HL.a Environmental law
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Environmental law is the set of rules on how humans use and impact natural resources, aiming at sustainability.
- Laws can be local, national or international, but lobbying can make them hard to approve.
- Conventions are legally binding; protocols may become binding on signatories.
- Some laws grant legal personhood to natural entities, e.g. the Whanganui River.
- Legal and economic strategies work best together.
What environmental law is
Environmental law is the set of rules about how humans use and impact natural resources, aiming to improve sustainability.
Laws are rules that govern human behaviour and are enforced by social or governmental authority. Environmental law aims to improve social and ecological sustainability. It is built into existing legal frameworks, but its success varies from country to country.
- 1
Laws
Rules on human behaviour, enforced by authority.
- 2
Environmental law
Rules on how humans use and impact natural resources.
- 3
Aim
Social and ecological sustainability.
- Environmental lawrules on human use of natural resources, for sustainability
What is the aim of environmental law?
Justice, lobbying and levels of law
Laws can support environmental justice, but lobbying by groups with opposing interests can make them difficult to approve.
Environmental laws can support environmental justice, but may be difficult to approve because of lobbying by groups with opposing interests. Laws can be drafted at local, national or international level.
Environmental constitutionalism puts environmental rights and obligations into a constitution, e.g. Ecuador's 2008 recognition of the rights of nature.
- 1
Local
e.g. a council ban on a pollutant
- 2
National
laws and constitutions of a country
- 3
International
conventions and protocols between states
Why can environmental laws be hard to approve?
International environmental law
International law is the essential framework for transboundary pollution and resource management.
International law is essential for transboundary pollution and resource management. UN conferences produce conventions that are legally binding, and protocols that may become legally binding on all signatories.
Agreements can generate institutions to aid implementation, such as the Multilateral Fund. Application has been examined in international courts and tribunals, e.g. the Trail Smelter arbitration.
- 1
UN conference
States negotiate on a transboundary problem.
- 2
Convention or protocol
Conventions are legally binding; protocols may bind signatories.
- 3
Institutions
Agreements can create bodies such as the Multilateral Fund.
- 4
Courts and tribunals
Application is examined, e.g. the Trail Smelter arbitration.
| Convention | Protocol | Regional agreement | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Legally binding agreement from a UN conference | Agreement that may become legally binding on signatories | Agreement on transboundary pollution |
| Example | Vienna Convention | Montreal Protocol | ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution |
Convention
- Meaning:
- Legally binding agreement from a UN conference
- Example:
- Vienna Convention
Protocol
- Meaning:
- Agreement that may become legally binding on signatories
- Example:
- Montreal Protocol
Regional agreement
- Meaning:
- Agreement on transboundary pollution
- Example:
- ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution
Which is an example of an institution generated by an international agreement?
Legal personhood for nature
Laws increasingly give natural entities legal personhood so they can be protected in their own right.
An increasing number of laws grant legal personhood to natural entities to strengthen protection. In 2017 New Zealand's Te Awa Tupua Act made the Whanganui River a legal person, with guardians appointed to act for it.
- 1
Law grants personhood
the river becomes a legal person
- 2
Guardians appointed
they act on the river's behalf
- 3
Harm can be challenged
in law, for the river itself
Who acts for the Whanganui River in law?
Law and economics together
Laws set compulsory rules and economic instruments create incentives, so together they can be more effective.
Both legal and economic strategies play a role in sustainable use of the environment. Laws set compulsory rules; economic strategies such as charges, taxes and subsidies create incentives. Used together they can be more effective than either alone, as with bans supported by charges on plastic bags.
- 1
Legal strategy
A compulsory rule, e.g. a ban on a pollutant.
- 2
Economic strategy
An incentive, e.g. a charge on plastic bags.
- 3
Combined effect
More effective than either alone.
| Legal | Economic | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | Compulsory rules | Incentives through prices |
| Example | e.g. ban on a pollutant | e.g. charge on plastic bags |
Legal
- How it works:
- Compulsory rules
- Example:
- e.g. ban on a pollutant
Economic
- How it works:
- Incentives through prices
- Example:
- e.g. charge on plastic bags
Give one reason legal and economic strategies work well together.
Try an exam question
Explain why international law is needed to deal with environmental problems, giving an example.
[3 marks]
- [1]Pollution and resources are transboundary, so national laws alone cannot manage them.
- [1]UN conferences produce conventions (legally binding) and protocols (may bind signatories).
- [1]Example: the Montreal Protocol on ozone-depleting substances (or the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution).
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Why is international law essential for dealing with ozone depletion?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Why is international law essential for dealing with ozone depletion?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme