Evidence for evolution

Evidence for evolution

IB MYP Biology: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Fossils in rock layers show how life changed; the deepest layers are oldest, but the record is incomplete.
  • Homologous structures have the same bone pattern but different uses, which suggests a common ancestor.
  • The fewer the differences in DNA or protein, the more closely related the species.
  • Lamarck said acquired characteristics are inherited; Darwin said natural selection acts on inherited variation.
  • Characteristics gained in life are not inherited.

The fossil record

Fossils in layered rock form a timeline of how organisms changed, but the record has gaps.

Fossils are the preserved remains or traces of organisms, mostly formed when bones or shells are buried in sediment and replaced by minerals. In sedimentary rock the deepest layers are the oldest. Sequences, such as those of whale ancestors, show gradual change over millions of years.

  1. 1

    Organism dies

    It is buried in sediment

  2. 2

    Hard parts replaced

    Bones or shells are slowly replaced by minerals

  3. 3

    Rock forms

    The sediment becomes sedimentary rock in layers

  4. 4

    Fossil found

    The deepest layers are the oldest

How a fossil forms

Fossils show

  • Gradual change over millions of years
  • Extinct species linked to living ones

Record is incomplete because

  • Soft-bodied organisms decay without leaving fossils
  • Fossilisation needs special conditions
  • Geological activity destroys fossils
  • Many fossils are not yet found

In undisturbed layers of sedimentary rock, which fossils are oldest?

Homologous structures

The same bone pattern in different species is best explained by descent from a common ancestor.

The forelimbs of a human, bat, whale and horse have different jobs but the same basic pattern of bones. These are homologous structures. Natural selection adapted the limbs from a common ancestor to different ways of life.

  1. 1

    Common ancestor

    has a forelimb with the basic bone pattern

  2. 2

    Natural selection

    adapts the limb to different ways of life

  3. 3

    Different uses

    human grasping, bat flying, whale swimming, horse running

  4. 4

    Same bone pattern

    still visible in every species

From one ancestor to four different limbs.

Human

Forelimb used for:
Grasping
Same basic bone pattern:
Yes

Bat

Forelimb used for:
Flying
Same basic bone pattern:
Yes

Whale

Forelimb used for:
Swimming
Same basic bone pattern:
Yes

Horse

Forelimb used for:
Running
Same basic bone pattern:
Yes

What does the same bone pattern in a bat wing and a human arm suggest?

DNA and protein similarities

The fewer the differences in DNA or protein, the more recent the common ancestor.

Scientists compare DNA base sequences and amino acid sequences. Fewer differences mean a more recent common ancestor, so less time for mutations to build up. Human cytochrome c is much more similar to a monkey's than to a fish's. This evidence can be checked against fossils and anatomy and works for any species with DNA.

0102030401Rhesus monkeyHorseTunaYeastSpeciesAmino acid differences
Differences in the amino acids of cytochrome c compared with humans: fewer differences mean a more recent common ancestor.
  • Fewer differencesmore closely related

Species X and Y have very few differences in their DNA. What can you conclude?

Lamarck and Darwin

Lamarck said acquired characteristics are inherited; Darwin said natural selection acts on inherited variation.

Lamarck suggested organisms change by use and disuse and pass on acquired characteristics. Darwin explained giraffes differently: they vary because of their alleles, longer-necked ones survive and reproduce more, and pass on their alleles. Evidence supports Darwin: characteristics gained in life, such as big muscles, are not inherited, because the alleles in the sex cells are unchanged.

  1. 1

    Variation

    neck length differs because of alleles

  2. 2

    Selection

    longer-necked giraffes survive and reproduce more

  3. 3

    Inheritance

    they pass on their alleles

  4. 4

    Change

    the population gets longer necks over generations

Darwin's explanation of the giraffe's neck.

Lamarck

Cause of change:
Use and disuse during life
Passed on?:
Acquired characteristics are inherited
Giraffe neck:
Stretching lengthens the neck; young inherit it

Darwin

Cause of change:
Natural selection of inherited variation
Passed on?:
Only alleles are inherited
Giraffe neck:
Longer-necked giraffes survive and reproduce more

A weightlifter develops large muscles. Will their children be born with large muscles because of this?

Try an exam question

Describe how fossils and homologous structures each provide evidence for evolution.

[4 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

In undisturbed layers of sedimentary rock, where are the oldest fossils usually found?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes