Ethics of biotechnology
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- An ethical issue is a question about what is right or wrong where people may disagree.
- Weigh up benefits, risks, ethical issues and evidence, then give a justified conclusion.
- GM crops: higher yields and nutrition against gene spread, costly seed and unknown long-term effects.
- Stem cells, cloning, gene therapy, screening and bioprinting each have benefits and ethical issues.
- A strong answer gives two benefits, two drawbacks, evidence and a reasoned recommendation.
Weighing up biotechnology
Weigh benefits, risks, ethical issues and evidence, then reach a justified conclusion.
Scientists, governments and the public ask who gains and how much, what the risks are for health, environment and safety, whether it is right and fair and who decides, and how strong the evidence is. A good evaluation gives points on both sides, uses evidence, and ends with a justified conclusion.
- 1
Benefits
Who gains, how much
- 2
Risks
Health, environment, safety
- 3
Ethical issues
Is it right, is it fair, who decides
- 4
Evidence
How strong and reliable it is
- 5
Conclusion
A decision with reasons
What makes a conclusion justified?
GM crops
GM crops can raise yields and nutrition, but they raise questions about the environment, cost and unknown effects.
A GM crop has a gene from another organism. Examples: golden rice (beta-carotene for vitamin A), crops resistant to insects or herbicides, and drought-resistant crops.
- 1
Find the gene
For example one for insect resistance
- 2
Cut it out
Using enzymes
- 3
Insert into crop cells
The cells now carry the new gene
- 4
Grow the plants
Each plant has the new characteristic
Benefits
- Higher yields
- More nutritious food, such as golden rice
- Less pesticide use
- Grow in harsh conditions
Risks and issues
- Genes may spread to wild relatives
- Effects on other organisms
- Costly seed; farmers become dependent
- Long-term effects not fully known
Give one benefit and one risk of GM crops.
Cloning and stem cells
Cloning copies useful organisms; stem cells could replace damaged cells, but both raise ethical questions.
Stem cells are unspecialised cells that can divide and differentiate into many cell types. They could replace damaged cells in spinal injuries or diabetes. Many people believe an embryo is a potential human life; supporters point out that leftover IVF embryos would be destroyed anyway.
- 1
Stem cell
Unspecialised
- 2
Divides many times
Makes more stem cells
- 3
Differentiates
Becomes a specialised cell type
- 4
Replaces damaged cells
For example in spinal injuries or diabetes
Cloning
- Many identical copies of useful plants or animals
- No genetic variation, low success rate, cost, animal welfare, fears about human cloning
Embryonic stem cells
- Taken from early embryos, which destroys them
- Can become many cell types
Adult stem cells
- Found in tissues such as bone marrow
- Make fewer types of cell
Why is lack of genetic variation a drawback of cloning?
Gene therapy and genetic screening
Gene therapy could treat the cause of disorders and screening can find them early, but both raise issues.
Gene therapy could treat the cause, but the effect may wear off, it may carry risks, and it is expensive. Genetic screening (newborns, carriers, embryos) can find disorders early. A designer baby is one whose features have been chosen by parents, usually after screening embryos.
- 1
Faulty gene found
Causes the disorder
- 2
Healthy gene copied
Placed inside a carrier such as a harmless virus
- 3
Carrier enters cells
The healthy gene is delivered into the patient's cells
- 4
Cells make the protein
The effect may wear off over time
Gene therapy
- Treats the cause
- Effect may wear off
- Risks and expense
Genetic screening
- Finds disorders early
- Anxiety and false results
- Privacy and discrimination
- Designer babies; ending a pregnancy
What is a designer baby?
Bioprinting
Bioprinting could provide skin, organs and drug testing without animals, but it is costly and unproven.
Bioprinting builds tissues from layers of living cells. It could provide skin for burns, replace donor organs and test drugs without animals.
- 1
Take cells
From the patient or a donor
- 2
Grow them
In a culture to make enough
- 3
Mix with gel
Makes a printable bio-ink
- 4
Print in layers
A printer builds the tissue shape
Benefits
- Skin for burns
- Replacement organs without donors
- Drug testing without animals
Issues
- High cost and unfair access
- Whole organs not yet possible (blood vessels)
- Long-term safety not known
- Where the cells come from
Give one benefit and one ethical issue of bioprinting.
Answering a Criterion D question
Give at least two benefits, two drawbacks, use evidence from the question and finish with a justified conclusion.
Criterion D is the MYP science criterion about reflecting on the impacts of science on society and the environment. Drawbacks can be ethical, social, economic or environmental. Listing only advantages, or only drawbacks, earns few marks.
- 1
Benefits
At least two, with who gains
- 2
Risks and drawbacks
At least two: ethical, social, economic or environmental
- 3
Evidence
Data or results from the question
- 4
Justified conclusion
What you recommend and why
How many benefits and drawbacks should a strong answer include?
Try an exam question
Discuss the use of genetically modified crops such as golden rice.
[4 marks]
- [1]Benefit: golden rice makes beta-carotene, which the body turns into vitamin A, so it can prevent blindness.
- [1]Benefit: GM crops can give higher yields and need less pesticide.
- [1]Risk: genes may spread to wild relatives; long-term effects are not fully known.
- [1]A justified conclusion that weighs benefits against risks.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
What is genetic modification?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
What is genetic modification?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme