Errors, uncertainties and error bars

Errors, uncertainties and error bars

Spec 3.1.2 · AQA A-Level Physics: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Random errors scatter readings and are reduced by repeats; systematic errors shift every reading and need calibration or a better method.
  • Precision is about scatter, accuracy is about closeness to the true value.
  • Percentage uncertainty = absolute uncertainty ÷ value × 100%.
  • Add absolute uncertainties for + and −; add percentage uncertainties for × and ÷; multiply by the power for powers.
  • Gradient uncertainty = best gradient − worst gradient.

Random and systematic errors

Random errors scatter readings about the true value; systematic errors shift every reading the same way.

A random error gives unpredictable scatter, for example from reaction time or reading a scale by eye. Repeat readings and a mean reduce it, as do a larger sample or finer resolution.

A systematic error shifts all readings by the same amount or proportion, such as a zero error, a wrong calibration or viewing a scale from the same wrong angle. Repeating does not remove it.

Random error

Effect on readings:
Scatter above and below the true value
Reduced by a mean of repeats?:
Yes
Reduced by:
Repeats, larger sample, finer resolution

Systematic error

Effect on readings:
All shifted the same way
Reduced by a mean of repeats?:
No
Reduced by:
Calibration, zero check, correcting the method

A micrometer reads 0.02 mm when closed. What type of error is this, and does averaging repeats remove it?

Precision and accuracy

Precision is the scatter of repeated readings, whereas accuracy is how close a reading is to the true value.

These terms are easily confused, so learn each exactly. Precision is how close repeated readings are to each other. Accuracy is how close a reading is to the true value, and resolution is the smallest change the instrument can detect, such as 0.01 mm on a micrometer.

A set of readings can be precise but inaccurate if a systematic error shifts them all.

  • Precisereadings agree closely with each other
  • Accuratereading is close to the true value
  • Resolutionsmallest change detected

Repeatability

Who and what changes:
Same person, method and equipment
Outcome:
Results agree closely

Reproducibility

Who and what changes:
Different people or equipment, or a different method
Outcome:
Results agree closely

Five readings of a 1.00 kg mass on a balance are 1.12, 1.12, 1.13, 1.12, 1.12 kg. Describe them.

Absolute, fractional and percentage uncertainty

An uncertainty gives the range in which the true value is expected to lie, and can be absolute, fractional or a percentage.

From repeat readings, take the uncertainty in the mean as half the range: (largest − smallest) ÷ 2. For a single reading it is at least the instrument resolution.

Give an uncertainty to 1 significant figure (2 if it starts with 1), and quote the value to the same number of decimal places: 2.00 ± 0.02 cm, not 2.0 ± 0.02 cm.

  • AbsoluteΔX\Delta X, in the unit of XX
  • FractionalΔX÷X\Delta X \div X
  • PercentageΔXX×100%\dfrac{\Delta X}{X} \times 100\%

Worked example

Repeat readings of a length are 2.00, 2.02, 1.98 and 2.00 cm. Find the mean, its uncertainty and its percentage uncertainty.

Which is correctly quoted?

Combining uncertainties

The rule depends on the operation: add absolute uncertainties, add percentage uncertainties, or multiply by the power.

If a=4.0±0.2a = 4.0 \pm 0.2 cm and b=6.0±0.3b = 6.0 \pm 0.3 cm, then a+b=10.0±0.5a + b = 10.0 \pm 0.5 cm and b−a=2.0±0.5b - a = 2.0 \pm 0.5 cm.

For a cube of side 2.00 ± 0.02 cm (1.0%), the volume has a percentage uncertainty of 3 × 1.0% = 3.0%.

You do not combine uncertainties for trigonometric or logarithmic functions at this level.

  • a+ba + b or a−ba - badd absolute uncertainties
  • a×ba \times b or a÷ba \div badd percentage uncertainties
  • ana^nmultiply percentage uncertainty by nn

Worked example

Density = 85.0 g ÷ 8.00 cm³, with percentage uncertainties of 0.59% in the mass and 3.0% in the volume. Find the density with its uncertainty.

A radius is measured with a 2% uncertainty. What is the percentage uncertainty in the area πr2\pi r^2?

Error bars and gradients

The uncertainty in a gradient is the difference between the best-fit gradient and the worst acceptable gradient.

An error bar shows the range of a point's uncertainty, vertically, horizontally or both.

Draw a best-fit line, then a worst acceptable line (steepest or shallowest) that still passes through all the error bars. Calculate both gradients with a large triangle.

Treat the intercept the same way. If theory predicts a line through the origin but the intercept range excludes zero, a systematic error is likely.

0.511.522.533.544.5524681012xy(2.5, 6)best fit, gradient 2.0worst line, gradient 2.4
Illustrative: best-fit gradient 2.0, worst line (dashed) 2.4, uncertainty 0.4

A best-fit line has gradient 5.2 and the worst acceptable line has gradient 4.6. What is the gradient with its uncertainty?

Try an exam question

A student measures the side of a cube as 2.00 ± 0.02 cm and its mass as 85.0 ± 0.5 g. Calculate the percentage uncertainty in the volume and in the density.

[5 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What type of error is shown by the reading of 0.02 mm when the jaws of the gauge are closed?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes