A4.1 Evolution and speciation
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Evolution is change in the heritable characteristics of a population; acquired traits (Lamarckism) are not evolution.
- Evidence: sequence data, selective breeding, and homologous structures such as the pentadactyl limb.
- Speciation needs reproductive isolation then differential selection.
- Allopatric speciation has a geographical barrier; sympatric speciation does not.
- Plants can form new species abruptly by hybridisation and polyploidy.
- 1
One population
a single species with a shared gene pool
- 2
Isolation
a barrier stops gene flow
- 3
Differential selection
different environments favour different alleles
- 4
Divergence
gene pools so different they cannot interbreed: two species
What evolution is
Evolution is change in the heritable characteristics of a population, which is why acquired characteristics do not count.
Evolution is change in the heritable characteristics of a population. This distinguishes it from Lamarckism: characteristics acquired in life, such as muscles built by exercise, are not genetic.
Nature of science: natural selection explains a very broad range of observations and is unlikely to be falsified, but no theory can be formally proved. It is a pragmatic truth, still called a theory.
- 1
Variation
individuals differ in heritable characteristics
- 2
Differential survival
better-adapted individuals survive and reproduce more
- 3
Alleles passed on
their alleles become more common
- 4
Population changes
acquired characteristics are not inherited
- Evolutionchange in heritable characteristics of a population
A bodybuilder’s children are born with larger muscles than average. Is this evolution?
Evidence for evolution
Sequence data, selective breeding and homologous structures all show common ancestry and heritable change.
Sequence data from DNA, RNA and proteins show common ancestry: fewer differences mean a more recent ancestor. Selective breeding, such as dog breeds from the grey wolf and crops from wild cabbage, shows how rapidly heritable change occurs.
Homologous structures such as the pentadactyl limb have the same bones in different functions. Analogous structures have the same function but different origin.
- 1
Sequence data
fewer DNA differences mean a more recent common ancestor
- 2
Selective breeding
dog breeds from the grey wolf show rapid heritable change
- 3
Homologous structures
e.g. the pentadactyl limb shows common ancestry
| Homologous | Analogous | |
|---|---|---|
| Evolutionary origin | Same | Different |
| Function | Often different | Same |
| Example | Human arm and bat wing | Bat wing and butterfly wing |
Homologous
- Evolutionary origin:
- Same
- Function:
- Often different
- Example:
- Human arm and bat wing
Analogous
- Evolutionary origin:
- Different
- Function:
- Same
- Example:
- Bat wing and butterfly wing
Whale flippers and bat wings contain the same bones. This is evidence of
Speciation by isolation
New species arise only when a species splits: isolated populations then diverge under differential selection.
New species arise only by splitting of a pre-existing species. Gradual change in one lineage is not speciation.
Populations must be reproductively isolated (no gene flow) and differential selection makes allele frequencies diverge. The Congo River separates bonobos (south) from common chimpanzees (north); neither can swim.
- 1
One population
a single species with a shared gene pool
- 2
Isolation
a barrier stops gene flow
- 3
Differential selection
different environments favour different alleles
- 4
Divergence
gene pools so different they cannot interbreed: two species
Why is gradual change within one unbroken lineage not speciation?
HL: Allopatric and sympatric
Allopatric speciation happens in separated populations; sympatric speciation happens in the same place.
Reproductive isolation may be geographic, behavioural (different courtship) or temporal (breeding at different times).
Allopatric speciation occurs in different places, separated by a barrier. Sympatric speciation occurs in the same place, through behavioural or temporal isolation, or polyploidy. Both need isolation then divergence of gene pools; the difference is whether a geographical barrier is involved.
- 1
Population is split
by a geographic barrier
- 2
No gene flow
each group faces different selection pressures
- 3
Populations diverge
adaptations and genetic differences build up
- 4
Reproductive isolation
two separate species
| Allopatric | Sympatric | |
|---|---|---|
| Where | Different places | Same place |
| Isolation | Geographical barrier | Behavioural or temporal isolation, or polyploidy |
Allopatric
- Where:
- Different places
- Isolation:
- Geographical barrier
Sympatric
- Where:
- Same place
- Isolation:
- Behavioural or temporal isolation, or polyploidy
Two populations of insects in the same field breed in different seasons and diverge. This is
HL: Adaptive radiation
One ancestral species rapidly diversifies into many, each adapted to a different niche, so close relatives coexist without competing.
Adaptive radiation is the rapid diversification of one ancestral species into many, each adapted to a different niche. Species using different resources can coexist without competing, which increases biodiversity where there are vacant niches.
- 1
One ancestral species
enters an area with vacant niches
- 2
Rapid diversification
variation and natural selection
- 3
Many species
each adapted to a different niche
- 4
Coexistence
little competition, so biodiversity rises
| Cichlid fish | Darwin’s finches | |
|---|---|---|
| Where | African Great Lakes | Galápagos |
| Adaptation | Different jaws for algae, snails, fish | Different beaks for seeds, insects, cacti |
Cichlid fish
- Where:
- African Great Lakes
- Adaptation:
- Different jaws for algae, snails, fish
Darwin’s finches
- Where:
- Galápagos
- Adaptation:
- Different beaks for seeds, insects, cacti
Why can many closely related finch species coexist on the Galápagos?
HL: Hybrids and polyploidy
Barriers to hybridisation and hybrid sterility keep species separate, but in plants hybridisation plus polyploidy can make a new species in one or two generations.
Species stay separate through barriers to hybridization, such as species-specific courtship behaviour, and sterility of interspecific hybrids: a mule is sterile because its horse and donkey chromosomes cannot pair in meiosis.
In plants, a sterile hybrid whose chromosome number doubles (polyploidy) becomes fertile and is instantly isolated from both parents, as in Persicaria.
- 1
Hybridization
two species cross; hybrid is sterile
- 2
Chromosome doubling
each chromosome now has a partner
- 3
Fertile polyploid
meiosis works
- 4
New species
isolated from both parents at once
Why is chromosome doubling needed to make the hybrid fertile?
Try an exam question
Explain how polyploidy can lead to the formation of a new plant species in one or two generations.
[4 marks]
- [1]Two species hybridise and the hybrid is sterile because its chromosomes are not homologous.
- [1]The chromosome number doubles (polyploidy).
- [1]Every chromosome now has a partner, so meiosis works and the plant is fertile.
- [1]The polyploid cannot produce fertile offspring with either parent, so it is instantly reproductively isolated.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which statement best explains why mules are almost always sterile?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which statement best explains why mules are almost always sterile?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme