Thermal stability and flame colours
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- In a flame test, heated electrons are excited to higher levels and emit light of a characteristic colour as they fall back.
- Group 2 carbonates decompose to oxide + CO₂; Group 1 carbonates (except lithium) do not decompose at Bunsen temperatures.
- Group 2 nitrates and lithium nitrate give oxide + NO₂ + O₂; other Group 1 nitrates give nitrite + O₂.
- Thermal stability increases down both groups because the cation’s charge density and polarising power fall.
- CO₂ turns limewater milky, O₂ relights a glowing splint and NO₂ is a brown acidic gas.
Flame colours
Heat excites electrons to higher energy levels. When they fall back they emit light of a frequency set by the energy gap, so each metal has its own colour.
In a flame test a nichrome wire is cleaned in concentrated hydrochloric acid, dipped in the sample and held in the edge of a blue Bunsen flame.
The heat promotes electrons to higher energy levels (excitation). When they fall back they emit energy as light. Each metal has a different set of energy gaps, so it emits a characteristic frequency and colour.
- 1
Heat excites electrons
they move to higher energy levels
- 2
Electrons fall back
to lower energy levels
- 3
Light is emitted
ΔE = hν, so each metal gives its own colour
- Electron falls backemits light,
| Lithium | Sodium | Potassium | Calcium | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flame colour | Red | Yellow | Lilac | Brick-red |
| Group | Group 1 | Group 1 | Group 1 | Group 2 |
Lithium
- Flame colour:
- Red
- Group:
- Group 1
Sodium
- Flame colour:
- Yellow
- Group:
- Group 1
Potassium
- Flame colour:
- Lilac
- Group:
- Group 1
Calcium
- Flame colour:
- Brick-red
- Group:
- Group 2
| Strontium | Barium | Magnesium | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flame colour | Red (crimson) | Apple green | No colour |
| Group | Group 2 | Group 2 | Group 2 |
Strontium
- Flame colour:
- Red (crimson)
- Group:
- Group 2
Barium
- Flame colour:
- Apple green
- Group:
- Group 2
Magnesium
- Flame colour:
- No colour
- Group:
- Group 2
Why do different metals give different flame colours?
Decomposing carbonates
Group 2 carbonates and lithium carbonate decompose to the oxide and carbon dioxide; other Group 1 carbonates do not decompose at Bunsen temperatures.
Group 2 carbonates decompose on heating: . Lithium carbonate does the same: . Other Group 1 carbonates do not decompose at Bunsen temperatures.
The thermal stability of the carbonates increases down both groups: magnesium carbonate decomposes at a lower temperature than barium carbonate.
Thermal decomposition is the breakdown of a compound into simpler substances on heating.
Group 1 carbonates
- No decomposition at Bunsen temperatures
- Except lithium carbonate
Lithium carbonate
- Li₂CO₃ → Li₂O + CO₂
- Less stable than other Group 1
Group 2 carbonates
- MCO₃ → MO + CO₂
- More stable down the group
Which carbonate decomposes at the lowest temperature?
Decomposing nitrates
Group 2 nitrates and lithium nitrate give an oxide, nitrogen dioxide and oxygen; the other Group 1 nitrates give a nitrite and oxygen.
Group 2 nitrates and lithium nitrate give the oxide, nitrogen dioxide and oxygen: and .
The other Group 1 nitrates give the nitrite and oxygen: .
Stability again increases down each group, so needs a higher temperature than .
- 1
Group 2 nitrate or lithium nitrate
oxide + NO₂ + O₂ (brown fumes)
- 2
Other Group 1 nitrate
nitrite + O₂ only
Heating sodium nitrate gives a gas that relights a glowing splint but no brown fumes. What is the solid product?
Explaining stability
A small, highly charged cation polarises the anion and weakens it. Down a group the cation is larger, so it polarises less and more heat is needed.
A small cation with a high charge has a high charge density. It polarises (distorts) the electron cloud of a nearby anion and weakens the bonds within it, so the compound decomposes more easily.
Down a group the cation radius increases, so the charge density and polarising power fall. Group 2 ions (2+) are smaller than Group 1 ions (1+) in the same period, so their compounds are less stable. is the smallest Group 1 ion, so lithium compounds behave like those of Group 2.
- 1
Cation radius increases
going down the group
- 2
Charge density falls
weaker polarising power
- 3
Anion distorted less
bonds in the anion weaken less
- 4
Thermal stability increases
higher temperature needed to decompose
Why is lithium carbonate less stable than sodium carbonate?
Testing the gases
Carbon dioxide turns limewater milky, oxygen relights a glowing splint and nitrogen dioxide is brown and turns damp blue litmus red.
To test a decomposition, heat a small amount of the solid in a dry hard-glass test tube, then test the gas.
Limewater is aqueous calcium hydroxide. Carbon dioxide forms insoluble calcium carbonate, which makes it milky: .
A glowing splint relights in oxygen. Nitrogen dioxide is a brown, acidic gas.
| Carbon dioxide | Oxygen | Nitrogen dioxide | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Test | Bubble through limewater | Glowing splint | Damp blue litmus paper |
| Result | Turns milky | Relights | Turns red; gas is brown |
Carbon dioxide
- Test:
- Bubble through limewater
- Result:
- Turns milky
Oxygen
- Test:
- Glowing splint
- Result:
- Relights
Nitrogen dioxide
- Test:
- Damp blue litmus paper
- Result:
- Turns red; gas is brown
- 1
Heat the solid
dry hard-glass test tube
- 2
Test the gas
limewater, splint or damp litmus
- 3
Remove delivery tube from limewater
before stopping heating, to avoid suck-back
A gas turns limewater milky. Which gas is it?
Try an exam question
Describe and explain how the thermal stability of the Group 2 carbonates changes down the group.
[4 marks]
- [1]Thermal stability increases down the group (a higher temperature is needed to decompose).
- [1]The cation radius increases down the group, so the charge density falls.
- [1]The cation polarises the carbonate ion less.
- [1]The bonds in the carbonate ion are weakened less, so more energy is needed to decompose it.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
What colour is seen in the flame test on a barium compound?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
What colour is seen in the flame test on a barium compound?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme