Evidence for climate change and its causes
Studying this course? Keep your progress in one place.
Key facts
- Carbon dioxide has risen from about 280 ppm before the Industrial Revolution to over 420 ppm; ice cores give the earlier record.
- Peat-bog pollen and tree rings (dendrochronology) give indirect evidence of past climate, each with limitations.
- A correlation does not prove causation; a mechanism and independent evidence are needed.
- The enhanced greenhouse effect comes from human activity increasing greenhouse gases.
- Carbon dioxide can be reduced by using less fossil fuel, planting forests, protecting carbon stores and carbon capture.
Carbon dioxide and temperature records
Direct measurements and ice cores show carbon dioxide rising, and temperature records show about 1.1 °C of warming since 1850.
Direct measurements (Mauna Loa since 1958) show a steady rise from about 315 ppm to over 420 ppm, with a seasonal oscillation caused by northern hemisphere photosynthesis.
For earlier times, air trapped in bubbles in ice cores is analysed. Each year's snow forms a layer, so deeper ice is older. Cores show about 280 ppm before the Industrial Revolution, rising and falling with temperature over hundreds of thousands of years.
Temperature records show a rise of about 1.1 °C since 1850. Independent sources agree.
- 1
Snow falls
traps air as it is compacted into a layer
- 2
Layers build up
deeper ice is older
- 3
Core drilled
a cylinder of ice is removed
- 4
Bubbles analysed
gives CO₂ concentration at that time
Why does deeper ice give an older record?
Pollen in peat bogs
Peat preserves pollen, whose species and proportions in each layer indicate the plants and so the climate at the time.
Peat bogs are waterlogged, acidic and anaerobic, so decay is inhibited and pollen is preserved. Pollen has a tough outer wall, the exine, with a species-specific shape, so grains can be identified.
Samples from each depth of a core are examined; deeper peat is older and can be dated, for example by radiocarbon dating. Different plants tolerate different temperatures, so cold-tolerant pollen suggests a cold climate and oak and hazel a warmer one.
Limitations: pollen blows in from far away, plants differ in pollen production, and soil, grazing and humans also affect vegetation.
- 1
Preserved pollen
anaerobic, acidic peat stops decay
- 2
Identify species
exine shape is species-specific
- 3
Date the layer
deeper is older, e.g. radiocarbon
- 4
Infer climate
from the temperature tolerance of the plants
Why is pollen preserved in peat bogs?
Dendrochronology
Ring width varies with growing conditions, and cross-dating extends the record beyond one tree.
Dendrochronology is the study of annual rings in trees. Each year the cambium adds a ring of xylem. In a warm year with plenty of water, growth is long and productive and the ring is wide; in a cold or dry year it is narrow.
Cross-dating matches ring patterns in a living tree with the outer rings of older wood, and so on back in time.
Limitations: ring width is also affected by rainfall, carbon dioxide, soil nutrients, competition and disease, so results are checked against other evidence.
- 1
Cambium adds a ring each year
a ring of xylem
- 2
Warm, wet year
long growing season, wide ring
- 3
Cold or dry year
short growing season, narrow ring
- 4
Cross-dating
matches ring patterns of living and older wood to extend the record
Warm, wet year
- Long growing season
- Wide ring
Cold or dry year
- Short growing season
- Narrow ring
Give one limitation of using tree rings as evidence of past temperature.
Correlation and causation
A correlation shows variables change together; causation needs a mechanism and independent evidence.
A correlation is a relationship in which two variables change together. A causal relationship means a change in one directly brings about the change in the other.
Correlation does not prove causation: both may be affected by a third factor, it may be chance, or the direction may be unclear.
To show causation, scientists look for a plausible mechanism (carbon dioxide absorbs infrared), consistency across independent data, the cause before the effect, and other explanations ruled out. A statistical test shows strength and chance, but not a mechanism.
- 1
Correlation found
two variables change together
- 2
Plausible mechanism
e.g. carbon dioxide absorbs infrared radiation
- 3
Independent data agree
consistent across different evidence
- 4
Cause comes first, alternatives ruled out
chance and third factors excluded
- 5
Causation supported
a statistical test alone cannot show it
Correlation
- Two variables change together
- Can be due to a third factor or chance
Causation
- One directly causes the change in the other
- Needs a plausible mechanism and ruled-out alternatives
Why does a correlation between CO₂ and temperature not prove causation on its own?
The greenhouse effect and the carbon cycle
Human activity raises greenhouse gases, trapping more infrared; the carbon cycle shows how to cut carbon dioxide.
Sunlight warms the surface, which emits infrared. Greenhouse gases (carbon dioxide, methane, water vapour, nitrous oxide) absorb some and re-radiate it, including back down. This natural greenhouse effect makes life possible. The enhanced effect is caused by anthropogenic activity: burning fossil fuels, deforestation, cattle and rice paddies (methane) and fertilisers (nitrous oxide).
Carbon dioxide is removed by photosynthesis and returned by respiration, decomposition and combustion. To reduce it: use less fossil fuel, plant forests, protect forests and peat, and capture industrial carbon dioxide.
- 1
Sunlight arrives
short wavelengths warm the surface
- 2
Surface emits infrared
longer wavelengths
- 3
Gases absorb
greenhouse gases take up some infrared
- 4
Re-radiated
in all directions, including back down
- 5
Lower atmosphere warms
more gas means more warming
- 1
Atmospheric CO₂
taken up by photosynthesis and dissolving in oceans
- 2
Producers
carbon stored in biomass
- 3
Consumers and decomposers
feeding, then decomposition
- 4
Release
respiration, decomposition and combustion return CO₂
Then back to step 1
Name one human activity that releases methane.
Try an exam question
Explain how human activities have enhanced the greenhouse effect, and suggest two ways of reducing atmospheric carbon dioxide.
[5 marks]
- [1]Burning fossil fuels and deforestation release carbon dioxide (and cattle and rice paddies release methane).
- [1]Greenhouse gases absorb infrared radiation emitted by the Earth's surface.
- [1]They re-radiate it, including back to the surface, so more heat is trapped and the Earth warms.
- [1]Reduction: use less fossil fuel (renewable energy).
- [1]Reduction: afforestation, so more carbon dioxide is taken up by photosynthesis.
That's the notes covered.
Carry on to the next subtopic.
Try a question
Which feature of the ice core allows scientists to measure the carbon dioxide concentration of the atmosphere at the time each layer formed?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme
Which feature of the ice core allows scientists to measure the carbon dioxide concentration of the atmosphere at the time each layer formed?
1 mark, marked against the mark scheme