IB Environmental Systems and Societies HL
HL.b Environmental and ecological economics
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A paper mill on a river sells its paper at a price based only on the cost of wood, labour and energy. The mill discharges untreated waste water, which has killed fish for 20 km downstream, and downstream fishers have lost income. The mill advertises its paper as "planet-friendly" while continuing to discharge. The government now plans to charge the mill for each tonne of pollutant it releases.(a)Which term describes the allocation of paper by the free market when the mill's price does not include the cost of the damage to the river?[1 mark]
- ATragedy of the commons
- BEco-economic decoupling
- CMarket failure
- DEnvironmental accounting
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(b)What is the practice of advertising paper as "planet-friendly" while continuing to pollute called?[1 mark]- AGreenwashing
- BThe polluter-pays principle
- CDegrowth
- DEnvironmental constitutionalism
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)Explain how charging the mill for each tonne of pollutant could reduce pollution of the river.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] polluter-pays principle: the cost of the damage is added to the mill's costs (the external cost is internalised)
[1] the mill has a financial incentive to cut discharges, e.g. by treating waste water or adopting cleaner technology, to avoid or reduce the chargeTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2Fishers on a large inland lake have open access: there are no licences, no quotas and nobody owns the lake. Over ten years the number of fishers has doubled, while the mean catch per fisher has halved and the fish caught are smaller. Each fisher says that if they stopped fishing, others would simply take their fish.(a)Which concept does the situation on the lake illustrate?[1 mark]
- AGreenwashing
- BThe polluter-pays principle
- CThe circular economy
- DThe tragedy of the commons
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(b)Which statement best explains why individual fishers continue to fish even though the stock is falling?[1 mark]- AFishers are unaware that catches are falling
- BEach fisher gains the full benefit of extra fish while the cost of overfishing is shared by everyone
- CThe lake is privately owned and the owner charges for fish
- DThe fish are too valuable to leave in the lake
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(c)Suggest how giving fishers clearly defined property rights, such as individual or community quotas, could reduce overexploitation of the lake.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] defined rights mean the holder benefits from conserving the fish, so there is an incentive to fish sustainably
Accept: owners have a long-term stake in the stock
[1] quotas limit the catch and others can be excluded, so total catch is controlled and the stock can recover
Accept: no incentive to take fish before others doTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A 500-hectare mangrove wetland lies on the coast of the Mekong Delta in Vietnam. A study of its annual use values per hectare gave: timber and fuelwood 300, storm protection 80. A developer proposes converting the wetland to shrimp ponds, which would earn $1 500 per hectare per year, but ponds like these are typically productive for only about five years before disease and soil acidification force their abandonment. (The values are illustrative.)(a)Calculate the total annual use value of the whole wetland, and state why this figure underestimates the full value of the wetland.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] 120 + 300 + 900 + 80 = $1 400 per hectare
[1] 700 000 per year
Accept: ECF from an error in the first step
Do not accept: answer without units
[1] non-use values (e.g. existence, bequest or cultural value) are not included, so the full value is higher
Accept: values that cannot be given a price(b)Evaluate the use of environmental accounting to decide whether to convert the wetland to shrimp ponds.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] strength: giving monetary values to ecosystem services (storm protection, nursery habitat) makes them visible in the decision, which markets ignore
[1] strength: comparison over time shows ponds earn 1 400 a year indefinitely, so conversion is poor value in the long term
Accept: the wetland's $900 storm protection value alone is large
[1] limitation: non-use and cultural values are hard or impossible to value, so the wetland's value is understated
[1] limitation: values depend on assumptions and are uncertain, and reducing nature to a price may ignore ethical and social considerations
Accept: values are illustrative; difficult to predict future valuesTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4Between 2005 and 2020 the gross domestic product (GDP) of Country P, a European country, grew by 25 %, while carbon dioxide emissions produced within its borders fell by 20 %, mainly because coal power stations were closed and renewable energy expanded. Over the same period its imports of manufactured goods rose strongly, and the emissions from making those goods occur in other countries. A group of ecological economists argues that the country should now aim for zero or slow growth. (The figures are illustrative.)(a)Compare and contrast environmental economics and ecological economics.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] environmental economics applies economics to the environment and environmental issues
[1] it works within the existing economic system, using tools such as valuation, taxes and the polluter-pays principle to correct market failures
[1] ecological economics views the economy as a subsystem of Earth's biosphere, with society a sub-component of ecology
[1] both value ecosystem services, but ecological economics places even greater emphasis on them
[1] environmental economics generally assumes growth can continue if separated from damage (decoupling)
[1] ecological economists support slow, zero or no growth, or degrowth, because the biosphere is finite
Accept: any valid similarity or difference(b)Evaluate whether the data for Country P show that eco-economic decoupling allows economic growth to continue without environmental degradation.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] support: GDP grew 25% while territorial CO₂ emissions fell 20%, so growth was separated from emissions produced inside the country
[1] the fall was linked to a change in energy supply (coal closed, renewables expanded), so decoupling is possible in some sectors
[1] limitation: imports rose and emissions from making imported goods occur abroad, so degradation may have been moved, not removed
[1] limitation: only one pollutant is considered, so decoupling from resource use, biodiversity loss or waste is not shown
[1] limitation: decoupling may be temporary or too slow, as easy gains such as closing coal plants cannot be repeated
[1] justified conclusion, e.g. the data show only partial or relative decoupling, not growth without environmental degradation
Accept: any reasoned judgementTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions