HL.b Environmental and ecological economics

HL.b Environmental and ecological economics

IB Environmental Systems and Societies HL: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Market failure happens when the cost of environmental damage is not in the price.
  • The polluter-pays principle makes the polluter bear the cost of damage.
  • The tragedy of the commons arises when property rights are unclear and there is no market price.
  • Ecological economics sees the economy as a subsystem of the biosphere.
  • Decoupling separates economic growth from environmental degradation.

Economics and the environment

Market failure occurs when the cost of environmental damage is left out of prices.

Economics studies how humans produce, distribute and consume goods and services. Environmental economics applies it to environmental issues.

Market failure occurs when the free market allocation imposes negative impacts on the environment, because the cost of damage is not in the price (an external cost). The polluter-pays principle may then apply. Greenwashing is marketing that gives a company a more environmentally friendly image than its practices justify.

  1. 1

    Free market

    goods are produced and priced

  2. 2

    External cost

    the cost of damage is not in the price

  3. 3

    Negative impact

    harm to the environment

  4. 4

    Polluter pays

    the polluter bears the cost, e.g. a pollution charge or tax

Market failure and the polluter-pays principle.

Which describes the polluter-pays principle?

The tragedy of the commons

Where property rights are unclear and no price is attached, users overexploit a common good.

The tragedy of the commons highlights the problem where property rights are not clearly delineated and no market price is attached to a common good, resulting in overexploitation. Each user gains the full benefit of taking more while the cost is shared by all.

Examples: open-access fisheries, shared grazing land, the atmosphere as a carbon sink. Strategies include defined property rights, quotas, licences and community management.

  1. 1

    No clear property rights

    and no price on the resource

  2. 2

    Each user takes more

    gaining the full benefit

  3. 3

    Cost shared by all

    so no one limits use

  4. 4

    Overexploitation

    the resource declines

Then back to step 1

How the tragedy of the commons builds.

Why does an open-access fishery tend to be overfished?

Environmental accounting and valuation

Environmental accounting attaches economic value to natural resources, but use-based valuation leaves out non-use values.

Environmental accounting attempts to attach economic value to natural resources and their depletion. Value can sometimes be established by use (direct uses such as timber or fish; indirect uses such as storm protection), but not for non-use values such as existence value, bequest value (leaving it for future generations) and cultural value.

  1. 1

    Use values

    Direct (timber, fish) and indirect (storm protection)

  2. 2

    Non-use values

    Existence, bequest and cultural value

  3. 3

    Accounting

    Can price use values more easily than non-use values

Valuing natural resources

Direct use

  • Timber
  • Fish

Indirect use

  • Storm protection

Non-use

  • Existence value
  • Bequest value
  • Cultural value

Strengths

  • Makes ecosystem services visible in decisions
  • Allows comparisons

Limitations

  • Non-use values are hard to measure
  • Values are uncertain
  • Reducing nature to a price raises ethical issues

Which is a non-use value?

Ecological economics

Ecological economics treats the economy as a subsystem of the biosphere and supports slow, zero or negative growth.

Ecological economics views the economy as a subsystem of Earth's larger biosphere, and the social system as a sub-component of ecology. Ecological economists support a slow, no or zero growth model, and degrowth: a planned reduction in consumption and production.

  1. 1

    Biosphere

    The largest system

  2. 2

    Society

    A sub-component of ecology

  3. 3

    Economy

    A subsystem of the biosphere

The economy sits inside the biosphere

Environmental economics

View of economy:
Applies economics to environmental issues
Valuation of ecosystem services:
Addresses valuation of ecosystem services
Growth:
Growth not the focus

Ecological economics

View of economy:
Economy is a subsystem of the biosphere
Valuation of ecosystem services:
Even greater emphasis on valuation
Growth:
Slow, zero growth or degrowth

What does ecological economics see the economy as?

Economic growth and decoupling

Economic growth is the annual percentage change in GDP, and decoupling tries to separate it from environmental degradation.

Economic growth is influenced by supply and demand and may be seen as a measure of prosperity, but it has impacts on environmental welfare such as resource use and pollution. Eco-economic decoupling is the notion of separating growth from environmental degradation.

Evidence of decoupling needs care: emissions may be moved abroad through imports, and decoupling from one pollutant does not show decoupling from resource use.

246810121416182020406080100120140160180200xyGDP indexEmissions index
Illustrative values (not real data): GDP grows 3% a year while emissions fall 1% a year, which is what decoupling aims for
  • Economic growthannual % change in GDP

Why might falling national emissions not prove decoupling?

Models for sustainability

The circular economy and doughnut economics apply ecological economics to sustainability and challenge growth alone.

The circular economy and doughnut economics can be seen as applications of ecological economics. The circular economy aims to eliminate waste and pollution, circulate products and materials, and regenerate nature. Doughnut economics aims to meet the needs of all people within the means of the planet. Both challenge the idea that growth alone leads to prosperity.

  1. 1

    Design out waste

    and pollution

  2. 2

    Circulate products

    and materials at their highest value

  3. 3

    Regenerate nature

    restoring natural systems

Then back to step 1

The circular economy.

Which model aims to meet the needs of all people within the means of the planet?

Try an exam question

Explain the polluter-pays principle and why it may be needed when markets fail.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which term describes the allocation of paper by the free market when the mill's price does not include the cost of the damage to the river?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes