Investigating diversity

Investigating diversity

Spec 3.4.7 · AQA A-Level Biology: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Genetic diversity is the variety of alleles and genes within or between species.
  • It can be investigated by comparing characteristics, DNA, mRNA or amino acid sequences.
  • More differences between sequences means an older common ancestor.
  • Comparing DNA reveals more than comparing proteins, because the code is degenerate and some DNA is non-coding.
  • A small standard deviation means values are clustered close to the mean.

Investigating genetic diversity

You can compare observable characteristics, or the base sequences of DNA and mRNA, or the amino acid sequence of proteins.

Genetic diversity is the variety of alleles and genes within a species or between species.

Within or between species you can compare:

  • the frequency of measurable or observable characteristics, such as height, flower colour or fur colour
  • the base sequence of DNA
  • the base sequence of mRNA
  • the amino acid sequence of the proteins encoded
  1. 1

    DNA base sequence

    the genetic code

  2. 2

    mRNA base sequence

    copied from DNA

  3. 3

    Amino acid sequence

    the protein that is made

Information flows from DNA to protein, so each level can be compared

Which can be compared to investigate genetic diversity?

Comparing sequences

The more differences between sequences, the longer ago two organisms shared a common ancestor.

DNA codes for mRNA, which codes for the amino acid sequence of a protein. Mutations change the base sequence over time, and some change the protein.

The more differences between the sequences of two organisms, the longer ago they shared a common ancestor, so the more distantly related they are. Few differences suggest a close relationship.

051015201Human and rhesus monkeyHuman and tunaComparisonAmino acid differences
Amino acid differences in the same protein: more differences mean an older common ancestor.

Human and rhesus monkey

Amino acid differences in the same protein:
1
Interpretation:
More recent common ancestor

Human and tuna

Amino acid differences in the same protein:
21
Interpretation:
Older common ancestor

Species X differs from humans in 3 amino acids and species Y in 15. Which shared a more recent ancestor with humans?

Differences hidden in proteins

Comparing DNA detects differences that proteins hide, because the code is degenerate and some DNA is non-coding.

The genetic code is degenerate, so a change in a base may not change the amino acid.

DNA also contains non-coding DNA that is never translated. These differences are only detected by comparing DNA directly.

  1. 1

    Base changes in DNA

    a mutation

  2. 2

    Degenerate code

    the codon still codes for the same amino acid

  3. 3

    Protein unchanged

    missed by comparing proteins

  4. 4

    Comparing DNA

    detects the difference directly

A change hidden from proteins but seen in DNA.

Comparing proteins

Base change that does not alter the amino acid:
Missed
Non-coding DNA:
Missed

Comparing DNA

Base change that does not alter the amino acid:
Detected
Non-coding DNA:
Detected

Why might two species have identical proteins but different DNA?

Gene technology

Gene technology compares DNA directly, which is more accurate and objective than judging characteristics.

In the past, genetic diversity was inferred from observable characteristics. These can mislead because they are influenced by the environment, by recessive alleles and by several genes acting together.

Gene technology now allows base sequences of DNA to be compared directly. You do not need to know how the technologies work.

  1. 1

    Observable characteristics

    affected by the environment, recessive alleles and several genes

  2. 2

    Can mislead

    about genetic diversity

  3. 3

    Gene technology

    compares DNA base sequences directly: more accurate and objective

Characteristics against DNA.

Observable characteristics

Influenced by the environment:
Yes
Hidden by recessive alleles:
Yes
Several genes acting together can mislead:
Yes

DNA base sequence

Influenced by the environment:
No
Hidden by recessive alleles:
No
Several genes acting together can mislead:
No

Why is comparing DNA more accurate than comparing characteristics?

Quantitative investigations

Use random samples, calculate the mean and standard deviation, and interpret overlapping ranges as possible chance.

To investigate variation within a species, collect data from random samples to avoid bias. Calculate the mean and the standard deviation. You will not have to calculate a standard deviation, but you must interpret it.

Larger samples give more reliable means.

−6−4−22460.10.20.30.40.5xysmall SDlarge SD
Two distributions with the same mean: a small standard deviation (tall, narrow) and a large one (low, wide). Illustrative.
  • Small standard deviationvalues clustered close to the mean
  • Large standard deviationmore variation
  • Mean ± SD ranges overlapthe difference may be due to chance

Two samples have overlapping mean ± SD ranges. What can you say?

Try an exam question

Explain why comparing DNA base sequences gives more information about genetic diversity than comparing amino acid sequences.

[3 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which conclusion is best supported by these data?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes