A3.2 Classification and cladistics
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Classification handles the immense diversity of species and lets features be predicted.
- A clade is a common ancestor and all its descendants; cladistics uses unranked clades.
- DNA and protein sequences are the most objective evidence; the molecular clock estimates divergence times.
- A cladogram is chosen by parsimony: the fewest sequence changes.
- Woese’s rRNA work (1977) created the three domains: Archaea, Bacteria and Eukarya.
- 1
Kingdom
broadest
- 2
Phylum
- 3
Class
- 4
Order
- 5
Family
- 6
Genus
- 7
Species
narrowest
The need for classification
Classification copes with the immense diversity of species and lets features be predicted, but fixed ranks are arbitrary.
Classification is needed because of the immense diversity of species, and it makes further study easier: features can be predicted and organisms identified. The traditional hierarchy does not always match evolutionary divergence.
Nature of science: a fixed ranking is arbitrary because variation is gradual. Cladistics uses unranked clades, a paradigm shift.
- 1
Kingdom
broadest
- 2
Phylum
- 3
Class
- 4
Order
- 5
Family
- 6
Genus
- 7
Species
narrowest
Why do cladists avoid fixed ranks?
Clades and evolutionary classification
A clade is a common ancestor and all its descendants; sequence data are the most objective way to find them.
A clade is a group with a common ancestor and shared characteristics. In an evolutionary classification, features can be predicted because they are shared within the clade.
The most objective evidence is the base sequences of genes or amino acid sequences of proteins. Morphology can mislead because of convergent evolution.
- 1
Compare gene or protein sequences
the most objective evidence
- 2
Group by a common ancestor
a clade includes the ancestor and all descendants
- 3
Predict shared features
features are shared within the clade
- 4
Beware morphology
convergent evolution can mislead
- Cladea common ancestor and all its descendants
Sequence data
- Most objective
- Reflects common ancestry
Morphology
- Can be used
- May reflect convergent evolution
Why are DNA sequences considered more objective evidence than morphology?
The molecular clock
Sequence differences accumulate gradually, so counting them estimates when two groups diverged, but only roughly.
Sequence differences accumulate gradually, so the number of differences between two groups estimates when they diverged: the molecular clock.
It gives only estimates because mutation rates are affected by generation time, population size and the intensity of selection.
- Ratedifferences ÷ known divergence time
- Timedifferences ÷ rate
Worked example
Two species differ at 12 base positions in a gene. A similar pair that diverged 20 million years ago (known from fossils) differ at 8 positions. Estimate when the first pair diverged.
- 1
Rate = differences ÷ time = 8 ÷ 20 = 0.4 differences per million years.
- 2
Time = differences ÷ rate = 12 ÷ 0.4 = 30 million years.
Why is a molecular clock only an estimate?
Constructing cladograms
Cladograms are built from sequences and the most parsimonious one, with the fewest changes, is chosen.
Cladograms are built from base or amino acid sequences. Parsimony analysis selects the most probable cladogram: the one needing the smallest number of sequence changes.
The root is the common ancestor of all shown. A node is a branching point representing a hypothetical common ancestor. Terminal branches end at the organisms. Any node plus all it branches into is a clade.
Which cladogram does parsimony analysis select?
Reclassification: figworts
Chloroplast gene sequences showed that flower similarity in the figwort family was convergent, so many genera were moved.
Cladistics tests whether traditional groups match evolutionary relationships. The figwort family was grouped by flower structure. Chloroplast gene sequences showed that similar morphology arose by convergent evolution, and over half the genera, such as foxgloves and snapdragons, moved to other families such as the plantain family.
Nature of science: claims can be falsified. You do not need the details.
- 1
Grouped by flowers
traditional classification by structure
- 2
Sequences compared
chloroplast genes examined
- 3
Convergence found
similar flowers evolved independently
- 4
Genera moved
to other families, such as the plantain family
What did chloroplast gene sequences show about the figwort family?
The three domains
In 1977 Woese used rRNA sequences to divide life into Archaea, Bacteria and Eukarya, a level above kingdoms.
In 1977 Carl Woese used ribosomal RNA base sequences to classify all organisms into three domains: Archaea, Bacteria and Eukarya. This added a taxonomic level above kingdoms.
rRNA is suitable because it occurs in every organism and changes slowly.
- 1
1977: Carl Woese compares ribosomal RNA
present in every organism, changes slowly
- 2
Archaea
no nucleus; as distinct from bacteria as from eukaryotes
- 3
Bacteria
no nucleus; prokaryotes
- 4
Eukarya
nucleus: animals, plants, fungi and protists
| Archaea | Bacteria | Eukarya | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nucleus | No nucleus | No nucleus | Nucleus |
| Notes | rRNA shows they are as distinct from bacteria as from eukaryotes | Prokaryotes | Animals, plants, fungi and protists |
Archaea
- Nucleus:
- No nucleus
- Notes:
- rRNA shows they are as distinct from bacteria as from eukaryotes
Bacteria
- Nucleus:
- No nucleus
- Notes:
- Prokaryotes
Eukarya
- Nucleus:
- Nucleus
- Notes:
- Animals, plants, fungi and protists
Why was rRNA a good molecule for comparing all organisms?
Try an exam question
Explain how a cladogram is constructed from sequence data, and what is meant by parsimony.
[4 marks]
- [1]Base or amino acid sequences of the organisms are compared.
- [1]The differences are used to group organisms that share the most similarities, showing common ancestors.
- [1]Nodes represent hypothetical common ancestors and terminal branches the organisms.
- [1]Parsimony selects the cladogram that needs the smallest number of sequence changes.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Why did the traditional classification wrongly group these genera in one family?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Why did the traditional classification wrongly group these genera in one family?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme