1.3 Sustainability

1.3 Sustainability

IB Environmental Systems and Societies HL: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Sustainability is the long-term viability of a system; it has environmental, social and economic pillars.
  • Sustainable development meets present needs without compromising future generations.
  • GDP neglects the value of natural systems, so it can mislead.
  • Environmental justice: all people have the right to a pollution-free environment and equitable access to resources.
  • Ecological footprint greater than biocapacity means unsustainable.

What sustainability means

Sustainability is a measure of how far practices allow the long-term viability of a system, across three pillars.

Sustainability is generally used for the responsible maintenance of socio-ecological systems so that conditions are not diminished for future generations.

  • Environmental: resources are replaced and ecosystems recover and regenerate.
  • Social: structures such as health, education, equity and community support human well-being.
  • Economic: structures support production and consumption of goods and services into the future.
  1. 1

    Environmental

    resources replaced, ecosystems recover and regenerate

  2. 2

    Social

    health, education, equity and community

  3. 3

    Economic

    production and consumption continue into the future

  4. 4

    Sustainability

    conditions not diminished for future generations

Three pillars that together support sustainability.

Environmental

  • Resource replacement
  • Recovery and regeneration of ecosystems

Social

  • Health, education, equity, community
  • Human well-being

Economic

  • Production and consumption
  • Meeting human needs into the future

A scheme provides schools and health clinics for a community. Which pillar does this mainly support?

Development, collapse and GDP

Sustainable development protects future generations, but GDP ignores natural systems and can hide unsustainable use.

Sustainable development meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own. Unsustainable use, such as removing a resource faster than it can be replaced, can lead to ecosystem collapse.

Gross domestic product (GDP) neglects the value of natural systems. A country can record rising GDP while clearing forest or depleting fish stocks.

  1. 1

    Resource removed faster than replaced

    e.g. clearing forest, depleting fish stocks

  2. 2

    GDP rises

    it neglects the value of natural systems

  3. 3

    Natural system degrades

    less and less can be supplied

  4. 4

    Ecosystem collapse

    future needs cannot be met

How unsustainable use can end in collapse while GDP still rises.
  • Sustainable developmentmeets present needs without compromising future generations

Why can rising GDP be misleading as a measure of development?

Environmental justice

Environmental justice is the right of all people to a pollution-free environment and fair access to natural resources.

Environmental justice is the right of all people to a pollution-free environment and equitable access to natural resources, regardless of race, gender, socio-economic status or nationality.

Inequalities in income, race, gender and cultural identity, within and between societies, lead to disparities in access to water, food and energy. Sustainability and justice apply at every operating scale, from individual to global.

  1. 1

    Inequalities

    income, race, gender, cultural identity

  2. 2

    Disparities

    in access to water, food and energy

  3. 3

    Environmental justice

    aims for equitable access for all

How inequality leads to unequal access.

What does environmental justice say about access to natural resources?

Indicators and footprints

Sustainability indicators such as footprints measure resource use; a footprint above biocapacity is unsustainable.

Sustainability indicators are quantitative measures applied from local to global scale.

  • Ecological footprint: area (global hectares) needed to supply a population's resources and absorb its wastes.
  • Biocapacity: ability of an area to supply renewable resources and absorb wastes.
  • Carbon footprint: greenhouse gases, in tonnes of COX2\ce{CO2} equivalent.
  • Water footprint: water use, in m³ per year.

Citizen science volunteers increase coverage and awareness, but data quality can vary.

  1. 1

    Measure the footprint

    area needed for resources and waste absorption (gha)

  2. 2

    Measure the biocapacity

    area able to supply and absorb (gha)

  3. 3

    Compare

    footprint above biocapacity is unsustainable

  4. 4

    Other indicators

    carbon (tonnes CO₂ equivalent), water (m³ per year)

Comparing a footprint with biocapacity.

Ecological footprint

  • Area for resources and waste absorption
  • Global hectares (gha)

Biocapacity

  • Ongoing supply of renewable resources
  • Global hectares (gha)

Carbon footprint

  • Greenhouse gases produced
  • Tonnes CO₂ equivalent

Water footprint

  • Water use
  • m³ per year

A population's ecological footprint is greater than the biocapacity available to it. What does this show?

Frameworks for sustainability

The SDGs, planetary boundaries, doughnut economics and the circular economy each guide action, with uses and limits.

  • Sustainable Development Goals: UN goals and targets to guide action on sustainability and environmental justice.
  • Planetary boundaries model: nine processes that kept the Earth system stable in the Holocene; crossing the limits increases the risk of abrupt, irreversible change.
  • Doughnut economics: a regenerative and distributive economy meeting everyone's needs within the planet's means.
  • Circular economy: decoupling activity from finite resources by eliminating waste, circulating materials and regenerating nature.

Limitations: global models are hard to apply locally, thresholds are uncertain, and indicators involve value judgements.

  1. 1

    Eliminate waste and pollution

    design them out

  2. 2

    Circulate products and materials

    keep them in use

  3. 3

    Regenerate nature

    restore natural systems

Then back to step 1

The three principles of a circular economy.

Which model identifies limits of human disturbance, where crossing them increases the risk of abrupt and irreversible change?

Try an exam question

Explain why a country with rising GDP may not be developing sustainably.

[3 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which statement best explains why GDP may be a poor indicator of sustainable development in this country?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes