1.1 Perspectives
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- A perspective is how an individual views a situation, built from assumptions, values and beliefs.
- Values are principles people feel have worth; they show in communication and actions.
- Three worldviews: technocentric, anthropocentric and ecocentric.
- An environmental value system is a model: inputs affect perspectives, which produce outputs.
- Perspectives change over time, e.g. through the environmental movement.
What a perspective is
A perspective is how an individual understands a situation, shaped by personal and collective assumptions, values and beliefs.
A perspective is informed and justified by many factors: sociocultural norms, scientific understanding, laws, religion, economic conditions, local and global events and lived experience.
Two people can look at the same wind farm and hold opposite perspectives because different factors have shaped them.
- 1
Influences
sociocultural norms, science, laws, religion, economics, events, lived experience
- 2
Assumptions, values and beliefs
shaped by those influences
- 3
Perspective
how a person understands a situation
- Perspectiveassumptions + values + beliefs
Two people hold opposite views about a new wind farm. What best explains this?
Values and how we see them
Values show in what people and organisations say and do, and a values survey can investigate a group.
Values are qualities or principles that people feel have worth and importance in life. They show in our communication and actions. The values of organisations can be seen in their advertisements, media output, policies and actions.
A values survey asks a social group to respond to statements, so it can investigate the group's perspectives on an environmental issue.
- 1
Write statements
about the environmental issue
- 2
Group responds
agree or disagree with each
- 3
Analyse responses
to identify the perspectives shown
How could you investigate the perspectives of a social group towards an environmental issue?
Three worldviews
Worldviews are shared lenses; they fall into technocentric, anthropocentric and ecocentric.
A worldview is a lens shared by a group through which they perceive, make sense of and act within their environment. It is shaped by culture, philosophy, ideology, religion and politics.
- Technocentric: technology and science can solve environmental problems.
- Anthropocentric: humans are central; nature is valued for what it provides, and humans must manage it responsibly.
- Ecocentric: nature has intrinsic value; humans are part of ecosystems.
- 1
Technocentric
technology and science can solve environmental problems
- 2
Anthropocentric
humans are central; nature is valued for what it provides
- 3
Ecocentric
nature is central and has intrinsic value
Technocentric
- Centre: technology and science
- Nature is managed and used
- Problems solved by technology
Anthropocentric
- Centre: humans
- Nature valued for what it provides
- Humans must manage it responsibly
Ecocentric
- Centre: nature
- Intrinsic value
- Humans are part of ecosystems
A person argues that a forest should be protected because it has value in its own right, whatever its use. Which worldview is this?
Environmental value systems
An environmental value system is a model of the inputs that shape our perspectives and the outputs that result.
An environmental value system is a model. Inputs include education, culture, religion, media and economic and political influences. Outputs include decisions, laws, policies and personal actions.
- 1
Inputs
education, culture, religion, media, economic and political influences
- 2
Perspective (the system)
the individual or group's views and values
- 3
Outputs
decisions, laws, policies and personal actions
Is a law passed to protect a river an input or an output of an environmental value system?
Change over time
Perspectives change as societies change, and the environmental movement grew through many influences.
Perspectives and the beliefs behind them change over time in all societies. Government or NGO campaigns and social and demographic change can influence them.
The environmental movement has been influenced by individuals (e.g. Rachel Carson), literature (Silent Spring), the media, major disasters (e.g. Exxon Valdez), international agreements, new technologies and scientific discoveries.
1962
Silent Spring
Rachel Carson’s book raises public concern about pesticides
1987
Montreal Protocol
an international agreement to protect the ozone layer
1989
Exxon Valdez
a major oil spill reported widely in the media
People and ideas
- Individuals, e.g. Rachel Carson
- Literature, e.g. Silent Spring
- The media
Events and change
- Major disasters, e.g. Exxon Valdez
- International agreements
- New technologies and discoveries
Name two influences on the development of the environmental movement.
Try an exam question
Explain how two different environmental worldviews could lead to different decisions about a proposed forest clearance.
[4 marks]
- [1]Technocentric: technology can solve the problems, so clearance and replanting or management is acceptable.
- [1]Ecocentric: the forest has intrinsic value, so it should be protected.
- [1]Anthropocentric: valued for what it provides, so cleared only if managed responsibly for human benefit.
- [1]Worldviews shape values and perspectives, which become outputs such as decisions and policies.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
What is a values survey best used to investigate?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
What is a values survey best used to investigate?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme