Limiting factors in photosynthesis

Limiting factors in photosynthesis

Spec 3.5.1 · AQA A-Level Biology: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • A limiting factor is the factor in shortest supply, which sets the rate; only one limits at a time.
  • Light, carbon dioxide, temperature and water can all limit photosynthesis.
  • At low light, GP accumulates and RuBP and triose phosphate fall.
  • Above the optimum temperature, enzymes such as rubisco are denatured.
  • Growers raise limiting factors in glasshouses, but must weigh the extra cost against the extra yield.

What limits the rate?

A limiting factor is the variable in shortest supply; raising it increases the rate until another factor limits.

A limiting factor is the variable in shortest supply, which sets the rate of photosynthesis. It can be light intensity, carbon dioxide concentration, temperature or water. At any time only one factor is limiting.

Increasing a factor that is not limiting has no effect. Once the limiting factor is raised enough, another factor becomes limiting and the graph levels off.

1234567891024681012xyplateau, high CO₂plateau, low CO₂High CO₂Low CO₂
Rate against light intensity at two CO₂ levels (illustrative, not real data)

On the plateau of the low CO₂ curve, what limits the rate?

Light intensity

At low light, too little ATP and reduced NADP are made, so GP cannot be reduced fast enough.

Light provides the energy for the light-dependent reaction.

At low light intensity, little ATP and reduced NADP are made, so GP is reduced slowly. GP accumulates while RuBP and triose phosphate fall.

The rate rises in proportion to light intensity until another factor becomes limiting. Wavelength matters too, as pigments absorb red and blue light best.

  1. 1

    Low light

    little light energy absorbed

  2. 2

    Less ATP and reduced NADP

    made in the light-dependent reaction

  3. 3

    GP reduced slowly

    so GP accumulates

  4. 4

    RuBP and triose phosphate fall

    so the rate of photosynthesis is low

Effect of low light on the Calvin cycle

At low light intensity, which compound accumulates?

Carbon dioxide concentration

Carbon dioxide is the substrate for rubisco, so more of it gives more GP until another factor limits.

Carbon dioxide is the substrate for rubisco, which combines it with RuBP.

Increasing the carbon dioxide concentration (about 0.04% in air) increases the rate until light, temperature or enzyme concentration becomes limiting.

Higher carbon dioxide gives more GP and, if light is plentiful, more triose phosphate.

  1. 1

    More CO₂

    more is fixed by rubisco with RuBP

  2. 2

    More GP

    formed per second

  3. 3

    More triose phosphate

    if enough ATP and reduced NADP are available

Raising carbon dioxide when light is plentiful

What stops more CO₂ increasing the rate?

Temperature and water

Enzymes speed up with temperature, then denature above the optimum; water shortage closes stomata.

Photosynthesis uses enzymes, mostly in the Calvin cycle. As temperature rises towards the optimum, molecules gain kinetic energy, so more enzyme-substrate complexes form per second.

Above the optimum (around 25–35 °C in many plants) enzymes such as rubisco denature, so the rate falls rapidly.

Water is a reactant, but in practice shortage closes stomata, restricting carbon dioxide entry.

510152025303540455024681012xyoptimumRate
Rate against temperature (illustrative): optimum, then denaturing

Why does the rate fall above the optimum temperature?

Agricultural practices

In glasshouses, growers raise light, carbon dioxide, temperature and water, but a raised factor may make the next one limiting.

Growers control limiting factors in glasshouses. Raising one factor may make the next limiting, so the factors work together. Raising carbon dioxide and temperature together can give a greater increase than the sum of the separate effects.

Carbon dioxide enrichment can be done by burning fuel or releasing bottled gas.

246810121410203040506070Light intensityRate (a.u.)Low CO₂Raised CO₂
Illustrative values: raising carbon dioxide lifts the plateau until another factor, such as temperature, becomes limiting.

Practice

  • Supplementary lighting
  • Carbon dioxide enrichment
  • Heating
  • Irrigation

Factor controlled

  • Light intensity and day length
  • Carbon dioxide concentration
  • Temperature
  • Water

Which practice raises carbon dioxide concentration?

Evaluating practices

Convert the gain in yield to income and compare it with the extra cost.

To evaluate a practice, work out the gain in yield, convert it to income, compare it with the extra cost, and state a conclusion, including the factor that is limiting.

Consider whether a cheaper factor gives the larger gain, whether the response is diminishing, and the limits of the data (one crop, one season, short trial). This is a cost-benefit comparison.

  1. 1

    Gain in yield

    from the data

  2. 2

    Income

    convert yield to money

  3. 3

    Extra cost

    of the practice

  4. 4

    Conclusion

    net gain or loss, and the limiting factor

Evaluating a practice

Worked example (illustrative figures)

Heating a glasshouse raises yield by 200 kg, worth £1.50 per kg. The extra heating costs £250. Is it worthwhile?

Extra income is £400 and extra cost £450. What is the conclusion?

Try an exam question

Explain why the rate of photosynthesis stops increasing when light intensity is raised above a certain level.

[3 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Which environmental factor is most likely to be limiting the rate of photosynthesis where the graph has levelled off?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes