IB Environmental Systems and Societies HL
4.2 Water access, use and security
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1Cape Town, South Africa, depends mainly on rain-fed surface reservoirs. After three years of very low rainfall (2015 to 2017), reservoir levels fell sharply and the city warned that the taps could be turned off ("Day Zero"). In 2018 each resident was limited to 50 litres of water per day. Households fitted low-flow showerheads and reused washing water on gardens, while the city planned desalination plants and the tapping of groundwater.(a)Which statement best describes water scarcity?[1 mark]
- AHaving access to sufficient amounts of safe drinking water
- BThe limited availability of water to human societies
- CThe total volume of water stored in a country's lakes and rivers
- DThe proportion of water used by industry rather than by households
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)Which action described in the scenario is a domestic water conservation technique?[1 mark]- ABuilding a new reservoir
- BConstructing a desalination plant
- CEnhancing natural wetlands
- DReusing washing water on gardens
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Explain one advantage and one disadvantage of using desalination to increase Cape Town's water supply.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] advantage: a reliable supply from seawater that does not depend on rainfall or drought
[1] disadvantage: high energy use (cost, emissions) or brine discharge harming marine life
Accept: high capital costTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2Country Y is an arid country of 12 million people. Each year its accessible, clean renewable freshwater supply is 18 billion cubic metres. Much of this water comes from a river that rises in a neighbouring country. The population is growing and irrigated agriculture takes most of the water.(a)Water stress is defined as a clean, accessible water supply of less than how many cubic metres per person per year?[1 mark]
- A1,700
- B170
- C17,000
- D5,000
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(b)Which statement correctly distinguishes water stress from water scarcity?[1 mark]- AWater stress considers only the amount of rainfall
- BWater stress applies only to countries with no rivers
- CWater stress also takes into account water quality, environmental flows and accessibility
- DWater stress and water scarcity both ignore water quality
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(c)Calculate the clean accessible water supply per person per year in Country Y and state, with a reason, whether Country Y is water-stressed.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] 18 billion ÷ 12 million = 1 500 m³ per person per year
[1] below 1 700 m³ per person per year, so water-stressed
Accept: ECF from an incorrect calculationTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A water footprint is the total volume of freshwater used to produce a good or service. A school food-technology class compares typical global average water footprints per kilogram of food: beef about 15,000 litres, rice about 2,500 litres and wheat about 1,800 litres.(a)Calculate how many times greater the water footprint of beef is than that of wheat (to one decimal place) and suggest one reason why beef has such a large footprint.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] correct working: 15 000 ÷ 1 800
[1] 8.3 (times)
[1] reason: cattle eat large amounts of feed crops that need water, and energy is lost at each trophic level so much more feed is needed per kg of meat
Accept: cattle drink water(b)Explain how water footprints can be used to inform decision-making about water security.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] footprints show how much water is used to make goods, including hidden (virtual) water
[1] consumers can choose lower-footprint products or diets, reducing demand
[1] governments and companies can target water-intensive sectors for efficiency or regulation
[1] a country can compare its consumption footprint with its supply and import water-intensive goods if short of waterTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4Egypt is a mainly desert country of more than 100 million people that receives very little rain. Almost all its freshwater comes from the River Nile, whose flow is regulated by the Aswan High Dam (completed 1970), which created Lake Nasser. Upstream, Ethiopia began building the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam on the Blue Nile, a major tributary, in 2011, mainly to generate electricity. Egypt and Sudan, which lie downstream, have raised concerns about how quickly the new reservoir is filled.(a)Evaluate the options available to Egypt for increasing its water supply.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] desalination on the coasts gives a supply independent of the Nile and rainfall
[1] but it is energy-intensive and costly, and brine can damage marine ecosystems
[1] reservoirs and dams store water for dry periods, as Lake Nasser does
[1] but reservoirs lose much water by evaporation, trap sediment and displace people and habitats
[1] rainwater catchment and wetland enhancement are cheap and sustainable but give small volumes in a very dry country
[1] conclusion: no single option is enough, so a combination with conservation suits Egypt(b)Discuss how transboundary disputes and governance affect water stress in the Nile basin.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] the Nile crosses several countries, so upstream use changes the quantity and timing of flow downstream
[1] Egypt depends on the Nile for almost all its freshwater, so reduced or delayed flow raises water stress
[1] Ethiopia needs the dam for electricity and development, so interests compete and a dispute arises
[1] local governance (laws, allocation, licences) can manage use within each country
[1] international governance (treaties, agreements on filling and operating, UN mediation, shared data) can reduce conflict
[1] judgement: cooperation is essential since no country can manage a shared river alone, though agreements are hard to enforceTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions