Human effects on ecosystems

Human effects on ecosystems

Spec 10.4 · Edexcel A-Level Biology B: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Correlation shows two variables change together; it does not prove causation.
  • Carbon dioxide and methane trap heat; human activity raises their levels (enhanced greenhouse effect).
  • Overfishing is shown by falling catch per unit effort and smaller fish; quotas, mesh sizes and no-take zones help.
  • CITES regulates international trade in endangered species but does not protect habitats.
  • Peer review, journals and conferences validate scientific evidence.

Interpreting data

Use figures from the data, such as percentage change, and remember that correlation does not prove causation.

Humans affect ecosystems through fossil fuels, farming, fishing, deforestation and trade in wild species.

  • Describe trends with figures, for example the percentage change.
  • A correlation shows that two variables change together. It does not prove one causes the other (causation).
  • Longer records, many sites and independent sources make conclusions more reliable.
  • Consider alternative explanations, such as natural variation.
  1. 1

    Describe the trend with figures

  2. 2

    Calculate the percentage change

    (final − initial) ÷ initial × 100

  3. 3

    Correlation is not causation

    two variables changing together

  4. 4

    Test alternatives

    natural variation, longer records, many sites

Reading data about human effects.
  • Percentage changefinal−initialinitial×100\dfrac{\text{final} - \text{initial}}{\text{initial}} \times 100

Worked example

Carbon dioxide rose from 317 ppm to 418 ppm. Calculate the percentage increase.

Two variables show a strong positive correlation. What can you conclude?

Climate change

Burning fossil fuels and deforestation raise carbon dioxide, enhancing the greenhouse effect and warming the planet, which changes ecosystems.

The greenhouse effect is natural: gases such as carbon dioxide and methane absorb infrared radiation re-emitted from the Earth and trap heat. Burning fossil fuels and deforestation raise COX2\ce{CO2}, causing global warming.

Effects on ecosystems:

  • changes in the distribution of species, towards the poles or higher ground
  • changes in timing, such as earlier leafing and breeding
  • mismatches between species, for example when food is not available when young hatch
  • loss of species that cannot adapt or move.
  1. 1

    Human activity

    burning fossil fuels and deforestation

  2. 2

    More greenhouse gases

    carbon dioxide and methane rise

  3. 3

    More heat trapped

    enhanced greenhouse effect

  4. 4

    Global warming

    rising temperatures, melting ice, rising sea level

  5. 5

    Ecosystem effects

    changed distribution, timing and community composition

From activity to ecosystem effects

Give one way climate change can cause a mismatch between species.

Overfishing

Overfishing removes fish faster than stocks can replace them; quotas, mesh sizes and closed areas let stocks recover.

Overfishing removes fish faster than the stock can replace them. Signs: a fall in catch per unit effort, smaller and more immature fish, and falling total catch despite more effort.

The aim is the maximum sustainable yield: the greatest catch each year without reducing the stock.

Measures include quotas, larger mesh sizes, closed seasons or no-take zones, and monitoring with enforcement.

1234567891051015202530fishing effortyearly catchMaximum sustainable yieldcatch
Illustrative values: yearly catch rises with fishing effort to a maximum (the maximum sustainable yield), then falls as stocks collapse.

Quotas

  • Limit the total catch so the stock can replace itself

Larger mesh sizes

  • Juveniles escape and can breed later

No-take zones, closed seasons

  • Protect spawning and nursery areas

Monitoring

  • Checks stocks recover and rules are followed

Which observation suggests overfishing?

CITES and sustainability

CITES controls international trade in endangered species; sustainability balances human needs against conservation.

CITES is the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (1973), with over 180 member countries. It aims to ensure trade does not threaten survival. It has reduced legal trade and raised awareness, but illegal trade continues, it relies on enforcement, and it does not protect habitats.

Sustainability means meeting present needs without preventing future generations meeting theirs. Quotas and cuts in fossil fuel use can cost income or jobs in the short term, while securing resources in the long term. Strategies need evidence, international agreement and enforcement.

  1. 1

    Appendix I

    threatened with extinction: commercial trade banned

  2. 2

    Appendix II

    not yet threatened: trade controlled by permits

  3. 3

    Appendix III

    protected by one country, which asks others to help

CITES appendices.

Appendix I

Status:
Threatened with extinction
Trade:
Commercial trade banned

Appendix II

Status:
Not yet threatened
Trade:
Controlled by permits

Appendix III

Status:
Protected by one country
Trade:
Other countries asked to help

Why can conservation conflict with human needs?

Validating climate evidence

Evidence is checked by peer review, discussed at conferences and replicated, until consistent results build a consensus.

  • Scientific journals publish methods and data so others can examine the work.
  • Peer review: independent experts assess the methods, data and conclusions before publication, to reduce bias and error.
  • Conferences: findings are questioned and challenged.
  • Other scientists replicate the work, and consistent results from different groups build a consensus.

A claim on social media that has not been peer reviewed is less reliable.

  1. 1

    Investigation

    scientists collect and analyse data

  2. 2

    Peer review

    independent experts assess methods and conclusions

  3. 3

    Publication

    journals publish methods and data

  4. 4

    Conferences

    findings are questioned and discussed

  5. 5

    Replication

    other scientists repeat the work

  6. 6

    Consensus

    consistent results build agreement

How evidence is validated

Why is a social media claim less reliable than a peer-reviewed paper?

Try an exam question

Explain how overfishing can be identified from data, and describe two measures to conserve fish stocks.

[5 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which observation is the best indicator that the haddock stock is being overfished?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes