4.3 Aquatic food production systems

4.3 Aquatic food production systems

IB Environmental Systems and Societies HL: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Phytoplankton and macrophytes are the producers of aquatic food webs.
  • Overexploitation harvests faster than stocks replace themselves, and can cause collapse.
  • Maximum sustainable yield is the highest annual catch that can be sustained, used to set quotas.
  • Ocean acidification makes it harder for shellfish and corals to form shells.
  • Aquaculture is expanding but causes pollution, disease, escapes and habitat loss.

Demand and overexploitation

Rising demand drives harvesting faster than stocks can replace themselves, and stocks can collapse.

Phytoplankton and macrophytes (large aquatic plants and algae, e.g. seagrass and kelp) are the producers that provide energy for aquatic food webs. Demand for seafood is rising with population growth and dietary change.

This has encouraged unsustainable practices (large trawlers, bottom trawling, driftnets, bycatch) and overexploitation. The northern cod fishery off Newfoundland collapsed (moratorium in 1992), harming ecosystems and people.

  1. 1

    Demand rises

    more fish are caught

  2. 2

    Catch exceeds replacement

    harvesting faster than the stock replaces itself

  3. 3

    Fewer breeding adults

    fewer young are produced

  4. 4

    Collapse

    the stock falls and fishing communities suffer

How overexploitation leads to collapse.

Why can overexploitation cause a fishery to collapse?

Maximum sustainable yield

MSY is the highest annual catch that can be sustained over time, and it sets caps on fishing quotas.

The maximum sustainable yield (MSY) is the highest possible annual catch that can be sustained over time. It sets caps on quotas. Growth is fastest at a medium population size, so harvesting a stock down to about that size gives the most fish each year.

(HL) Fish stocks must be accurately assessed and harvest rates monitored (surveys, catch records, observers). Risks of harvesting at MSY: uncertain estimates, ignored species interactions and environmental change, so a precautionary quota below MSY may be set. Overexploited species can recover with multi-stakeholder cooperation, as Atlantic bluefin tuna has begun to under ICCAT.

10203040506070809010051015202530xyMSYsustainable yield
Illustrative logistic yield curve: the sustainable catch is greatest at the middle population size, which is the maximum sustainable yield
  • MSYhighest annual catch that can be sustained

At what stock size is growth fastest, giving the greatest sustainable catch?

Climate, acidification and mitigation

Climate change and acidification harm aquatic populations, and policy, consumer choice and protected areas help.

Climate change warms water and shifts species' ranges. Ocean acidification (COX2\ce{CO2} forming carbonic acid) makes it harder for shellfish, corals and some plankton to form calcium carbonate shells. These can collapse some populations.

Marine protected areas (MPAs) protect habitats and spawning grounds, support food chains and maintain yields; the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park has large no-take zones.

  1. 1

    CO₂ dissolves in the ocean

    forms carbonic acid

  2. 2

    Ocean pH falls

    shells and coral skeletons are harder to build

  3. 3

    Warming adds stress

    coral bleaching and shifts in where species live

  4. 4

    Responses

    policy, consumer choice and protected areas

How climate change and acidification harm aquatic populations

Policy and legislation

  • Quotas
  • Gear restrictions, minimum mesh sizes
  • Closed seasons
  • Bans on illegal fishing

Consumer behaviour

  • Eco-labels
  • Choosing sustainable species

Marine protected areas

  • Protect habitats and spawning grounds
  • Support food chains and yields

Why does ocean acidification harm shellfish?

Aquaculture

Aquaculture is expanding to increase food supplies, but it has several environmental impacts.

Aquaculture is the farming of aquatic organisms, including fish, molluscs, crustaceans and aquatic plants. The industry is expanding to increase food supplies and support economic development.

  1. 1

    Fish are farmed

    in cages or ponds

  2. 2

    Waste and uneaten feed

    nutrient pollution of the water

  3. 3

    Disease and escapes

    spread to wild populations

  4. 4

    Feed

    may be made from wild-caught fish

Environmental impacts of aquaculture

Why it is expanding

  • Increases food supplies
  • Supports economic development

Environmental impacts

  • Nutrient and waste pollution (eutrophication) under cages
  • Disease and parasites, e.g. sea lice, spreading to wild fish
  • Escapes that breed with wild fish
  • Antibiotic and chemical use
  • Loss of habitats, e.g. mangroves cleared for shrimp ponds
  • Wild fish used as feed

Which is an environmental impact of aquaculture?

HL: productivity and nutrients

Stratification traps nutrients in deep water, while mixing and nutrient loading raise surface productivity.

(HL) Productivity, thermal stratification, nutrient mixing and nutrient loading are interconnected.

In warm water a surface layer sits above colder, denser water (thermal stratification), which stops nutrients mixing up from the deep, so surface productivity can be limited. Mixing (upwelling, storms or seasonal turnover) brings nutrients up and raises productivity and fish catches. Nutrient loading from run-off or sewage can also raise productivity, but too much causes eutrophication.

  1. 1

    Stratification

    a warm surface layer sits on cold nutrient-rich water, trapping nutrients below

  2. 2

    Mixing or upwelling

    brings nutrients to the surface

  3. 3

    Nutrient loading

    raises productivity, and may cause algal blooms

Nutrients and productivity

Thermal stratification

  • Warm layer above cold, dense water
  • No nutrient mixing from the deep
  • Surface productivity limited

Mixing

  • Upwelling, storms, seasonal turnover
  • Nutrients reach the surface
  • Productivity and catches rise

Nutrient loading

  • Run-off or sewage
  • Can raise productivity
  • Too much causes eutrophication

Why can thermal stratification limit surface productivity?

HL: UNCLOS and marine mammals

Coastal states control resources in a 370 km exclusive economic zone, and harvesting marine mammals raises ethical issues.

(HL) Under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), coastal states have an exclusive economic zone (EEZ) stretching 370 km out to sea, with rights to its resources and a responsibility to manage them. Beyond it lie the high seas, where cooperation between states is needed.

Harvesting seals, whales and dolphins raises ethical issues about animal rights: whether intelligent animals that can suffer should be killed, balanced against the livelihoods and cultural traditions of some coastal and indigenous communities.

050100150200250300350400450500coastterritorial sea ends (12 nm)EEZ ends
Distance from the coast (km): the exclusive economic zone is 200 nautical miles, about 370 km
  • Exclusive economic zone370 km from the coast; coastal state controls resources

How far does an exclusive economic zone stretch from the coast?

Try an exam question

Explain how overexploitation can cause a fishery to collapse.

[3 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which term describes harvesting so heavily that a population can no longer replace itself?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes