HL.c Environmental ethics
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Ethics is the branch of philosophy about right and wrong; environmental ethics applies it to environmental issues.
- Instrumental value is usefulness to humans; intrinsic value is value for what something is; both can be held together.
- Three traditional approaches: virtue, consequentialist and rights-based ethics.
- The appeal to nature fallacy wrongly assumes natural means good.
- Environmental and social justice movements increasingly share goals.
Ethics and environmental ethics
Ethics deals with right and wrong, and environmental ethics applies it to environmental issues where beliefs about nature conflict.
Ethics is the branch of philosophy that focuses on moral principles and what behaviours are right and wrong. Environmental ethics addresses environmental issues.
A variety of ethical frameworks and conflicting ethical values arise from different fundamental beliefs about the relationship between humans and nature.
- 1
Ethics
moral principles: what is right and wrong
- 2
Environmental ethics
ethics applied to environmental issues
- 3
Different beliefs about humans and nature
give different ethical frameworks
- 4
Conflicting ethical values
so people disagree about what to do
- Ethicsmoral principles: what is right and wrong
- Environmental ethicsethics applied to environmental issues
Why do conflicting ethical values arise?
Instrumental and intrinsic value
Nature has instrumental value for its usefulness and intrinsic value for what it is, and both can apply at once.
Instrumental value is the usefulness an entity has for humans. Intrinsic value is the value one attaches to something simply for what it is. The two are not exclusive: a forest can be valued both for its resources and for its own sake.
An entity has moral standing if it is to be morally considered in how we ought to act towards it.
- 1
Instrumental value
usefulness to humans: timber, water supply
- 2
Intrinsic value
valued for what it is, for its own sake
- 3
Not exclusive
a forest can have both
- 4
Moral standing
morally considered in how we act towards it
Instrumental value
- Usefulness to humans
- Forest: timber, water supply
Intrinsic value
- Value for what it is
- Forest: valued for its own sake
A person values a forest for its timber and also for its own sake. Which values do they hold?
Three approaches of traditional ethics
Virtue ethics looks at character, consequentialist ethics at consequences and rights-based ethics at rights.
- Virtue ethics: focuses on the character of the person acting; good people do good actions.
- Consequentialist ethics (e.g. utilitarian): the consequences of an action determine whether it is moral.
- Rights-based (deontological) ethics: focuses on actions and whether they conflict with the rights of others; there is debate about what these rights are.
- 1
Virtue ethics
the character of the person acting
- 2
Consequentialist ethics
the consequences of the action
- 3
Rights-based ethics
whether the action conflicts with others' rights
| Virtue ethics | Consequentialist | Rights-based | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What decides if it is moral | Character of the person | Consequences of the action | Whether it conflicts with others' rights |
| Focus | Focus: the actor | Focus: the outcome | Focus: the action |
Virtue ethics
- What decides if it is moral:
- Character of the person
- Focus:
- Focus: the actor
Consequentialist
- What decides if it is moral:
- Consequences of the action
- Focus:
- Focus: the outcome
Rights-based
- What decides if it is moral:
- Whether it conflicts with others' rights
- Focus:
- Focus: the action
Which approach judges an action by its consequences?
Appeal to nature fallacy
The appeal to nature fallacy wrongly assumes that whatever is natural is correct or good.
Some people hold that whatever is natural is correct or good. This position is contentious and is called the appeal to nature fallacy: natural things can be harmful and artificial things beneficial.
- 1
Claim
whatever is natural is correct or good
- 2
Counter-example 1
natural but harmful: toxins, disease
- 3
Counter-example 2
artificial but beneficial: vaccines, renewable energy
- 4
Conclusion
the appeal to nature is a fallacy
Natural but harmful
- Toxins
- Disease
Artificial but beneficial
- Vaccines
- Renewable energy
Give one example showing that natural does not always mean good.
Try an exam question
Distinguish between instrumental value and intrinsic value, using a forest as an example.
[3 marks]
- [1]Instrumental value is the usefulness an entity has for humans.
- [1]Intrinsic value is the value attached to something for what it is.
- [1]A forest can be valued for its timber (instrumental) and for its own sake (intrinsic); the two are not exclusive.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
The pharmaceutical company's valuation of the forest is an example of:
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
The pharmaceutical company's valuation of the forest is an example of:
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme