A4.1 Evolution and speciation
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Evolution is change in the heritable characteristics of a population over generations.
- Lamarckism (acquired characteristics are inherited) is not evolution by natural selection.
- Fewer differences in DNA or protein sequences mean a more recent common ancestor.
- Homologous structures share an origin; analogous structures share a function through convergent evolution.
- Speciation needs reproductive isolation and differential selection.
What evolution is
Evolution is a change in the heritable characteristics of a population, not in individuals.
Evolution is change in the heritable characteristics of a population over generations. Heritable means the change is in alleles, so it is passed on. Population means individuals do not evolve; populations do.
This distinguishes Darwinian evolution from Lamarckism, the idea that characteristics acquired during life (bigger muscles, a cut tail, a pruned plant) are passed to offspring. Acquired changes that are not genetic are not evolution.
- 1
Variation
heritable differences between individuals
- 2
Selection
some individuals survive and reproduce more
- 3
Alleles passed on
in greater numbers to the next generation
- 4
Allele frequencies change
the population evolves
Then back to step 1
| Evolution | Lamarckism | |
|---|---|---|
| What changes | Heritable characteristics (alleles) | Acquired characteristics, not genetic |
| Acts on | Populations | Individuals |
Evolution
- What changes:
- Heritable characteristics (alleles)
- Acts on:
- Populations
Lamarckism
- What changes:
- Acquired characteristics, not genetic
- Acts on:
- Individuals
Which of these is an example of evolution?
Evolution as a theory
The theory of evolution by natural selection explains a very broad range of observations but, like any scientific theory, cannot be formally proved.
The theory of evolution by natural selection predicts and explains a very broad range of observations and is unlikely ever to be falsified. But no scientific theory can be formally proved true by correspondence, because a future observation could always contradict it. Evolution is therefore a pragmatic truth.
In science, "theory" means a well-tested explanation, not a guess.
1831
Voyage of the Beagle
Darwin begins five years of observations
1858
Darwin and Wallace
natural selection presented to the Linnean Society
1859
On the Origin of Species
Darwin publishes the theory
1953
Structure of DNA
explains how heritable information is stored
- Scientific theorya well-tested explanation, not a guess
- Evolutiona pragmatic truth: it cannot be formally proved
Why is evolution still called a theory?
Evidence from sequences
Many identical positions in shared molecules show common ancestry, and fewer differences mean a more recent ancestor.
Base sequences in DNA or RNA and amino acid sequences in proteins give powerful evidence of common ancestry. Very different organisms share the same molecules (cytochrome c, ribosomal RNA) with many identical positions, which is unlikely by chance.
Mutations accumulate over time, so the fewer the differences, the more recent the common ancestor. Because the genetic code is degenerate, DNA sequences can differ even when protein sequences are identical, so DNA comparisons are more sensitive.
| Few differences | Many differences | |
|---|---|---|
| Number of differences | Low | High |
| Common ancestor | Recent | Long ago |
Few differences
- Number of differences:
- Low
- Common ancestor:
- Recent
Many differences
- Number of differences:
- High
- Common ancestor:
- Long ago
Species X and Y differ at 3 positions in a protein; X and Z differ at 25. Which pair diverged more recently?
Evidence from selective breeding
Selective breeding shows how rapidly evolutionary change can occur when humans choose parents with desired heritable traits.
Selective (artificial) breeding of domesticated animals and crop plants shows how rapidly evolutionary change can occur. Humans choose parents with desired heritable traits each generation.
Examples: dog breeds from the grey wolf; cabbage, kale, broccoli, cauliflower, Brussels sprouts and kohlrabi from wild cabbage (Brassica oleracea). The variation between breeds and varieties, and between them and the wild species, arose within a few thousand years.
- 1
Choose parents
with the desired heritable trait
- 2
Breed them
only the chosen individuals reproduce
- 3
Offspring inherit alleles
the trait is more common
- 4
Select again
repeat over many generations
Then back to step 1
Selective breeding shows that evolutionary change can be...
Homologous and analogous structures
Homologous structures come from a common ancestor; analogous structures share a function but arose by convergent evolution.
Homologous structures have the same basic structure because they were inherited from a common ancestor, even if their functions differ. The pentadactyl limb (one upper bone, two lower bones, wrist bones, palm bones and five digits) is in the human arm, whale flipper, bat wing and frog leg.
Analogous structures have the same function but different evolutionary origins. They arise by convergent evolution, when similar selection pressures act on unrelated lineages: wings of insects and birds, streamlined shapes of sharks and dolphins, eyes of octopuses and vertebrates.
- 1
Homologous: common ancestor
e.g. the pentadactyl limb of a bat, whale and human
- 2
Different functions
flying, swimming, grasping, same basic bone plan
- 3
Analogous: separate origins
e.g. bat wing and insect wing
- 4
Same function
convergent evolution, different structure
| Homologous | Analogous | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Common ancestor | Different ancestors |
| Function | Often different | Same |
| Caused by | Divergent evolution | Convergent evolution |
| Example | Human arm and bat wing | Insect wing and bird wing |
Homologous
- Origin:
- Common ancestor
- Function:
- Often different
- Caused by:
- Divergent evolution
- Example:
- Human arm and bat wing
Analogous
- Origin:
- Different ancestors
- Function:
- Same
- Caused by:
- Convergent evolution
- Example:
- Insect wing and bird wing
Dolphin and shark streamlined bodies are...
Speciation
Speciation splits one species into two, needing reproductive isolation and different selection pressures.
New species arise only by speciation: the splitting of a pre-existing species into two. Gradual change within a single lineage is not speciation.
Two things are needed. Reproductive isolation: the populations stop interbreeding, so there is no gene flow; geographical isolation by a river, mountain range or sea is one way. Differential selection: different environments impose different selection pressures, so allele frequencies diverge until the populations can no longer interbreed.
Example: the Congo River separates common chimpanzees (north) from bonobos (south).
- 1
One population
interbreeds freely
- 2
Barrier forms
river, mountain or sea splits it
- 3
No gene flow
the populations are reproductively isolated
- 4
Differential selection
different environments favour different alleles
- 5
Two species
they can no longer interbreed
Which is required for speciation?
Try an exam question
Explain how geographical isolation can lead to the formation of two species.
[4 marks]
- [1]A barrier such as a river, mountain range or sea splits one population, so there is no gene flow between the parts.
- [1]The populations are in different environments, which impose different selection pressures (differential selection).
- [1]Allele frequencies in the populations diverge over generations.
- [1]Eventually the populations can no longer interbreed, so they are two species.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which conclusion is best supported by these data?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which conclusion is best supported by these data?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme