IB Environmental Systems and Societies HL
6.2 Climate change — causes and impacts
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1The Great Barrier Reef off Queensland, Australia, has suffered mass coral bleaching in several recent summers, including 2016, 2017, 2020 and 2022, when sea temperatures stayed well above the normal summer maximum for several weeks. In bleaching, corals expel the symbiotic algae that live in their tissues and supply most of their food and colour. Reefs given several years to recover can regrow, but repeated events have left some sections with much lower coral cover. The reef supports tourism and fishing businesses along the Queensland coast.(a)What causes coral bleaching on the Great Barrier Reef?[1 mark]
- AIncreased ultraviolet radiation from ozone depletion
- BOverfishing of herbivorous fish
- CSea temperatures remaining abnormally high for several weeks, causing corals to expel their algae
- DAcid rain falling directly on the reef
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)Which statement about the resilience of the Great Barrier Reef is correct?[1 mark]- AResilience is unaffected by repeated bleaching
- BResilience is the number of tourists the reef can support
- CA reef with high resilience never changes
- DRepeated bleaching events with little time for recovery reduce the reef's resilience
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Explain how repeated mass bleaching could affect the people of coastal Queensland.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] fewer tourists visit a damaged, colourless reef, so income and jobs in tourism fall
Accept: tour operators, hotels and dive businesses lose money
[1] loss of coral reduces habitat and nursery areas for fish, so catches and fishers' incomes fall
Accept: reduced protection of the coast from waves, leading to erosion and storm damage
Do not accept: fish die with no link to coral habitatTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2Researchers reconstruct past climates using (i) pollen grains identified at different depths in a peat core from a Scottish bog, (ii) the ratio of oxygen isotopes in Antarctic ice cores and (iii) the widths of annual rings in long-lived oak trunks. In addition, weather stations, satellites and observatories record temperature and gas concentrations directly. The team also tests a global climate model by running it with conditions from past decades and comparing its output with the records.(a)Which of these is an indirect measurement (proxy) of past climate?[1 mark]
- ATemperature recorded by a weather station
- BPollen preserved in a peat core
- CCarbon dioxide concentration measured at an observatory
- DRainfall recorded by radar
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)What is hindcasting?[1 mark]- ARunning a climate model using past conditions and comparing its output with recorded past climate to test its validity
- BPredicting climate for the next century
- CCounting tree rings to find the age of a tree
- DMeasuring greenhouse gas concentrations in ice
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)Explain how pollen in a peat core can provide information about past climates.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] plant species are adapted to particular temperature and rainfall, so the types of pollen show what the vegetation, and so the climate, was
Accept: pollen of cold-tolerant species indicates cooler conditions and pollen of warm-climate species indicates warmer conditions
[1] peat forms in layers with the oldest deepest, so changes in pollen with depth show how the climate changed over time
Accept: dating the layers gives the timing of changesTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3In 2022 floods in Pakistan affected about 33 million people and killed more than 1 700; roughly a third of the country was under water, and many poorer rural households lost homes, crops and livestock. In 2022 Pakistan emitted under 1% of global carbon dioxide emissions, about 1 tonne per person per year, while the United States emitted about 13% of the global total, about 14 tonnes per person per year.(a)Describe how the 2022 floods affected society at different scales and how socio-economic conditions influenced the impact.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] household scale: homes, crops and livestock were lost, removing food and income
[1] national scale: more than 1 700 deaths, damaged infrastructure and 33 million people affected strained the economy and services
Accept: any valid national or regional effect, e.g. loss of farmland, pressure on health services
[1] socio-economic conditions: poorer rural households had fewer savings, less insurance and lower capacity to recover (lower resilience)
Accept: poverty increased vulnerability(b)(HL) Using the data, discuss the political and economic implications of the fact that countries differ in their responsibility for and vulnerability to climate change.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] US per person emissions are about 14 times Pakistan's (14 ÷ 1), yet Pakistan suffered severe damage, so the least responsible are often the most vulnerable
Accept: US 13% of global emissions against Pakistan under 1%
[1] this raises an issue of equity or justice, as those who caused most of the problem are not those suffering most
[1] political implication: poorer countries demand finance or compensation, e.g. a loss and damage fund, causing tension in climate negotiations
[1] economic implication: recovery and adaptation costs fall on a poor economy, increasing debt unless richer countries provide fundingTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4Climate scientists warn that the Amazon rainforest and the Greenland ice sheet are two parts of the climate system that could pass thresholds. In the Amazon, deforestation and drought reduce transpiration and rainfall, which can turn rainforest into dry savanna. Greenland's ice sheet is melting faster as it loses surface height and reflectivity. A commentator writes: "The Earth has already passed the planetary boundary for climate change, so it is too late for our efforts to make any difference."(a)Evaluate the commentator's claim that, because the planetary boundary for climate change has been passed, efforts to act are pointless.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the boundary has been crossed: concentrations are above 420 ppm against the 350 ppm boundary, so the first part of the claim is supported
Accept: any evidence that the boundary is exceeded
[1] passing a boundary raises the risk of dangerous change but does not mean all outcomes are fixed
[1] impacts increase with the amount of warming, so every reduction in emissions reduces harm
[1] positive feedback loops (e.g. ice-albedo, permafrost) mean delay makes warming harder to stop, so action is more urgent
[1] mitigation and adaptation can both still reduce suffering and protect resilience
[1] conclusion that the claim is not justified, with a perspective, e.g. technocentric emphasis on innovation or ecocentric emphasis on urgency
Accept: any reasoned conclusion supported by the points above(b)(HL) Explain what is meant by a tipping point and how tipping cascades could develop in the climate system.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] a tipping point is a critical threshold beyond which a system changes to a new equilibrium
[1] the change is often self-reinforcing (positive feedback) and difficult or impossible to reverse
[1] Amazon: deforestation and drought reduce transpiration and rainfall, so more forest dies and rainforest changes to savanna
[1] Greenland: melting lowers the ice surface and its reflectivity (albedo), so melting accelerates and adds to sea-level rise
[1] a cascade occurs when passing one tipping point pushes other parts of the system towards their thresholds
Accept: meltwater and warming affecting ocean circulation, rainfall and forests
[1] local systems also have tipping points, e.g. a coral reef shifting to algal dominance after repeated bleaching
Accept: any other valid local example, e.g. a lake becoming eutrophicTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions