D4.3 Climate change
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Human activity is raising atmospheric carbon dioxide and methane.
- Ice cores show a positive correlation between CO₂ and temperature, but correlation is not causation.
- Positive feedback loops amplify warming and can reach tipping points.
- Warming changes polar habitats, ocean currents, species ranges and coral reefs.
- Carbon sequestration stores carbon by afforestation, regeneration and peat restoration.
Causes and correlation
Human activities raise carbon dioxide and methane, and ice cores show they rise and fall with temperature.
Human (anthropogenic) activities are increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide (fossil fuels, deforestation) and methane (ruminant livestock, rice paddies, landfill, gas leaks). Both are greenhouse gases.
Antarctic ice cores show a positive correlation between carbon dioxide and global temperature over hundreds of thousands of years. A negative correlation would mean one falls as the other rises.
Correlation is not causation; other evidence, such as carbon dioxide absorbing infrared radiation, confirms the causal link.
Carbon dioxide
- Burning fossil fuels
- Deforestation
Methane
- Ruminant livestock, rice paddies
- Landfill, gas extraction leaks
Ice cores show CO₂ and temperature rising together. This is...
Positive feedback and tipping points
Positive feedbacks reinforce warming, and a tipping point switches a system to a new self-sustaining state.
A positive feedback reinforces the change that caused it. In global warming: CO₂ released from the warming deep ocean; loss of reflective snow and ice; faster decomposition of peat and thawing permafrost; methane release from melting permafrost; more droughts and forest fires.
A tipping point is reached when a system changes to a new state that sustains itself. In boreal forest, warmth and drought cause browning and intense fires that burn legacy carbon, switching the forest from net carbon accumulation to net carbon loss.
- 1
Warming
ice and snow melt
- 2
Less reflective surface
darker land and sea exposed
- 3
More radiation absorbed
the surface warms further
Then back to step 1
Which is a positive feedback in global warming?
Polar habitats
Melting landfast ice and sea ice removes breeding and resting platforms.
Melting of landfast ice and sea ice destroys polar habitats.
- Emperor penguins (Aptenodytes forsteri) breed on landfast ice. Early break-out before chicks have waterproof feathers causes breeding failure.
- Walruses rest on sea ice above their feeding grounds. As it retreats they haul out on crowded beaches far from food.
| Emperor penguin | Walrus | |
|---|---|---|
| Habitat | Breeds on landfast ice | Rests on sea ice |
| Effect of melting | Early break-out: breeding failure | Crowded beaches far from food |
Emperor penguin
- Habitat:
- Breeds on landfast ice
- Effect of melting:
- Early break-out: breeding failure
Walrus
- Habitat:
- Rests on sea ice
- Effect of melting:
- Crowded beaches far from food
Why does early ice break-out harm emperor penguin chicks?
Currents and range shifts
Warming alters nutrient upwelling and pushes species poleward and upslope.
Changes in ocean currents alter the timing and extent of nutrient upwelling. Warmer surface water forms a stable layer that stops nutrient-rich deep water rising, decreasing primary production by phytoplankton and reducing energy flow through marine food chains.
As temperatures rise, temperate species show poleward and upslope range shifts: tropical montane birds in New Guinea have moved upslope, and many North American trees show range contraction and northward spread.
- 1
Surface warms
forms a stable layer
- 2
Upwelling reduced
deep nutrients cannot rise
- 3
Less phytoplankton
primary production falls
- 4
Food chains affected
less energy flows through them
Why does a stable warm surface layer reduce primary production?
Coral reef collapse
Warming causes bleaching and CO₂ causes acidification, both killing corals that build the reef.
Higher carbon dioxide dissolves in sea water, causing ocean acidification, which suppresses calcification (deposition of calcium carbonate).
Higher temperatures cause coral bleaching: corals expel their symbiotic algae (zooxanthellae) and may starve.
Corals build the reef structure that other species depend on, so loss of corals collapses the reef ecosystem.
- 1
Warmer, more acidic water
temperature and dissolved CO₂ rise
- 2
Bleaching, less calcification
corals lose algae and build less skeleton
- 3
Corals die
reef structure is lost
- 4
Ecosystem collapses
dependent species lose habitat
What causes coral bleaching?
Carbon sequestration
Afforestation, forest regeneration and restoring peat-forming wetlands store carbon.
Carbon can be removed and stored by afforestation (planting trees where there was no forest), forest regeneration and restoring peat-forming wetlands. Peat forms in waterlogged soils where decomposition is slow.
Scientists debate which approach is better. Plantations of non-native trees take up carbon fast but have low biodiversity and may be vulnerable. Rewilding with native species is slower but more diverse and resilient.
| Non-native plantation | Rewilding with natives | |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon uptake | Fast carbon uptake | Slower uptake |
| Drawbacks or benefits | Low biodiversity, vulnerable | More diverse and resilient |
Non-native plantation
- Carbon uptake:
- Fast carbon uptake
- Drawbacks or benefits:
- Low biodiversity, vulnerable
Rewilding with natives
- Carbon uptake:
- Slower uptake
- Drawbacks or benefits:
- More diverse and resilient
Why is peat a good carbon store?
Try an exam question
Explain how loss of polar ice is an example of positive feedback.
[3 marks]
- [1]Warming melts ice and snow, which reflect solar radiation.
- [1]Darker land and sea are exposed and absorb more radiation.
- [1]This warms the surface further, melting more ice.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which statement best describes the relationship between carbon dioxide concentration and temperature in the ice-core record?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which statement best describes the relationship between carbon dioxide concentration and temperature in the ice-core record?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme