Conservation of habitats
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Many valuable habitats (heathland, chalk grassland) are at an early stage of succession and are lost to scrub and woodland if left alone.
- Conservation often means managing succession, holding the community as a plagioclimax to maintain biodiversity.
- Techniques include grazing, mowing with cuttings removed, coppicing, re-wetting and restricting access.
- Human needs conflict with conservation; sustainable use means the rate of use does not exceed the rate of replacement.
- Evaluate conflicting evidence by checking bias, sample, controls, numbers and causation, then conclude.
Why habitats need managing
Habitats such as heathland and meadows are early stages of succession. Left alone, scrub and woodland shade out the specialised species, so they are managed to hold succession back.
If left alone, succession continues: open habitats are replaced by scrub and then woodland, which shades out the specialised species that depend on them.
Conservation therefore frequently involves management of succession, holding the community at an earlier stage. A community held in this way by human activity is a plagioclimax. The aim is to maintain biodiversity.
- 1
Open grassland
many light-demanding species, high species diversity
- 2
Scrub
shrubs and tree seedlings begin to grow
- 3
Woodland
tall trees shade the ground; specialised grassland species are lost
Why does a heathland lose species if it is left unmanaged?
Management techniques
Techniques are chosen to prevent succession or restore a habitat. Always link the technique to its reason.
Grazing removes tree seedlings and tall vegetation. Mowing, with the cuttings removed, prevents scrub and stops nutrients returning to the soil, so fast-growing species cannot dominate.
Other techniques: removing scrub by hand, controlled burning of heather, coppicing woodland, re-wetting a drained habitat (for example blocking ditches on a bog) and replanting, and restricting access with fencing or boardwalks.
- 1
Open habitat
for example heathland or grassland
- 2
Scrub and tree seedlings invade
if nothing is done
- 3
Woodland replaces the habitat
open-habitat species are lost
- 4
Management holds it back
grazing, mowing, burning or scrub removal
Grazing
- Removes tree seedlings and tall vegetation, so succession is held back
Mowing, cuttings removed
- Prevents scrub; removes nutrients so fast-growing species cannot dominate
Coppicing
- Lets light reach the woodland floor, so ground flora survives
Re-wetting or restricting access
- Restores waterlogged conditions; stops trampling so plants recover
Why are the cuttings removed after mowing a meadow?
Human needs and conservation
People use land and resources for food, fuel, housing, jobs and income. Use is sustainable only if the rate of use does not exceed the rate of replacement.
These needs often conflict with conservation: a wetland drained for farming, a bog dug for peat, a woodland cleared for building.
The key idea is sustainability: using natural resources so they can be maintained for future generations. Peat forms at about 1 mm per year, so it cannot be used sustainably when extracted quickly.
The conflict must be managed by balancing the needs of people and wildlife.
- 1
People need resources
food, fuel, housing, jobs and income
- 2
Habitat is used or cleared
drained, dug or built on
- 3
Use faster than replacement
for example peat forms about 1 mm a year
- 4
Balance needs of people and wildlife
sustainable management
Food
- A wetland is drained for farming
Fuel
- A bog is dug for peat
Housing
- A woodland is cleared for building
- Sustainable userate of use does not exceed rate of replacement
Why is extracting peat quickly not sustainable?
Compromises
Compromise lets people benefit without destroying the habitat: zoning, quotas, involving local people, alternatives and restoration.
Conflicts are managed through compromise.
Examples: grazing to keep heathland open; fencing and boardwalks to protect sand dunes from trampling; regulated sustainable fishing in a wetland.
Ecotourism gives local people an income from the habitat, so they have a reason to protect it.
- 1
Identify the conflict
- 2
Involve local people
- 3
Zone the area and set quotas
- 4
Provide alternatives
ecotourism, peat-free compost
- 5
Restore damaged habitat
Zoning
- Use allowed in limited areas
- Breeding sites protected
Licences and quotas
- Limit fishing or harvesting
Local involvement
- Local people help decide
- Alternative income, such as ecotourism
Alternatives and restoration
- For example peat-free compost
- Restore damaged habitats once use has ended
How does ecotourism help conservation?
Evaluating conflicting evidence
Check the source for bias, the sample, controls, quantification, causation and scale. Then weigh the evidence and give a justified conclusion.
Consider whether the source is independent or has a financial or political interest, and whether one summer or a small sample is representative. Look for control areas or before-and-after data, and measured values rather than statements without numbers.
Correlation may not mean causation, and effects may extend beyond the site or take decades to appear.
Finish with a justified conclusion that weighs the evidence, and say what further data you would need.
- 1
Source
independent or biased?
- 2
Sample
size, duration, repeats
- 3
Comparisons
control area or before and after
- 4
Quantification
measured values
- 5
Causation
correlation is not proof
- 6
Scale and timescale
- 7
Justified conclusion
say what further data is needed
Check
- Source
- Sample size, duration, repeats
- Comparisons
- Quantification
- Correlation or causation
- Scale and timescale
Weakness if missing
- Bias from a financial or political interest
- Not representative
- No control to compare against
- Weaker than measured values
- Other factors may explain the pattern
- Effects may extend beyond the site
A study funded by a company that wants to dig peat finds no harm to the bog. Which weakness should you point out?
Try an exam question
Explain how grazing can be used to conserve a heathland.
[3 marks]
- [1]Without management, succession continues and scrub and woodland replace heathland.
- [1]Grazing removes tree seedlings and tall vegetation, holding succession at an earlier stage.
- [1]Light-demanding species are not shaded out, so biodiversity is maintained.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Why does the heathland need to be managed to conserve it?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Why does the heathland need to be managed to conserve it?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme