IB Environmental Systems and Societies HL
1.1 Perspectives
Total 27 marks
Name
Class
Date
- 1A city council surveys 500 residents about a proposal to ban private cars from the city centre. Residents rate statements from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree). One statement reads: "Nature has the right to exist whatever its use to people." Sixty per cent of respondents strongly agree with it.(a)What is a values survey best used to investigate?[1 mark]
- AThe exact quantity of pollution in the city centre
- BThe perspectives shown by a particular social group towards an environmental issue
- CThe scientific accuracy of the council's air-quality data
- DThe cost of introducing the ban
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: B(b)Which environmental worldview is most consistent with strong agreement with the statement?[1 mark]- ATechnocentric
- BAnthropocentric
- CPerspectives are unrelated to worldviews
- DEcocentric
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: D(c)Outline why the survey results might be different if the survey were repeated in the same city 20 years later.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] perspectives, and the beliefs that underpin them, change over time
[1] a named cause, e.g. government or NGO campaigns, media, social or demographic change, new scientific discoveries, an environmental disasterTotal for question 1: 4 marks
- 2Rachel Carson published Silent Spring in 1962. It described how pesticides such as DDT were harming birds and other wildlife. The book was widely read and discussed in the media. The Environmental Protection Agency was created in the USA in 1970, and DDT was banned for agricultural use there in 1972.(a)Silent Spring is an example of which influence on the development of the environmental movement?[1 mark]
- AA book (literature) written by an individual
- BA major environmental disaster
- CAn international agreement
- DA new technology
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: A(b)In an environmental value system model, the ban on DDT is best described as:[1 mark]- AAn input affecting perspectives
- BA worldview
- CAn output resulting from changed perspectives
- DA storage of values
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
Answer: C(c)Using the example of DDT, outline how an environmental value system model links inputs to outputs.[2 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] inputs, e.g. the book, scientific evidence or media coverage, influenced public and political perspectives
[1] outputs, e.g. creation of the EPA, the DDT ban or changed farming practice, resulted from those perspectivesTotal for question 2: 4 marks
- 3A researcher surveyed 400 people in a fishing village and 400 people in a nearby city about a proposed marine protected area (MPA) that would close local fishing grounds. In the village, 140 people supported the MPA and 82% agreed that "fish are important mainly because they provide an income". In the city, 312 people supported the MPA and 41% agreed with the same statement about fish.(a)Calculate how many more city respondents than village respondents supported the MPA, and suggest two reasons for the difference in perspective.[3 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] 312 − 140 = 172 more city respondents
[1] a reason linked to economic conditions or lived experience, e.g. village livelihoods depend on fishing
[1] a second reason, e.g. different sociocultural norms, education or media influence between city and village(b)Using the data, compare how an anthropocentric and an ecocentric worldview might respond to the proposed MPA.[4 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] anthropocentric: values nature for its benefits to people, so judges the MPA by its effect on human well-being
[1] it may support the MPA if it sustains fish stocks and long-term income, or oppose it if it removes livelihoods
[1] ecocentric: gives marine ecosystems intrinsic value, so supports the MPA whatever the economic cost
[1] link to data, e.g. 82% of villagers valuing fish mainly for income shows an anthropocentric view, while only 41% of city respondents suggests more hold other valuesTotal for question 3: 7 marks
- 4The first Earth Day took place in the USA in 1970. In 1989 the tanker Exxon Valdez spilled about 41 million litres of crude oil into Prince William Sound, Alaska. In 2018 Greta Thunberg began a school strike outside the Swedish parliament, which grew into the global Fridays for Future movement.(a)Explain how individuals, the media and major environmental disasters have influenced the development of the environmental movement, using the examples above.[6 marks]
Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] individuals can start action that spreads, e.g. Greta Thunberg's school strike growing into a global movement
[1] media coverage spreads information and raises awareness, e.g. images of oiled wildlife after Exxon Valdez; social media spread Fridays for Future
[1] major disasters make environmental damage visible and shock the public, e.g. Exxon Valdez in 1989
[1] disasters can lead to political or legal change, e.g. stricter regulation of oil tankers
[1] public events and campaigns build a collective identity, e.g. Earth Day 1970
[1] these influences change perspectives and the values behind them, so more people support environmental action(b)Evaluate the claim that environmental perspectives are fixed by a person's culture and cannot be changed by campaigns or education.[6 marks]Show the mark scheme
Mark scheme
[1] for: perspectives are informed by sociocultural norms, religion and lived experience that are deeply held
[1] for: people may resist campaigns that conflict with their worldview or economic interests, e.g. fishing or farming communities
[1] against: perspectives and beliefs change over time in all societies
[1] against: named evidence of change, e.g. growth of support for climate action after Fridays for Future, or public attitudes after Silent Spring
[1] against: government and NGO campaigns, education, and social or demographic change influence perspectives
[1] conclusion: the claim is too strong, since culture shapes perspectives but does not fix themTotal for question 4: 12 marks
End of questions