Grignard reagents and carbon chain extension

Grignard reagents and carbon chain extension

Spec 20.2 · Edexcel International A Level Chemistry: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Chain extension needs a new C–C bond: the nitrile route (+1 C) or Grignard reagents.
  • RMgX is made from RX and Mg in dry ether under reflux; the carbon is δ−, so it is a strong nucleophile and base.
  • Water destroys a Grignard reagent, giving an alkane: keep everything dry; ether is highly flammable.
  • RMgX + CO₂, then dilute acid, gives a carboxylic acid with one extra carbon.
  • With carbonyls: methanal gives a primary alcohol, other aldehydes secondary, ketones tertiary.

Why chain length matters

Building a bigger molecule needs a reaction that forms a new carbon–carbon bond.

Most reactions keep the number of carbon atoms the same. To build a bigger molecule you need a reaction that makes a new carbon–carbon bond.

Two methods are in the specification: the nitrile route (haloalkane + cyanide, adding one carbon) and Grignard reagents, which add carbon to carbonyl compounds and to carbon dioxide. Either is chain extension.

  1. 1

    Haloalkane + cyanide

    KCN in ethanol gives a nitrile with one extra carbon

  2. 2

    Haloalkane + magnesium

    dry ether gives a Grignard reagent, RMgX

  3. 3

    Grignard reagent attacks C=O

    forms a new carbon–carbon bond

Two ways to add carbon atoms to a molecule.

Nitrile route

Reagents:
Haloalkane + KCN in ethanol
Carbon added:
One carbon

Grignard route

Reagents:
RMgX + CO₂ or a carbonyl
Carbon added:
One or more carbons

Which of these makes a new carbon–carbon bond?

Making a Grignard reagent

React a haloalkane with magnesium in dry ether under reflux; the carbon bonded to Mg is δ−.

A Grignard reagent, RMgX\ce{RMgX}, is made from a haloalkane and magnesium turnings in dry ether under reflux:

CX2HX5Br+Mg→CX2HX5MgBr\ce{C2H5Br + Mg -> C2H5MgBr}

Magnesium is oxidised from 0 to +2. It is less electronegative than carbon, so the carbon is δ−: a carbanion-like strong nucleophile and strong base.

  1. 1

    Haloalkane + Mg

    In dry ether, under reflux

  2. 2

    RMgX forms

    The carbon is δ−

  3. 3

    Add electrophile

    A carbonyl compound or CO₂

  4. 4

    Add dilute acid

    Releases the alcohol or carboxylic acid

Making and using a Grignard reagent

Why is the carbon bonded to magnesium δ−?

Why everything must be dry

Water protonates the Grignard reagent to give an alkane, destroying it.

A Grignard reagent reacts with water (and alcohols) to give an alkane:

CX2HX5MgBr+HX2O→CX2HX6+Mg(OH)Br\ce{C2H5MgBr + H2O -> C2H6 + Mg(OH)Br}

So glassware, ether and the other reactant need anhydrous conditions.

Ether is the solvent because it is unreactive and its lone pairs stabilise the reagent. It is highly flammable: heat with a water bath or electric heater, never a naked flame.

  1. 1

    C₂H₅MgBr in wet ether

    the carbon is δ− and strongly basic

  2. 2

    Water protonates it

    a proton transfers to the carbon

  3. 3

    Ethane and Mg(OH)Br form

    the reagent is destroyed

  4. 4

    No new C–C bond

    so everything must be anhydrous

What happens if the Grignard reagent meets water.
  • RMgX + H₂Oalkane, so no Grignard reagent left

A Grignard reaction gives mostly ethane instead of the expected product. What is the likely cause?

Carboxylic acids from CO₂

RMgX adds to CO₂ and dilute acid releases a carboxylic acid with one more carbon than the haloalkane.

Add the Grignard reagent to solid carbon dioxide in dry ether. The δ− carbon attacks the δ+ carbon of CO₂ (nucleophilic addition), giving a magnesium carboxylate; dilute acid then gives the acid:

CHX3CHX2CHX2MgBr+COX2→CHX3CHX2CHX2COOMgBr\ce{CH3CH2CH2MgBr + CO2 -> CH3CH2CH2COOMgBr}

CHX3CHX2CHX2COOMgBr+HX+→CHX3CHX2CHX2COOH+MgX2++BrX−\ce{CH3CH2CH2COOMgBr + H+ -> CH3CH2CH2COOH + Mg^2+ + Br-}

The acid has one more carbon than the haloalkane.

  1. 1

    1-bromopropane

    3 carbons

  2. 2

    Mg in dry ether

    Gives CH₃CH₂CH₂MgBr

  3. 3

    Add CO₂

    Gives the magnesium carboxylate

  4. 4

    Dilute acid

    Gives butanoic acid, 4 carbons

1-bromopropane to butanoic acid

Bromoethane is converted to a carboxylic acid via a Grignard reagent and CO₂. Which acid forms?

Alcohols from carbonyl compounds

RMgX adds to C=O; methanal gives a primary alcohol, other aldehydes secondary and ketones tertiary.

Grignard reagents add to the C=O of aldehydes and ketones in dry ether; dilute acid then releases the alcohol.

Example: CHX3MgBr+CHX3COCHX3\ce{CH3MgBr + CH3COCH3}, then HX+\ce{H+}, gives (CHX3)X3COH\ce{(CH3)3COH}, 2-methylpropan-2-ol.

The carbonyl carbon is δ+, the Grignard carbon attacks it, the C=O π bond breaks and an alkoxide forms, which the acid protonates.

  1. 1

    Dry ether

    RMgX adds across the C=O bond

  2. 2

    Intermediate formed

    the carbonyl carbon (δ+) bonds to the R group (δ−)

  3. 3

    Add dilute acid

    releases the alcohol

  4. 4

    Alcohol type

    methanal primary, other aldehydes secondary, ketones tertiary

Making alcohols from carbonyl compounds with a Grignard reagent.

Alcohol formed

Methanal:
Primary
Other aldehydes:
Secondary
Ketones:
Tertiary

Example

Methanal:
CH3CH2OH from CH3MgBr
Other aldehydes:
Propan-2-ol from CH3MgBr + ethanal
Ketones:
2-methylpropan-2-ol from CH3MgBr + propanone

What type of alcohol forms when a Grignard reagent reacts with ethanal, then dilute acid?

Try an exam question

Describe how bromoethane can be converted into propanoic acid using a Grignard reagent. Give reagents and conditions.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which conditions are used to form a Grignard reagent from a haloalkane?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes