IB Environmental Systems and Societies HL
HL.a Environmental law
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1The Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer was agreed in 1985, and the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer in 1987. Under the Protocol, countries agreed to phase out chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and other ozone-depleting substances. The Protocol set up a Multilateral Fund to help developing countries meet their obligations. Every UN member state has now ratified it, and the ozone layer is slowly recovering.(a)Why is international law essential for dealing with ozone depletion?[1 mark]
- AOzone depletion affects only the country that releases the gases
- BCFCs released in any country spread through the atmosphere, so the problem crosses national borders
- CNational laws cannot ban chemicals
- DOnly international courts can punish polluters
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)The Multilateral Fund of the Montreal Protocol is an example of:[1 mark]- AEnvironmental constitutionalism
- BGranting legal personhood to the atmosphere
- CAn institution generated by an international agreement to help implement it
- DA local environmental law
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(c)Outline two features of the Montreal Protocol that help to explain why it has been effective.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] legally binding on signatories, who must follow the agreed phase-out
[1] it generated an institution (the Multilateral Fund) to help countries implement it, or near-universal ratification gives wide coverage
Accept: any other valid feature, such as a timetable of phase-out targetsTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2In 2008 Ecuador became the first country to recognise the rights of nature in its constitution. In 2017 the New Zealand parliament passed the Te Awa Tupua Act, which gave the Whanganui River the status of a legal person. Two guardians, one appointed by the Māori people of the river and one by the Crown, act on the river's behalf.(a)Writing environmental rights and obligations into a national constitution is called:[1 mark]
- AEnvironmental accounting
- BLegal personhood
- CTransboundary law
- DEnvironmental constitutionalism
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(b)What does granting the Whanganui River legal personhood mean in practice?[1 mark]- AThe river can have its interests defended in law, through guardians who act on its behalf
- BThe river must pay for any damage it causes
- CAll uses of the river are banned
- DThe river becomes private property of the Crown
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(c)Outline how granting legal personhood to a natural entity can strengthen environmental protection.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] harm to the entity can be challenged directly as harm to a rights-holder, not only as harm to people or property
[1] guardians can bring legal action on its behalf, giving the entity long-term representationTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3Two countries wanted to cut the use of single-use plastic bags. Country A passed a law banning free bags in shops. Its average use fell from 200 bags per person per year to 20 over three years. Country B introduced voluntary guidelines, and its use fell from 190 to 150 bags per person per year over the same time. In Country A, plastic manufacturers lobbied against the law for several years before it passed. The law was supported by a small charge on any bag that was sold.(a)Calculate the percentage reduction in bag use in each country, and state which approach was more effective.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] Country A: (200 − 20) ÷ 200 × 100 = 90%
[1] Country B: (190 − 150) ÷ 190 × 100 = 21%
Accept: 21.1
[1] the law (Country A) was more effective than voluntary guidelines
Accept: ECF from the calculated percentages(b)Explain why environmental laws can be difficult to approve, and how legal and economic strategies together can support sustainable use of the environment.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] industries affected by a law may lobby against it
[1] laws may be seen as costly or conflict with economic interests, delaying approval
[1] law sets a clear rule and makes the behaviour compulsory
[1] economic strategy such as a charge or tax gives a financial incentive; together they strengthen compliance, as with the bag chargeTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4Smoke haze from forest and peatland fires in Indonesia regularly drifts across Singapore, Malaysia and other neighbouring countries, causing health problems and school closures. In 2002 members of ASEAN signed the Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution, which came into force in 2003 and set up a coordinating centre for haze monitoring and response. Indonesia, where most of the fires start, was the last member state to ratify the agreement, in the mid-2010s.(a)Explain how international environmental law provides a framework for addressing transboundary pollution, using the haze agreement and one other example.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] transboundary pollution crosses national borders, so no single country's law can control it
[1] international conventions are legally binding on signatories (protocols may become binding)
[1] the ASEAN haze agreement commits signatories to prevent, monitor and respond to haze
[1] agreements can generate institutions to help implementation, e.g. the ASEAN coordinating centre
[1] a second example such as the Montreal Protocol and its Multilateral Fund for ozone-depleting substances
Accept: any other valid example of international environmental law
[1] application of the law can be examined in international courts and tribunals, e.g. the Trail Smelter arbitration(b)Evaluate the effectiveness of international environmental law, using examples.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] strength: legally binding on signatories, giving clear obligations, e.g. the Montreal Protocol phase-out largely achieved
[1] strength: institutions help implementation, e.g. the Multilateral Fund or the ASEAN haze centre
[1] strength: courts and tribunals can examine whether states have applied the law
[1] limitation: binds only states that have signed and ratified, e.g. Indonesia ratified the haze agreement much later than other members
[1] limitation: enforcement depends on national governments and success varies, and lobbying can delay approval
[1] conclusion: effective with wide ratification, funding and monitoring, weaker where economic interests drive the problem, so economic strategies are also neededTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions