D4.2 Stability and change
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Stable ecosystems need continuous energy supply, nutrient recycling, genetic diversity and tolerable climate.
- A tipping point is where a system switches to a new, self-sustaining state.
- A keystone species has a disproportionate effect on its community.
- Sustainable harvesting takes less than the rate of replacement.
- Biomagnification concentrates persistent toxins at higher trophic levels.
Stability and tipping points
Stable ecosystems have energy, recycled nutrients, genetic diversity and tolerable climate; too much damage can cause a tipping point.
Stability is a property of natural ecosystems; some rainforests and deserts have persisted for millions of years. Requirements:
- a continuous supply of energy (usually sunlight);
- recycling of nutrients by decomposers;
- genetic diversity, so populations can adapt;
- climatic variables within organisms' tolerance.
Amazon rainfall depends on a large area of forest: transpiration cools the air and drives air flows, and the vapour falls as rain inland. Too much clearance may switch forest to savanna: a tipping point.
- 1
Transpiration
forest returns water vapour to the air
- 2
Cooling and air flow
vapour is carried inland
- 3
Rain
falls further inland, supporting forest
- 4
Too much forest lost
forest may dry and switch to savanna
Worked example
Forest area falls from 4.10 to 3.28 million km². Calculate the percentage change.
- 1
Change = 3.28 − 4.10 = −0.82.
- 2
−0.82 ÷ 4.10 = −0.20.
- 3
× 100 gives −20 %.
Which is NOT a requirement for ecosystem stability?
Mesocosms and keystone species
Mesocosms test variables in a small sealed ecosystem; a keystone species has a disproportionate impact, so removing it risks collapse.
A mesocosm is a small experimental ecosystem used to test how variables affect stability. Sealed glass vessels are better than open tanks because matter cannot enter or leave while light energy still can. Aquatic or microbial mesocosms work better than terrestrial ones, and animals must be cared for under IB guidelines.
A keystone species has a disproportionate impact on community structure relative to its abundance. Removing it risks ecosystem collapse.
- 1
Otters eat urchins
so urchin numbers stay low
- 2
Kelp is grazed less
so the kelp forest survives
- 3
Kelp supports many species
so the community stays diverse
Why are sealed mesocosms preferable to open ones?
Sustainable harvesting
Harvesting is sustainable when the rate of harvesting is lower than the rate of replacement.
Harvesting is sustainable if the rate of harvesting is lower than the rate of replacement.
- Terrestrial plant: wild Brazil nuts gathered from forest trees. Survey tree age structure to check enough seedlings establish to replace old trees.
- Marine fish: Atlantic cod. Estimate stock size (surveys, catch data, age structure) and set quotas.
Northern cod off Newfoundland collapsed by 1992 through overfishing.
| Brazil nuts | Atlantic cod | |
|---|---|---|
| Assessed by | Survey tree age structure | Estimate stock size, set quotas |
| Sustainable if | Enough seedlings to replace old trees | Catch below replacement |
Brazil nuts
- Assessed by:
- Survey tree age structure
- Sustainable if:
- Enough seedlings to replace old trees
Atlantic cod
- Assessed by:
- Estimate stock size, set quotas
- Sustainable if:
- Catch below replacement
What does a quota control?
Agriculture and eutrophication
Erosion, leaching, inputs, pollution and carbon footprint limit sustainability; fertiliser leaching causes eutrophication.
Sustainability of agriculture depends on soil erosion, leaching of nutrients, supply of fertilisers and other inputs, pollution by agrochemicals, and the carbon footprint of farming.
Eutrophication: fertiliser nitrate and phosphate leach into water, causing an algal bloom. When the algae die, aerobic bacteria decompose them, biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) rises and dissolved oxygen falls, so fish and invertebrates die.
- 1
Fertiliser leaches
nitrate and phosphate enter water
- 2
Algal bloom
rapid algal growth
- 3
Algae die
aerobic bacteria decompose them
- 4
High BOD
biochemical oxygen demand rises
- 5
Oxygen falls
fish and invertebrates die
Why does dissolved oxygen fall during eutrophication?
Biomagnification and plastics
Persistent toxins become more concentrated at each higher trophic level; plastics persist and harm animals.
Biomagnification: persistent toxins that are stored and not excreted become more concentrated at each higher trophic level, because consumers eat large amounts from the level below. DDT thinned the eggshells of birds of prey; mercury is high in tuna and other top predators.
Plastics are non-biodegradable. Macroplastics entangle animals and block guts (albatross chicks); microplastics are eaten by filter feeders and plankton and can carry toxins. Media coverage changed public perception and drove action such as bag charges.
DDT
- Thinned eggshells of birds of prey
Mercury
- High in tuna and top predators
Macroplastics
- Entangle animals, block guts
Microplastics
- Eaten by plankton, may carry toxins
Why do top predators have the highest toxin concentrations?
Rewilding
Rewilding restores natural processes by reintroducing keystone predators, reconnecting habitats and reducing human impact.
Rewilding restores natural processes. Methods:
- reintroducing apex predators and other keystone species (wolves in Yellowstone);
- re-establishing connectivity between habitats over large areas;
- minimising human impact, including by ecological management.
Example: Hinewai Reserve, New Zealand. Former sheep farmland on Banks Peninsula was left to regenerate with minimal intervention, and native forest has returned.
- 1
Apex predator returns
wolves reintroduced to Yellowstone
- 2
Grazing pressure falls
prey such as elk browse less in some places
- 3
Vegetation recovers
more trees and shrubs grow
- 4
Ecosystem recovers
more habitat for other species
Reintroduce apex predators
- Restores keystone effects
Reconnect habitats
- Allows movement over large areas
Minimise human impact
- Lets regeneration happen
Which is an example of rewilding?
Try an exam question
Outline how eutrophication leads to the death of fish.
[4 marks]
- [1]Nitrate and phosphate from fertiliser leach into water.
- [1]This causes rapid algal growth (an algal bloom).
- [1]When algae die, aerobic bacteria decompose them, raising biochemical oxygen demand.
- [1]Dissolved oxygen falls, so fish die.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
What was the percentage change in forest area between the original extent and 2022?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
What was the percentage change in forest area between the original extent and 2022?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme