Percentage yield and atom economy

Percentage yield and atom economy

Spec 1.9 · Edexcel International A Level Chemistry: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Percentage yield = actual yield ÷ theoretical yield ×\times 100.
  • Yields are below 100% because of incomplete reactions, side reactions and losses during handling.
  • Atom economy = MrM_r of desired product ÷ sum of MrM_r of all products ×\times 100, from the balanced equation.
  • Yield is a property of the experiment; atom economy is a property of the equation. They are independent.
  • Heat to constant mass to be sure a reaction is complete.

Percentage yield

Percentage yield compares the mass you actually obtained with the maximum the equation predicts.

The theoretical yield is the maximum mass of product predicted by the balanced equation, found from the limiting reagent: moles, equation ratio, then mass. The actual yield is the mass obtained.

Percentage yield cannot normally exceed 100%.

0246810Theoretical yieldActual yieldYieldMass of product (g)
Illustrative values: 8.0 g obtained from a theoretical maximum of 10.0 g is a percentage yield of 80%.
  • Percentage yieldactual yieldtheoretical yield×100\dfrac{\text{actual yield}}{\text{theoretical yield}} \times 100

Worked example

2.43 g of magnesium burns in oxygen: 2 Mg+OX2→2 MgO\ce{2Mg + O2 -> 2MgO}. The actual yield of MgO\ce{MgO} is 3.60 g. Calculate the percentage yield.

The actual yield is 2.0 g and the theoretical yield is 2.5 g. What is the percentage yield?

Why yields are below 100%

Reactions do not go to completion, other reactions compete, and some product is lost in handling.

Practical yields are lower for three kinds of reason: incomplete reactions (reversible reactions, too little time), side reactions giving other products, and loss of product during transfer, filtering, washing, recrystallisation, or as smoke or vapour.

Impure reactants also lower the yield.

  1. 1

    Theoretical yield

    The most the equation allows

  2. 2

    Chemical losses

    Incomplete reaction and side reactions

  3. 3

    Practical losses

    Filtering, washing, transfers, vapour

  4. 4

    Actual yield

    The mass you collect

Where the product is lost between the equation and the flask.

Chemical causes

  • Reaction is reversible or incomplete
  • Side reactions give other products
  • Impure reactants

Practical losses

  • Solid left on filter paper
  • Product lost in transfers
  • Smoke or vapour escapes

Which is the best reason for a low yield in a filtration step?

Atom economy

Atom economy is the percentage of the reactant mass that ends up as the desired product, worked out from the equation.

Atom economy uses the balanced equation, with the moles of each substance, not experimental masses. It equals the mass of desired product divided by the total mass of reactants.

An addition reaction with one product has 100% atom economy. A high atom economy means less waste.

020406080100Reactant CaCO₃Desired CaOWaste CO₂Mass in the equationRelative formula mass
CaCO₃ → CaO + CO₂ (Mr 100 → 56 + 44): the desired product CaO is 56% of the mass, so the atom economy is 56%.
  • Atom economyMr desired∑Mr products×100%\dfrac{M_r \text{ desired}}{\sum M_r \text{ products}} \times 100\%

Worked example

Calculate the atom economy for making hydrogen: CHX4+HX2O→CO+3 HX2\ce{CH4 + H2O -> CO + 3H2}. The desired product is HX2\ce{H2}.

A reaction has one product, and it is the desired one. What is the atom economy?

Yield versus atom economy

Atom economy belongs to the equation; yield belongs to the experiment.

A reaction can have a 100% yield yet a low atom economy, because it still makes by-products. A reaction with 100% atom economy can have a low yield.

Industry considers both, with by-product value, energy use and hazards. Useful by-products, or reactants that can be recycled, improve efficiency.

020406080Percentage yieldAtom economyMeasurePercentage (%)
The same reaction can score differently: a 90% yield (illustrative) for the CaCO₃ decomposition, but its atom economy is still 56%.

Percentage yield

Based on:
Experimental masses
Tells you:
How much product you got
Affected by:
Losses, side reactions, incomplete reaction

Atom economy

Based on:
Balanced equation
Tells you:
How much reactant mass becomes desired product
Affected by:
Reaction design, by-products

A reaction gives a 100% yield but makes a large mass of waste product. Which is true?

Formulae by experiment

Heat to constant mass, then use the mass change to find the moles of each element.

Burning magnesium in a crucible gives the formula of its oxide from the masses. If the oxygen gained is lower than expected, some product was lost as smoke or not all the metal reacted.

Improve the experiment by heating to constant mass, keeping the lid on as far as possible and weighing accurately.

  1. 1

    Heat

    the crucible and contents strongly

  2. 2

    Cool and weigh

    record the mass

  3. 3

    Reheat

    heat again and reweigh

  4. 4

    Compare

    if the mass changed, repeat; if not, the reaction is complete

Heating to constant mass

Worked example

1.215 g of magnesium is burned to give 2.015 g of oxide. Find the formula.

Why is the crucible heated to constant mass?

Try an exam question

Magnesium reacts with oxygen: 2 Mg+OX2→2 MgO\ce{2Mg + O2 -> 2MgO}. 1.215 g of magnesium gives 1.50 g of magnesium oxide. Calculate the percentage yield, and suggest one reason why it is below 100%. (ArA_r: Mg 24.3, O 16.0)

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What is the theoretical yield of magnesium oxide?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes