Plant-derived antimicrobials and drug testing

Plant-derived antimicrobials and drug testing

Spec 4.11–13 · Edexcel International A Level Biology: Revision notes

Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.

Key facts

  • Bacteria need nutrients, warmth, suitable pH, water and usually oxygen; school cultures are kept at or below 25 to 30 °C.
  • Aseptic technique: sterilise, flame, open lids briefly, tape and invert dishes.
  • In Core Practical 9, a larger clear zone around a plant extract means a stronger antibacterial effect; area = πr².
  • Plants gave digitalis, aspirin and quinine.
  • Modern drugs pass pre-clinical tests then phases 1, 2 and 3; double-blind trials with a placebo remove bias.

Conditions for bacterial growth

Bacteria multiply quickly when they have nutrients, a suitable temperature, pH, water and oxygen.

Bacteria need nutrients (a carbon source such as glucose and a nitrogen source, supplied in nutrient agar or broth), a suitable temperature, pH and water, and oxygen for aerobes.

In school, a culture is grown on sterile agar in a Petri dish with a lid.

Enzymes work faster when warm but denature if too hot. Human pathogens grow best at 37 °C, so school cultures are incubated at 25 °C or below 30 °C to reduce risk.

1020304050600.20.40.60.811.2xy37 °Crelative growth
Illustrative shape only: bacterial growth is fastest at a suitable temperature (about 37 °C for human pathogens) and falls away when it is too cold or too hot.

Needs

  • Nutrients
  • Suitable temperature
  • Suitable pH and water
  • Oxygen (aerobes)

In school

  • Sterile agar in a Petri dish
  • Incubate at 25 °C
  • Not 37 °C

Why are school cultures not incubated at 37 °C?

Aseptic technique

Aseptic technique stops unwanted microbes entering the culture and stops pathogens escaping.

Aseptic technique prevents contamination of the culture and the release of pathogens.

Flame the loop until red hot, then let it cool, and flame the neck of the bottle. Open lids as briefly as possible. Tape the lid with two short strips so oxygen can enter and anaerobic pathogens do not grow, and invert the dish so condensation does not drip onto the agar.

  1. 1

    Disinfect

    the bench and wash hands

  2. 2

    Sterile equipment

    autoclaved equipment and agar

  3. 3

    Flame

    the loop until red hot, then let it cool; flame the neck of the bottle

  4. 4

    Minimise exposure

    open lids briefly, working near a Bunsen flame

  5. 5

    Seal

    tape with two short strips, not all the way round; invert the dish

  6. 6

    Dispose safely

    sterilise or autoclave used cultures before disposal

Aseptic technique

Why is the lid taped with only two short strips?

Core Practical 9: antimicrobial plants

Place discs soaked in plant extracts on a bacterial lawn and compare the clear zones.

A larger clear zone shows a stronger antibacterial effect. Use equal volumes of each extract, a negative control (sterile water or solvent) and a positive control (a known antibiotic). Repeat and take a mean.

Measure the diameter of each clear zone (zone of inhibition) and calculate the area using πr2\pi r^2.

  1. 1

    Lawn

    spread bacteria on sterile nutrient agar using aseptic technique

  2. 2

    Discs

    soak sterile paper discs in equal volumes of plant extracts (garlic or mint) and place on the lawn with sterile forceps

  3. 3

    Controls

    negative: sterile water or solvent; positive: a known antibiotic

  4. 4

    Incubate

    taped, inverted, at 25 °C for 48 hours

  5. 5

    Measure

    diameter of each clear zone, then calculate area using πr²

Method

Worked example

A clear zone has a diameter of 12 mm. Calculate its area.

What does a larger clear zone show?

Plants as sources of medicines

Many plants make protective compounds that are used as drugs, but extracts need testing.

Many plants make compounds that protect them against pests and infection, and some are used in medicine.

Plant extracts must be tested, because the dose is hard to control and some are toxic. Many drugs are made synthetically once the active compound is known.

  1. 1785

    Withering: foxglove

    William Withering describes foxglove (digitalis) for heart conditions.

  2. 1820

    Quinine isolated

    Pelletier and Caventou isolate quinine from cinchona bark.

  3. 1828

    Salicin isolated

    The pain-relieving compound salicin is isolated from willow bark.

  4. 1897

    Aspirin made

    Felix Hoffmann makes aspirin, a modified form of the willow compound.

Compound

Foxglove (Digitalis):
Digitalis
Willow bark:
Salicin, led to aspirin
Garlic:
Allicin
Cinchona bark:
Quinine
Yew:
Taxol

Use

Foxglove (Digitalis):
Heart conditions
Willow bark:
Pain relief
Garlic:
Antimicrobial
Cinchona bark:
Malaria
Yew:
Cancer

Which medicine was developed from willow bark?

From Withering to drug testing

Modern drugs go through pre-clinical tests and three clinical phases, using double-blind placebo-controlled trials.

In 1785 William Withering published results of using foxglove leaves, called digitalis soup, to treat dropsy, adjusting the dose to each patient. His method had no control group, variable dose, no blinding and no earlier safety testing.

Double-blind: neither patients nor doctors know who receives the drug. A placebo is an inactive treatment that looks identical. Together they remove bias.

  1. 1

    Pre-clinical

    tests on cells and animals for toxicity

  2. 2

    Phase 1

    small group of healthy volunteers: safety and dose

  3. 3

    Phase 2

    small group of patients: effectiveness and side effects

  4. 4

    Phase 3

    large group of patients: compared with the existing treatment or a placebo

Modern drug testing

What does double-blind mean?

Try an exam question

Describe how you would investigate the antibacterial properties of garlic extract, including how contamination is avoided.

[5 marks]

That's the notes covered.

Carry on to the next subtopic.

Try a question

Why is the dish incubated at 25 °C rather than at 37 °C?

1 mark, marked against the mark scheme

Revision notes