Rutherford scattering and nuclear radius

Rutherford scattering and nuclear radius

AQA A-Level Physics: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • In the Geiger–Marsden experiment most alpha particles passed through gold foil, but about 1 in 8000 was deflected through more than 90°.
  • This showed an atom has a tiny, dense, positive nucleus containing nearly all of its mass.
  • Closest approach gives an upper limit for the nuclear radius: r=Qq4πε0Ekr = \dfrac{Qq}{4\pi\varepsilon_0E_k}.
  • Electron diffraction gives a more accurate radius: first minimum at sin⁡θ≈1.22λD\sin\theta \approx \dfrac{1.22\lambda}{D}.
  • R=R0A1/3R = R_0A^{1/3} with R0≈1.2R_0 \approx 1.2 fm, so all nuclei have the same density, about 2.3×10172.3\times10^{17} kg m⁻³.

Rutherford scattering

Most alpha particles passed straight through, but a few were deflected through large angles: the atom has a small, dense, positive nucleus.

In the Geiger–Marsden experiment a narrow beam of alpha particles was fired at very thin gold foil in a vacuum, and the numbers scattered at different angles were counted. The foil was thin so each particle was scattered by a single nucleus, and the vacuum prevented absorption by air.

The scattering matched an inverse-square electric repulsion between the nucleus and the alpha particle.

straight throughsmall deflectionlarge angleN
Alpha particles fired at a gold nucleus: most go straight through, some are deflected slightly, and a very few are turned through more than 90°.

Most pass straight through

  • Most of an atom is empty space

About 1 in 8000 deflected through more than 90°

  • Positive charge and nearly all the mass are concentrated in a tiny nucleus

Scattering matches inverse-square repulsion

  • The nucleus repels the positive alpha particles with an electric force

What did the few alpha particles scattered through more than 90° show?

Changing models of the atom

Each model was replaced when new evidence could not be explained by it.

A theory is accepted until new evidence cannot be explained by it. The plum pudding model predicted only small deflections of alpha particles, so large-angle scattering ruled it out.

  1. 1904

    Plum pudding

    Thomson: positive sphere with electrons embedded; predicts only small deflections.

  2. 1911

    Nuclear model

    Rutherford: small dense positive nucleus, electrons far away.

  3. 1932

    Neutron

    Chadwick: explains the extra mass of nuclei.

  4. 1968

    Quarks

    High-energy electron scattering shows protons and neutrons have structure.

Solid sphere (Dalton)

+++++++++−−−−−−−−

Plum pudding (Thomson)

+

Nuclear model (Rutherford)

How the model of the atom changed: Dalton, plum pudding, nuclear.

Why was the plum pudding model rejected?

Closest approach

A head-on alpha particle stops where all its kinetic energy has become electric potential energy; that distance is an upper limit for the nuclear radius.

A head-on alpha particle slows as it approaches a nucleus because of the electric repulsion. At the distance of closest approach it is momentarily at rest and all its kinetic energy is electric potential energy. QQ and qq are the nuclear and alpha charges, 2e2e for an alpha particle and ZeZe for the nucleus.

The alpha particle never touches the nucleus, so rr is an upper limit to the nuclear radius.

12345678910123456xyclosest approachelectric potential energyinitial kinetic energy
Illustrative: potential energy rises as 1/r; the alpha particle stops where it equals its starting kinetic energy (closest approach).
  • Closest approachEk=Qq4πε0rE_k = \dfrac{Qq}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 r}

Worked example

A 7.7 MeV alpha particle is fired head-on at a gold nucleus (Z=79Z = 79). Estimate the distance of closest approach.

Why is the distance of closest approach only an upper limit for the nuclear radius?

Electron diffraction

High-energy electrons have a wavelength about the size of a nucleus; the first minimum of the diffraction pattern gives the nuclear diameter.

Electrons of hundreds of MeV have a de Broglie wavelength λ=h/p\lambda = h/p about the size of a nucleus (around 10−1510^{-15} m), with p≈E/cp \approx E/c. Scattering by a nucleus gives a diffraction pattern: intensity against angle falls to a first minimum, then rises to a smaller maximum.

Here DD is the nuclear diameter, so the radius is D/2D/2. This is more accurate than closest approach, because electrons do not feel the strong force.

0.511.522.530.20.40.60.81xyfirst minimumintensity
Illustrative electron diffraction by a nucleus (arbitrary angle units): intensity falls to a first minimum, then rises to a smaller maximum.
  • First minimumsin⁡θ≈1.22λD\sin\theta \approx \dfrac{1.22\lambda}{D}

Why are high-energy electrons used to measure the size of a nucleus?

Nuclear radius and density

Nuclear radius is proportional to the cube root of the nucleon number, so every nucleus has the same density, about 10¹⁷ kg m⁻³.

Nuclear radii are between about 1 fm and 8 fm, around 10510^5 times smaller than an atom. Since volume ∝R3∝A\propto R^3 \propto A and mass ∝A\propto A, the density is the same for all nuclei: constant density.

ρ=Au43πR03A=3u4πR03≈2.3×1017\rho = \dfrac{Au}{\frac43\pi R_0^3A} = \dfrac{3u}{4\pi R_0^3} \approx 2.3\times10^{17} kg m⁻³.

2040608010012014016018020022024012345678xyA = 8: 2.4 fmA = 56: 4.6 fmA = 216: 7.2 fmR = 1.2A^(1/3)
Nuclear radius (fm) against nucleon number, R = 1.2A^(1/3).
  • Nuclear radiusR=R0A1/3R = R_0A^{1/3}, R0≈1.2R_0 \approx 1.2 fm

Worked example

Find the radius of a ⁵⁶Fe nucleus, and compare nuclear density with that of iron (7.9×1037.9\times10^3 kg m⁻³).

Nucleus X has 8 times as many nucleons as nucleus Y. What is the ratio of the radius of X to the radius of Y?

Try an exam question

Describe the results of the Geiger–Marsden alpha particle scattering experiment and explain what each result showed about the structure of the atom.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

What can be concluded from the observation that almost all the alpha particles pass through the foil with little or no deflection?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes