has modified the limb to suit each animal's environment and way of life
[1] evaluation: it is very unlikely such a complex arrangement would arise independently by chance, so common ancestry is a stronger explanation than separate design for each function
Accept: other valid evidence for evolution(b)New genetic analysis techniques allow scientists to compare DNA sequences between organisms far more precisely than earlier methods based only on visible physical features. Using this genetic evidence, scientists proposed replacing the traditional five-kingdom classification system (which grouped organisms mainly by visible characteristics) with a three-domain system based on genetic differences.[6 marks]
Evaluate why genetic analysis led scientists to suggest the three-domain classification system instead of continuing to use the five-kingdom system, and discuss what this change reveals about how scientific classification can develop over time.Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the five-kingdom system classified organisms mainly by visible features
[1] genetic analysis compares DNA or RNA sequences directly, showing similarities and differences that cannot be seen from appearance
[1] it showed that some organisms grouped together as single-celled organisms were genetically very different from each other
[1] so organisms were reclassified into three domains, splitting these groups apart, instead of five kingdoms
[1] evaluation: genetic evidence is more reliable than appearance, because unrelated organisms can look alike (convergent evolution) but have very different genes
[1] this shows classification is not fixed and is revised as new evidence and techniques become availableTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions