Controlling endemic disease
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- A disease is endemic when it is always present in a region, as malaria is in sub-Saharan Africa.
- Control targets the mosquito population, bites, or infection in people.
- Methods have social, economic and ethical implications.
- Scientists validate methods through trials, peer review, replication and monitoring.
Endemic malaria
Malaria is endemic in many regions and kills many children; control targets the vector, bites or infection.
A disease is endemic when it is always present in a region. Malaria is endemic in much of sub-Saharan Africa and parts of Asia and South America, where it causes illness and many deaths, especially in young children.
Malaria is transmitted by the female Anopheles mosquito (the vector), so control methods target one of three things.
Each method has social, economic and ethical implications, and the scientific community checks that it works.
- 1
Mosquito population
fewer vectors
- 2
Bites
prevent contact
- 3
Infection in people
treat and protect
What does endemic mean?
Control methods
Methods reduce mosquitoes, stop bites or treat and prevent infection in people.
Methods fall into three groups, matching the three targets.
Spraying insecticide such as DDT inside walls kills mosquitoes that rest there. Removing or treating breeding sites reduces numbers. Genetically modified mosquitoes could reduce the population or stop them carrying the parasite.
Bed nets stop night-time bites and kill mosquitoes that land on them.
Antimalarial drugs treat infection and protect people at risk, and a vaccine makes memory cells against Plasmodium.
- 1
Reduce the mosquito population
insecticide, draining breeding sites, GM mosquitoes
- 2
Stop bites
insecticide-treated bed nets
- 3
Treat and protect people
antimalarial drugs and a vaccine
Mosquito population
- Insecticide spraying (DDT)
- Draining pools, larvicides
- Genetically modified mosquitoes
Bites
- Insecticide-treated bed nets
Infection in people
- Antimalarial drugs
- Vaccine
Which method prevents mosquito bites?
Ethical implications
Ethical issues weigh lives saved against harm to the environment, fairness and consent.
Ethical implications concern what is right or fair.
- DDT saves lives but persists in the environment and builds up in food chains, harming wildlife.
- Draining marshes destroys habitats for other species.
- Genetically modified mosquitoes cannot easily be recalled once released, and the effect on food webs is uncertain.
- Fair access: limited budgets mean choosing whom to protect first, and poorer people should not be left unprotected.
- In clinical trials, control groups must be treated fairly, for example by receiving the intervention afterwards.
- 1
DDT
saves lives but builds up in food chains
- 2
Draining marshes
destroys habitats for other species
- 3
GM mosquitoes
cannot be recalled once released
- 4
Fair access
limited budgets mean choosing whom to protect first
Benefit
- DDT kills mosquitoes and saves lives
- Draining pools removes breeding sites
Ethical concern
- DDT builds up in food chains
- Habitats destroyed
Why might releasing genetically modified mosquitoes be an ethical concern?
The scientific community
Controlled trials, peer review, replication and monitoring show a method is effective and safe.
The scientific community checks that control methods work and are safe. Large controlled trials with a control group are published and checked by independent experts (peer review). Results are replicated in different places, because they vary locally.
Bodies such as the WHO gather the evidence and advise governments, and long-term effects such as resistance are monitored.
Science gives the evidence, but decisions about money and ethics also depend on society.
- 1
Controlled trial
large sample with a control group
- 2
Publication
results are published
- 3
Peer review
independent experts check them
- 4
Replication
repeated in different places
- 5
Advice and monitoring
WHO advises; long-term effects tracked
Why are results replicated in different places?
Try an exam question
Evaluate the use of insecticide-treated bed nets to control malaria in a poor rural region.
[4 marks]
- [1]They prevent bites from Anopheles mosquitoes at night and kill mosquitoes that land on them.
- [1]They are relatively cheap compared with the cost of illness, so fewer working and school days are lost.
- [1]They only work if used correctly every night, so education is needed (social).
- [1]Insecticide resistance can develop and nets must be replaced, adding cost.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which organism must the bed nets protect people against to reduce the transmission of malaria?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which organism must the bed nets protect people against to reduce the transmission of malaria?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Social and economic implications
Methods depend on people using them and on money to buy, distribute and replace them.
Social: nets work only if families use them correctly every night, so education is needed (some use nets for fishing). Drugs must be taken for the full course or treatment fails and resistance develops. Draining wetlands or spraying homes may disturb communities, and genetically modified mosquitoes need public acceptance.
Economic: methods cost money to buy, distribute and replace. Poorer countries rely on richer countries and charities. Fewer cases mean fewer lost working and school days and lower health costs, so control can pay for itself. Resistance can make a method fail and raise costs later.
Social
correct net use, full drug courses, public acceptance
Economic
cost to buy, distribute and replace; funding from richer countries
Pay-off
fewer cases mean fewer lost working and school days
Social
Economic
Why must antimalarial drugs be taken for the full course?