Rate-determining step and reaction mechanisms

Rate-determining step and reaction mechanisms

Spec 11.6–9 · Edexcel International A Level Chemistry: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • The rate-determining step is the slowest step and controls the overall rate.
  • An intermediate is formed in one step and used up in a later one; it is not in the overall equation.
  • The order of a reactant is how many of its particles are in the slow step (or fast steps before it); zero order means it reacts after the slow step.
  • A mechanism is accepted only if the steps add up to the overall equation and the slow step gives the experimental rate equation.
  • First order in the halogenoalkane only means SN1; first order in both means SN2.

The rate-determining step

The slowest step in a mechanism controls the overall rate. Steps after it are fast and do not affect the rate.

A reaction mechanism shows the steps by which reactants become products.

The rate-determining step is the slowest step. It controls the overall rate, like the narrowest part of a pipe.

An intermediate is a species formed in one step and used up in a later step. It does not appear in the overall equation. The steps must add up to the overall equation once intermediates are cancelled.

  1. 1

    Slow step

    reactants form an intermediate (rate-determining)

  2. 2

    Fast step

    the intermediate reacts to give the products

A two-step mechanism: the slow step sets the pace

What is an intermediate?

From rate equation to slow step

The order of each reactant is the number of its particles in the slow step. A zero-order reactant reacts in a fast step afterwards.

The rate equation shows which species, and how many of each, are in the rate-determining step or in fast steps before it.

A reactant with order 1 is present once in the slow step; order 2 means two of that species. A reactant with zero order is not in the rate-determining step. It reacts in a fast step after it.

  1. 1

    Look at the rate equation

    each order tells you how much of that reactant is in the slow step

  2. 2

    Order 1 or 2

    one or two particles of that reactant in the slow step

  3. 3

    Zero order

    not in the slow step; reacts in a fast step afterwards

Reading a rate equation as a mechanism.
  • Order 1 in Xone X in the slow step
  • Order 2 in Xtwo X in the slow step
  • Zero order in XX reacts after the slow step

Worked example

The rate equation for NOX2+CO→NO+COX2\ce{NO2 + CO -> NO + CO2} is second order in NOX2\ce{NO2} and has no CO\ce{CO}. Suggest a mechanism.

A reaction is zero order with respect to X. Where does X react in the mechanism?

Checking a mechanism

It must add up to the overall equation and its slow step must give the experimental rate equation. Otherwise it is rejected.

To predict the rate equation of a proposed mechanism, write the rate equation for the slow step using its reactants.

A mechanism is consistent with the data only if the steps add up to the overall equation and the rate-determining step gives the experimental rate equation. If the predicted rate equation does not match, the mechanism is rejected.

A consistent mechanism is possible, not proved, because other mechanisms might also fit.

  1. 1

    Add the steps together

    do they give the overall equation?

  2. 2

    Write the rate equation for the slow step

  3. 3

    Compare with the experimental rate equation

  4. 4

    Match: consistent, not proved

    no match: reject the mechanism

Testing a proposed mechanism.
  • Consistent mechanismsteps add up and slow step gives the experimental rate equation

A mechanism has steps that add up to the overall equation, but its slow step predicts a rate equation that differs from experiment. Is the mechanism accepted?

Iodination of propanone

The reaction is first order in propanone and H⁺ and zero order in iodine, so iodine reacts only after the slow step.

The reaction is CHX3COCHX3+IX2→CHX3COCHX2I+HI\ce{CH3COCH3 + I2 -> CH3COCH2I + HI}, catalysed by HX+\ce{H+}.

Initial-rate experiments show it is first order in propanone, first order in HX+\ce{H+} and zero order in iodine, so rate=k[CHX3COCHX3][HX+]\text{rate} = k[\ce{CH3COCH3}][\ce{H+}].

The rate-determining step therefore involves propanone and HX+\ce{H+} but not iodine. Iodine reacts only after the slow step, which explains its zero order.

  1. 1

    Fast

    propanone is protonated on the carbonyl oxygen

  2. 2

    Slow

    the protonated propanone loses H⁺ from a CH₃ group to form the enol, CH₂=C(OH)CH₃

  3. 3

    Fast

    the enol reacts with iodine to form CH₃COCH₂I and HI, regenerating H⁺

A possible mechanism

Why does changing the concentration of iodine not change the rate?

SN1 and SN2

A tertiary halogenoalkane with rate = k[RBr] is SN1, with a carbocation intermediate. A primary one with rate = k[RBr][OH⁻] is SN2, with a transition state.

In SN1 (tertiary), the slow step is the C–Br bond breaking heterolytically to form a carbocation and BrX−\ce{Br-}. Then OHX−\ce{OH-} attacks in a fast step. Only the halogenoalkane is in the slow step.

In SN2 (primary), one step has OHX−\ce{OH-} attack the δ+ carbon as the C–Br bond breaks, through a transition state with both species. There is no intermediate.

Primary carbocations are unstable, so primary halogenoalkanes use SN2; tertiary carbocations are more stable, so tertiary use SN1.

  1. 1

    SN1 step 1 (slow)

    C–Br breaks to give a carbocation and Br⁻; rate = k[RBr]

  2. 2

    SN1 step 2 (fast)

    OH⁻ attacks the carbocation

  3. 3

    SN2: one step

    OH⁻ attacks as C–Br breaks, through a transition state; rate = k[RBr][OH⁻]

SN1 has two steps; SN2 has one.

SN1 (tertiary)

Rate equation:
rate=k[RBr]\text{rate} = k[\ce{RBr}]
Number of steps:
Two
Species in slow step:
Halogenoalkane only
Intermediate or transition state:
Carbocation intermediate

SN2 (primary)

Rate equation:
rate=k[RBr][OHX−]\text{rate} = k[\ce{RBr}][\ce{OH-}]
Number of steps:
One
Species in slow step:
Halogenoalkane and OH⁻
Intermediate or transition state:
Transition state only

A halogenoalkane hydrolysis has rate=k[RBr]\text{rate} = k[\ce{RBr}]. Which mechanism is this and what forms in the slow step?

Try an exam question

The overall reaction NOX2+CO→NO+COX2\ce{NO2 + CO -> NO + CO2} has the rate equation rate=k[NOX2]2\text{rate} = k[\ce{NO2}]^2. Suggest a two-step mechanism consistent with this and explain how it fits.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which statement about the rate-determining step is correct?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes